Why is there such a discrepancy between what the Government advises (weaning at 26 weeks) and what HV's advise (16 weeks)?

[beatie]

I cannot speak for all Health Visitors so perhaps should not generalise so much, but there is certainly that discrepancy between governmental advice and the advice dished out by the 2 HVs at the clinic I attend.

Overheard today:

HV: I see you already have another child so you'll knwo all about weaning.
Mum: Yes, but at that time they said to do it at 4 months and now it has changed to 6 months
HV: Hmmmm. Well, I defy anyone to hold out to 6 months.
Mum: Well,yes, he is quite big
HV: I say to do it at 16 lbs or 16 weeks.... which ever he reaches first

So, now I'm left thinking like I should just not mention that I am holding off until 26 weeks. Why are Health Visitors allowed to keep dishing out their personal opinions? Would we tolerate other health professionals advising against the latest research?

As I tried to say the guide lines are not just for third world countries but, they were brought in to help them and yes water down here is great if you drink it with your teeth shut in order to filter out the limescale and I come from the southwest originally where the water's lovely and I didn't have to replace my kettle so frequently

My HV is actually very good! So just want to say that not all HV's are crap although i have met a few who are.