Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

The tack room

Discuss horse riding and ownership on our Horse forum.

Loss of a horse

8 replies

Notfeelingtiptop · 28/03/2024 19:59

Hi all,

I'll preface this by saying that it might be upsetting for people who have lost their horses or anyone/animal close to them. I don't want to upset anyone.

I lost my horse in June last year, he was 20 and had pretty much been on borrowed time for about a year, a combination of arthritis (diagnosed at 15, probably confirmation because he certainly didn't have a hard life!) and also early Cushing's which manifested in needing restricted grazing to control laminitis risk.
He was, in all honesty a greedy bugger and managed to destroy many a muzzle and fence in his quest for more grass. He lived out since retiring at 16/7 because he was fast becoming unsound when not medicated and I didn't feel it was fair to bute him up to ride him, and he was stiff and uncomfortable when he came in so I chose him living out and he loved it, having been a bit of a handful at times he relaxed and seemed to be settled.
The only issue was the deteriorating arthritis and recurring laminitis, after one escape he got into the bigger field and he got it really bad, to the point the vet told me to prepare myself because it could go either way but he was in trouble. He was electric fenced into a bare paddock with a field shelter so he could move but not too much and obviously couldn't eat. As soon as he felt better, with pain relief on board, he trashed the fence and was out again, he was then put in the yard, gated in and surrounded by walls to stop him, with straw and mats to soften the concrete. Luckily I was the only livery and the owner a good friend.

He did get devils claw and I also gave Bute if he was more uncomfortable with cold/wet weather etc.

After this episode he became more sensitive towards grass, and he also had structural changes to one of his front feet. He needed to be on restricted grazing for the majority of the time, away from his friends and on bare earth practically with poor quality hay. He would get so frustrated that he'd break out eventually no matter what I did, electric current didn't deter him, and if it was solid it just got rammed until it was small/broken enough to escape from, he used to jump out sometimes when he was younger and had quite a jump, but obviously this ability deteriorated with the arthritis, though that didn't stop him trying sometimes!

He just used to stand with his head down and was quite honestly, miserable until he was frustrated enough to escape again. I didn't want to accept it and maybe I should have made the decision earlier, but one gorgeous summer evening I went to check him and lo & behold the fence was wrecked and he'd been grazing in the big field again, I'd checked him 24 hours before myself and he'd been checked that morning, but he could have been grazing for 12/14 hours by the time i found him.
He could hardly move, his feet were red hot and he was obviously unwell.
The vet attended and there were options - more restrictions though, stabled and small paddock for a couple of hours a day 24/7, medication to help the arthritis - but he would still swell and be stiff, and of course this was just going to make him miserable, and it had to be for the rest of his life. It also may have not got that far because of the structural changes to his front foot and that may be made worse and unrecoverable.
I just looked at him, I had led him to the paddock and re-erected the fence and he just stood, head down, he looked like he'd just given up, like he couldn't take being in that bloody paddock any more.

I took the decision and the vet agreed that it was probably the best course of action, although not necessary at this point for welfare, it might well be if he didn't recover this time or if he did and then escaped yet again and stuffed himself stupid again. And that may well be him down and unable to get up or the foot structure collapsing completely.

I feel horrendously guilty, still, 8 months on. I feel like I played God and took his life away.

And I don't think I have really dealt with the grief. He was my best friend, we had been through a lot together, he was a failed eventer and I was given him, he wasn't really an ideal riding horse because of his attitude but I loved him and that didn't rely on his being ridden. He had trust issues at first but people did often comment on our bond and the fact even when eating etc, his eyes were always on me. We had some real issues when he was younger and I'd almost given him up a couple of times but I ended up with him for 16 years before he died. I had some issues at the time and it was like we were both misfits that somehow fitted together and now I don't fit anywhere without him.

I don't know what I want from this thread, maybe some reassurance that it gets better, a time scale from others who have been through the same? Reassurance I did the right thing? Telling I did the wrong thing to appease my guilt? I just feel lost.

But whether it's because it's starting to show spring and this would be when I'd be doing big grooms and spending more time in general with him, or because I've pushed it away and now it's forced it's way through I don't know, but it suddenly feels very raw again and I am struggling with it.

And I feel ridiculous because he was a horse, not a person and people lose people all the time, that's real grief.

I can't really talk to anyone in real life, maybe I just needed to get it out.

OP posts:
countrygirl99 · 28/03/2024 20:06

I lost a horse to atypical myopathy 10 years ago on 12th April. I blamed myself for being at that yard, for putting him in that field, for not knowing about the risks of sycamore even though it had only just been identified as the cause. I wondered if I'd made the decision to pts too early, if I should have tried harder to save him even though the vet agreed it was the right decision and his heart was failing.
Even now I don't look at Facebook memories for a few days mid April. But it does fade and you do forgive yourself.

snowpo · 28/03/2024 20:32

You poor thing. I honestly think you had no choice, he couldn't be out on the grass and being kept in a little paddock was completely miserable for him.
I would have done the same and absolutely think you did the right thing.
I had my 28yr old PTS as her arthritis was getting worse, legs started swelling in the stable in winter but she hated living out 24/7. I could possibly have kept her going another 6 months/a year but she was getting more uncomfortable.
I do think it's better to have a controlled compassionate end than risking a painful end in an emergency situation when they have deteriorating conditions.
Probably took me 2yrs before I wasn't still missing her a lot, it does gradually get better xx

Bemyclementine · 28/03/2024 20:40

Oh @Notfeelingtiptop I really don't think you did the wrong thing. There's a tiny pony at my yard who had lived in a matted small enclosure in, at best, severe discomfort to, at worst, severe pain, for about 3 years. It's bloody awful to see. It's such a hard decision to make but better that than continued suffering with absolutely no quality of life.

Theyre never "just a horse". I lost my heart horse nearly 9 years ago. I'm still not over it. He was very old and retured, yet managed to have an awful field accident.

Be kind to yourself.

MaintainingBalance · 28/03/2024 20:54

Agree there’s no such thing as ‘just a’ anything when it comes to pets. They’re family members and they bring something totally unique and wonderful to one’s life.

i think it sounds like you did exactly the right thing for him. You loved him enough to let him go when he was no longer enjoying his life as much - what a wonderful and loving thing you did for him.

I banned my old boy’s name being said for a year because it made me cry - and I’m not a crier! And it was another year or so before I could trust myself to talk about him without breaking down ♥️

Tronkmanton · 28/03/2024 21:08

It sounds like you did exactly the right thing for him. But by god it’s tough. Long story but I had to put my 27 year old veteran and my 8 year old eventer down on the same day. Nearly 2 years ago in June. Both had reached the end of the road for very differing reasons and I had to make a very difficult call. But I was able to give them both a very peaceful ending on a beautiful sunny day. I keep my horses at home so I had to keep the curtains shut for a few weeks as I couldn’t bear to look out and not see them. I still think about them every day. Waiting for the vet to come that day was the hardest thing ever as I felt I was playing god.
It does get easier, but it doesn’t go away.
I’ve now got another horse on loan - that has helped. Have you got another one or could you get another one?

Mollyplop999 · 28/03/2024 21:26

You absolutely did the right thing. It's a pity that there aren't more owners like you out there. Would you consider having another horse (not to replace your lovely boy)?

Notfeelingtiptop · 28/03/2024 22:55

Thank you all so much, I really appreciate you sharing your own experiences - I know how hard it is to be reminded. Although now for some reason I want to talk about him, I didn't and shut down any conversation from my friends who asked about it shortly afterwards. And I am so sorry for your losses too. 💐

Logically I know what I did was compassionate and the best thing for him, but the guilt is still there, the 'what if'. He was a real character, and sometimes a real twat if I'm honest 🤣 and the last thing I wanted for him, or he deserved was being uncomfortable, in pain or miserable to what was going to happen at some point anyway, he wasn't going to be an old, old horse, his hocks were quite bad.

I haven't sorted his stuff out, it's all just sat at the bottom of the stairs, my friend who came to be with me still has his head collar he was wearing that night and I still have a bag of tail hair just hanging with his bridle (long since cleaned, oiled & hung up as he retired a few years ago) and I just don't want anything to do with it - he had died when it was cut off and although it doesn't creep me out or anything like that it just doesn't mean to me what I think it should? On the other hand I was always shoving bits of mane and tail that came out while grooming in the box or my pockets when grooming and it came out with the intention of leaving it out for nesting birds, I found some all wrapped round itself in the grooming box when I brought it home from the yard - and that's by my bed. I couldn't get away from him fast enough after he went, again it didn't creep me out, I've seen many animal and humans die and their bodies afterwards and it's not that, I can't explain it, it was all so peaceful and calm and I talked to him until the vet confirmed he was gone, and then i just stared, gave him a quick stroke on the neck and just said thank you and then walked away and didn't look back.

I got home and sat down and looked at my friend and just said "What the fuck just happened?!". After the first week or so I think I just went numb and now I'm not.

It's good to hear that things get easier, but I can't have another, I can't ride anymore due to a hip problem, that started after he retired and it's just too painful physically. I have friends with horses and I do visit sometimes but ........ The passion is gone, I still think they're amazing, beautiful animals and I love the smell, sight & sounds but it's just not the same anymore. I hope that changes because I was still really that pony mad little girl underneath who couldn't believe her luck when she got given this horse, right up to the day he died and I think it died with him.

Thank you so much all of you ❤️

OP posts:
pinkhousesarebest · 01/04/2024 19:00

I don’t have my own horse although I ride and have loved horses all my life. I think you were so courageous to put his happiness before your own and saved him living a twilight life at the end which would have been just endurance. What you describe sounds like the shock of grief now evolving into the next stage. I think you just have to be very kind to yourself and accept that though what happened was totally shit, you fulfilled your contract to him to the end. I am currently caring for a pony who was left to her own devices in the bottom of a field because her owner wouldn’t pay for her to be put down. That is the other side of the coin.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page