Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

The litter tray

Join our community of cat lovers on the Mumsnet Cat forum for kitten advice and help with cat behaviour.

New kitten after losing one - looking for reassurance

15 replies

sunshineoutdoors · 16/12/2024 12:12

Hi,

Id really appreciate some reassurance here as I’m not sure people irl will understand as much as you.

We got a kitten last summer, to be a companion to our much loved existing cat. Unfortunately he got very sick after we’d only had him for four weeks, and despite me taking him to the vets daily for an antibiotic injection and syringe feeding him (and water) for a week he sadly passed away. I was devastated and at the time vowed I couldn’t go through with it again.

A few months later though my existing cat seemed to be lacking a friend. The same reasons I wanted a friend for her were still there and she had started to wake me up earlier and earlier (4.30am the last couple of weeks) just to have some company.

So I chatted with dh and said I felt we should get her another friend. He’s not as bothered as me about having them but he understands how I feel and agreed. He even gave me some money towards him for my birthday present.

I brought him home last night and my husbands reaction was ‘he’s not as cute as (old kittens name)’. Afterwards he saw that it upset me and apologised and said he’d only said it because he was stressed about other things.

Today I’m at home on my own with the two and he’s settling in really well but I can’t stop thinking about what he said and I’m irrationally upset about it. I keep thinking about the old kitten too and feeling so sad that he died. The new kitten is a bit older than a baby (nearly 6 months) and the introductions have gone well - a little bit of hissing but now they’ve been touching noses and playing. The original kitten was more like 13-14 weeks and instantly looked to my existing cat like a mother and they used to curl up together to sleep even from day 1.

I wish my dh had never said anything because now I can’t stop comparing. I think it’s more grief coming out regarding the original kitten and I do love this new one but it’s thrown me a lot that I’m feeling like this. They do have different personalities obviously, this one is less fluffy and cuddly but he’s still absolutely wonderful and sweet, and I was expecting them to be different and never saw him as a replacement but I’m feeling so sad and angry that original kitten never got to grow up with us.

Please can anyone reassure me that’s it’s normal for me to feel like this and that it will pass. I’ve never said this on mumsnet before but please be kind I’m in a bit of a mess right now.

OP posts:
Toddlerteaplease · 16/12/2024 13:59

Completely normal. It absolutely will pass, and you will soon adore the new cat.

Toddlerteaplease · 16/12/2024 13:59

I totally get feeling cheated, that the other cat died so young.

sunshineoutdoors · 16/12/2024 15:12

@Toddlerteaplease thank you so much

OP posts:
WildFigs · 16/12/2024 15:42

Very normal. It's completely natural that getting the new kitten has brought up all your feelings about your old kitten, and also that you don't immediately have the same bond with the new kitten that you did with your old one after caring for him so diligently. Give it some time- I'm sure you'll fall for your new kitten soon but don't try to force yourself. It will happen.

Funkyslippers · 16/12/2024 15:47

I remember when we got our 2 kittens. We were totally mesmerised by them and just sat playing with them & watching them for hours. Then our resident cat made an appearance and I realised just how huge she was compared to the kittens and I thought "oh she's not as cute" because I had the novelty of the 2 little ones. I then felt really guilty for thinking that. Now they're all the same size they're as cute as each other. Sometimes we say things without putting our brain in gear

CollaterlieSistersSister · 16/12/2024 15:58

We had same but with a slight flip. Lost a cute little fluffball of a kitten after only having him for four weeks. Got a new kitten the next day, to keep his littermate company.

As we basically rushed into it, we went with what was available at (same) rescue. We picked a chatty little chap who seemed like fun.

But it was me who remarked that he wasn’t as cute as our poor departed little fluffball. And he wasn’t really - he is shorthair and (was) a bit scrawny. I guess not as aesthetically pleasing. Sounds mean, but just being honest.

But do you know what, he is an absolute belter. Such a lovely personality, and has grown into a loving, strong, funny, handsome chap. I lose count of the amount of times I say “good boy” every day. Easy to say when you’re dealing with cute kittens, but looks aren’t everything!

sunshineoutdoors · 16/12/2024 16:10

Thank you all, I’m still crying on and off today and feel pathetic but honestly these replies have helped me so much. currently playing with new kitten and trying to be kind to myself when I get ‘comparing’ thoughts.

OP posts:
Toddlerteaplease · 16/12/2024 16:57

It took me a while to love Penelope, as she had health issues from the start. And I missed my old girl. But she I came into the bathroom one day and she was sitting in the sink. And that was it!

itsmylife7 · 18/12/2024 19:56

Would you like to share a picture of your new cat so we can all admire the new arrival 😊

SnoopySantaPaws · 18/12/2024 20:08

Erm - where is the cat tax???

id be offended on behalf of the new kitten & take every opportunity to make him feel guilty!!

But if he's objectively correct then I'd just roll my eyes & not give it another thought.

but it sounds likes it has triggered all your feelings about previous wee kitty. Which if you're the poster I'm thinking of, it was devastating ( and probably was, even if you aren't).

it's very hard, but you'll come to love new kitty & gradually triggers of previous kitty will be less painful. You'll get there.

hopefully the cats will be great companions.🤞🏼🤞🏼

sunshineoutdoors · 18/12/2024 22:24

Apologies, I should know the rules by now! Thanks for the kind responses.

New kitten after losing one - looking for reassurance
OP posts:
sunshineoutdoors · 18/12/2024 22:26

It’s very likely it was my thread you’re thinking of but with a different username - I do change quite a bit but this is my go to place when I have cat issues as I know I’ll get great knowledge as well as compassion.

OP posts:
sunshineoutdoors · 18/12/2024 22:30

I chatted with dh more about his comment and he thinks the new arrival also brought up feelings for him about the old kitten and it just came out then he felt bad. He’s a softie with them really. After my day of upset I feel I’m properly bonding with new one now - it must have been a bit more grieving I needed to do.

OP posts:
sunshineoutdoors · 19/12/2024 13:38

I was a bit concerned my cat wasn’t bonding as well with this kitten as the previous one but they’ve chosen to sleep this close together today so that’s making me feel better too

New kitten after losing one - looking for reassurance
OP posts:
poppetandmog · 19/12/2024 13:46

They are both absolutely gorgeous 🥰

New posts on this thread. Refresh page