Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

The tack room

Discuss horse riding and ownership on our Horse forum.

Livery yard issues

14 replies

childandhorsemama · 23/04/2024 13:43

Hi,
I'm looking for open and honest advice please. We have been a customer of a stables where my children have had lessons for 3 years. 10 months ago we purchased a horse, and was offered full livery inc a set number of lessons per week for my children. We then purchased another horse 6 months ago, with exactly the same livery terms, and the same price. So I pay a set amount each month for each horse. In this includes them being fed 3 times per day. Since buying the 2nd, I have actively offered help, and I do some of the shifts for them. Some days I will do the morning shift, and feed, and muck out all of the horses (approx 20). I also, most days muck out over half the horses in an afternoon, when I am there with my children. The new horse has been a little difficult, so the yard owners son has been riding him once a week, as part of the lessons included in the livery. I said I would muck out that day, so as I was helping them in return. On top of this I have been paying for private lessons, for my child to gain confidence on the more difficult horse. I pay this upfront per month. The teacher has said she no longer wants to give the lesson because she does not want to run around with a lunge whip! I completely understand her thoughts on this, so I asked if I could offset the money I had paid for the lessons against the livery next month. This caused serious upset. Apparently I am ungrateful, and i do not respect what they do. my horses have no shelter, and all the other liveries have shelter, and we all pay the same! I have never complained, and there are only 2 of us that really help the yard owner. I regularly help prepare the horses for the lessons, when they are too busy. There have been several occasions where the horses have not had lunch because the yard owner has not prepared the buckets, and the teacher who is up there at the time refuses to prepare them, so they go without. There are many days they are not mucked out in an evening, which is why i took it upon myself to do it when I am there. I do not want my horses in dirt. I was told the price for the liveries would be the same because they would both be fed the same. But the past 3 months they have reduced the smaller horse feed by nearly half. They say he needs to lose weight, and he does not need as much. I have not been offered a reduction, and after the last discussion, I dont dare ask. The arena is hardly free because they have lessons mornings and afternoons so its difficult to be able to use the horses out of school times. The bitchiness and the things I hear said about there customers is horrible. I know they will be saying similar about me, which hurts because I only ever try to help them. I do not have lots of experience but I always want to learn, and am always eager to help in anyway. My children say there lessons are boring because they never learn anything new. My eldest in constantly being put in different classes because they move her around whenever they have space! We cannot plan our lives because there is no set routine. I have spoken to the owner, who said I could go up at 9am, but the arena is then used at 9.30.... Somedays they dont get breakfast until 8.30-9am, so I would be taking them away from their breakfast, and then i would have 2 not happy horses. Overall I feel like I am paying for a service, and I end up not getting what is agreed. I have compared prices and I am not getting it overly cheap. I did wonder if it was because they were under charging their services as to why the service is declining. I went to look at other livery yards, and 1 has offered me it £100 cheaper and including 5 lessons a week each. I only get 2 lessons where we are at the moment. The distance is similar, but my only apprehension is that the horses are stabled. Where they are now they are in a very smalI sand paddock. There is no shade or shelter. Im concerned that moving from being outside to a stable environment would be damaging for the horses. Overall the atmosphere of the other place is super friendly and welcoming. And they were great with the kids. Where we are now, I know everyone, and all the customers talk to me. We are all very friendly. The only problem is the owners, and the teacher. The new place would be kind of starting over again. The girls are very popular where they are, but they are also upset that there horses sometimes go without lunch, and that 1 of them has had there feeds cut in half. Today they have sent a message to all the owners asking if anyone can give lunch. They are obviously not there again to do it. The training of the more green horse is not going well. I need more help, and they are not able to provide it. We have difference of opinions in how it should be done. They wanted me to sign him over to the school for a month so as they could get as many people riding him as possible. But for me, they would only be putting much larger children than mine on him, and I would still have to get him working for my child. Its not that he is bad, but he gets a little over excited in the school, and can canter off, and he can also doze off when he chooses, and refuses to move. The problem, I believe is that my child is still small, so leg length and arm strength is not helping. But because I said No, to the school, I was told there is nothing more they can do to help. I accept this, so I am trying things differently with just us. Overall at the moment the children are unhappy, and I dread going there each day. We go everyday without fail, and we cannot think about not seeing them each day. What would you do???? any advice..... tips???

OP posts:
Crazeland · 23/04/2024 13:50

I’ve never given my horses lunch. They have ad lib forage but other than that just get some chaff with any supplements or meds in. Sounds like you. Are being taken advantage of with the mucking out. Can you go to a DIY yard, do your own horses and employ someone to teach your children?

Luckycloverz · 23/04/2024 13:56

I'd start over and move your horses, reading this there doesn't seem to be enough good reasons to keep them there. Your horses and children will get used to a new better atmosphere & environment soon enough.

JayAlfredPrufrock · 23/04/2024 13:57

Move your horses.

Petrine · 23/04/2024 14:04

You need to move. It sounds badly run and you’re being taken advantage of on every front. I don’t think you’re helping things by doing unpaid work either. You’re obviously keen to learn and be involved but, from what you’ve said, I think they see you as a pushover.

As stated by the previous poster, it isn’t normal for horses to have ‘lunch’… especially not good to give hard feed before working your horse as they can colic. As for the suggestion of using your new horse in the school… the horse will learn nothing and the yard will gain money from using said horse in lessons. The last thing your green horse needs is to used in the school by multiple novice riders.

It is likely that your smaller horse needs less feed as the spring grass is coming through.

Can you go DIY or even allow your horses to live out (with a shelter)? I would strongly suggest you find another yard asap.

You sound like a really conscientious owner - but sadly you are being treated really badly.

Good luck in your search!

childandhorsemama · 23/04/2024 14:17

Hi, sorry i should have clarified. The lunch is hay/grass in a bucket. Where the horses are its on sand, so there is no fresh grass to forage on.

OP posts:
childandhorsemama · 23/04/2024 14:20

Crazeland · 23/04/2024 13:50

I’ve never given my horses lunch. They have ad lib forage but other than that just get some chaff with any supplements or meds in. Sounds like you. Are being taken advantage of with the mucking out. Can you go to a DIY yard, do your own horses and employ someone to teach your children?

There are no DIY yards nearby. We live in spain now, so things are very different. Where we are there is no green grass. I have found another possible stables that offer full livery and lessons that I am going to see on Friday. Its further away, but a small price to pay for all my babies to be happy (horses and children!)Thanks for taking the time to read and reply.

OP posts:
JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 23/04/2024 14:21

You need to move yards it sounds absolutely awfully badly run.

Please please for the welfare of the horses go somewhere with proper turnout. Stabling them part time is fine but they should get time in a decent sized area so they can socialise and roll and stretch their legs. It doesn't have to be on grass all year round but they do need room to run and play.

childandhorsemama · 23/04/2024 14:21

Luckycloverz · 23/04/2024 13:56

I'd start over and move your horses, reading this there doesn't seem to be enough good reasons to keep them there. Your horses and children will get used to a new better atmosphere & environment soon enough.

Thanks. I think you are right.

OP posts:
childandhorsemama · 23/04/2024 14:24

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 23/04/2024 14:21

You need to move yards it sounds absolutely awfully badly run.

Please please for the welfare of the horses go somewhere with proper turnout. Stabling them part time is fine but they should get time in a decent sized area so they can socialise and roll and stretch their legs. It doesn't have to be on grass all year round but they do need room to run and play.

Thanks. What is the minimum turn out time you think they need please?

OP posts:
Petrine · 23/04/2024 14:57

Yes, it would have helped to know that you live in Spain.

My observations of the standard of animal care in Spain is vastly different to that in the UK.

Crazeland · 23/04/2024 17:07

Ah well if you’re in Spain that’s a slightly different matter. My horses live out 24/7 in summer in the UK. The grass gets bald so there’s nothing to graze on really, but they have 24/7 hay and access to shelter at all times. I know some yards round here don’t allow 24/7 so the horses are stabled apart of the day, but I wouldn’t allow mine to live anywhere without at least 8 hours turnout a day,so that they can groom each other and have a good quality of life. Definitely wouldn’t ever let my horse be used for riding lessons by anyone other than my family.

maxelly · 23/04/2024 19:52

100% move. They've been taking the right mickey out of you, have you really been feeding and mucking out 20 stables for them regularly, for free? And then again in the afternoon? That's surely a full time job at this point, yet you're paying them? And they aren't even doing what they've promised you in terms of feeding and lessons etc? Yeah I'd be getting out of there pronto.

Appreciate being in Spain does limit you wrt turnout and different standards apply but I'd want them to spend at least 8-10 hours a day out (may be better off out overnight rather than middle of the day if it gets very hot). I wouldn't expect a particular discount on prices if your horse needs feeding less, in the UK anyway you pay your full livery and it's the same even if your horse is on a diet or not getting hard feed at all, the owner can't do calculating 50p discounts or increases here and there for a half a scoop more or less chaff. But none of your other expectations are remotely off (by UK standards anyway), if they say they feed 4,5,6 times a day that's what they should deliver. If they say you get 6 lessons it's not unreasonable to expect 6 lessons (don't get the thing about the lunge whip, what on earth is your child/pony doing that they need to be chased constantly with a whip?). I think be most assertive in your next yard, agree a realistic package and fair price then hold them to it, don't be offering loads of free labour as they'll come to expect it...

CountryCob · 24/04/2024 12:09

I have an opinion that being on the same Yard as your trainer can lead to a lack of independence and the power dynamics can get a bit off. Is there a pony club or riding club you could join? Or maybe a separate trainer for the pony in training? The yards focus seems to be primarily lessons. I hope you find a way to work it out

Goinggoingone · 25/04/2024 10:02

Where you are sounds awful, given they aren't managing basic care for the horses and you are both paying, and having to do it yourself. No shelter if it gets hot in the summer is also not good. As a PP has said though I would not be moving to anywhere they are stabled full time. Is there anywhere that the horses have access to decent turnout, and shelter? It does sound like you are having to pick between some fairly poor options.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page