£50 is reasonable, especially as their breed means they are at a higher risk of certain health issues.
Other insurers are cheaper, however petplan do not increase premiums when you do make a claim, due to the fact that virtually all claims are made more vets accept direct payment from petplan meaning you only have to pay the copay up front. Petplan are also one of the few insurers that cover dentals.
You also need to consider pre-existing conditions. As your cats are ‘older’ any symptoms recorded on their vet record will be considered a pre-existing condition. Some insurers exclude these for the duration of the policy, some just ask the animal to be symptom free for two years.
You also need a lifetime policy rather than a yearly policy, in a life time policy conditions that happen during the policy are covered for the duration of the policy. On a yearly policy when the policy ends after 12 months any conditions/symptoms become pre-existing conditions and won’t be covered on a new policy.
We are with petplan on the £7k lifetime policy, I pay £26 per month for a moggy, in her time she has had two operations, one costing just shy of £4k, she is on regular medication and she has had two dentals. As our vets accept direct payment from petplan I only had to pay the £70 copay rather than paying upfront and getting a refund.
A neighbour is with animal friends, they recently had a claim refused because the dog had previously injured a leg, so essentially anything leg related is now a pre-existing condition.