Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

The staffroom

Whether you're a permanent teacher, supply teacher or student teacher, you'll find others in the same situation on our Staffroom forum.

Interview with ‘bully’ ex-manager on the panel. WWYD?

3 replies

Gansy · 31/07/2024 20:29

Hi MNetters, some advice please.

Backstory: DH works in education and was made redundant during a restructure from a job he loved and was great at. At that time, instead of redundancy he was offered a ‘similar’ role in the same institution on a trialled basis for a month. It was very different, and coupled with remote pandemic working, it didn’t go well.

Long story short, instead of offering him training and support, his manager handled him out of the position after 3wks, where they tried to create evidence of incapability in quite a malicious way. He was so shocked and hurt by this, as this manager had previously been a peer worker before the restructure, and he thought they had a great professional relationship. So he just chose redundancy and was completely demoralised for months.

Couple of years later, he’s had a few short contracts, but no permanent job. He’s heard on the grapevine that the ex-manager had to go on sick leave due to stress shortly after he left, and has since taken a demotion. DH now wonders if the ex-manager acted out of character because of mental health issues.

Fast forward to today, DH applied for a different job at the institution, and was offered an interview. In the email, it mentioned that this ex-manager (in this demoted role) would be on the interview panel.

DH is concerned about the ex-manager. They will not manage the role, but they may be biased and negatively influence the panel.

The other issue is that DH has been offered an interview for second role in the same institute and while this ex-manager is not on that panel, the same HR people are. DH’s worry is that if he goes to the first interview, and the ex-manager gives poor unbiased feedback in the interview for the first role, this might influence the views of HR, who are also on the panel for the second role. He’s desperate for a secure job.

How would you play this? Any advice would be v much appreciated. Thank you.

OP posts:
good96 · 31/07/2024 22:14

I’d personally be withdrawing my application. I’d not want to be working in that type of environment with people like that!

Look at other roles, there are plenty out there..

Paperthin · 31/07/2024 22:24

If I were him, I would go for it! Don’t let one person put him off.
He has two interviews so they must like the look of his applications/cv etc and likely know his employment history there anyway.

Usually in this type of interview there’s a scoring approach to questions, each candidate being asked the same and the panel rating their answers and whether they meet what they are looking for. So one persons opinion wouldn’t carry much weight ( or it shouldn’t!)

Gansy · 31/07/2024 22:37

Thanks for getting back to me.
I feel like an agree with both of you - you make good points.

It was a terrible place during the restructure. I’m hoping it has settled down. The thing is @good96 we’re a little geographically challenged for commuting and DH getting a job at this particular place would help us manage childcare (nursery is close by).

@Paperthin Part of me feels the same way too, that he should hold his head high and go in with a friendly no hard feelings vibe and just go for it.
I would like to trust the process, but having been on many panels myself, I’ve seen how it can go. I don’t know how much sway this ex manager has.

I wonder if he should minimise the risk of that ex manager interfering and skip the first one, and then just go all in for the second interview with a fresh slate…

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread