I've come to the sad decision that the pony has to go back.
We took the girls for a quiet hack down a bridlepath today.It was a lovely day,skylarks singing,perfect sunny weather.Joshie behaved perfectly with dd1 and we did about 2 miles walking and trotting on the lead rein.Then dd2 got on,she is far less experienced and a tiny 6 year old,which is why dd1 went first.If there were any problems,dd1 had a far better chance of staying on.For the first few minutes,she was fine,then the pony saw sunlight glinting off a car over a mile away,reared up and tried to pull away and bolt.I was yelling for dd2 to hold on,as I had visions of her falling off and him and him accidentally coming down on her.Thank God she hung on and I got him calmed down.She was crying with shock and pain,as he'd hit her on the forehead with his head as he went up
.She's a brave girl though and didn't want to get off,and even managed a trot on the way home.
Dh took the girls home when we got back to the road-I didn't trust the pony on the road with them and was still shaken by the experience.I walked him 3.5 miles in hand on the route we've done every day this week.At least 3 times he span around and tried to bolt,this time it was cyclists and a farmer in a nearby field that spooked him.I've thought about it all afternoon and come to the sad conclusion that he just isn't reliable enough for us.Hacking about on a pony is meant to be fun,not an exercise in testing your nerves and wondering what the problem will be next time.I wouldn't dare risk the dds on him without a lead rein outside of a menage and they are more than capable of riding independently,so it is a step backwards for them [they've never had a lead rein,even as beginners].
I've told Peter,my lovely neighbour of what happened and my decision and he says it is up to me,but that the pony just needs working on and will turn out alright with time.I don't mind work,but I'm not confident that things will change and that we'll be £1k out of pocket with a pony that the dds are scared to ride and we can't sell because of it's problems.Dh says he'll go with whatever I decide,but that he thinks the pony needs time.I said that it is me who'll be dealing with the pony most and I'm not happy with it's safety-sooner a broken heart than a broken neck.I told the dds and dd1 cried,as did I,but as soon as I told them that they'd go back to having riding lessons,dd1 was beaming at the thought of riding her old favourite at the school again.
I've got to ring his owner and arrange his return-she'll be as gutted as we are,she has been lovely every step of the way and thought she'd found a lovely home for him.