@Killingoffmyflowersonebyone
Thanks for responding 😊You are right about LGD owners being, in the main, experienced. It is certainly noticeable that breeders are always wary of homing pups with novice owners and rightly so. Clearly you know this - I can't remember if you said you're a vet...but your replies to posts are always spot on.
Not really struggling - no major issues. I've had the same breed for 47 years although it's our first puppy since 2014. We did have 3 together for many years (2f, 1m). They are terrible in adolescence; it's a massive body but still a puppy brain. Because they aren't usually food driven it can be difficult to get them to focus - they are distracted by the slightest thing but that's just their heritage coming out; they have to be aware of what is going on around them. With our girl (5 months) the pulling is now limited to her obsessive need to investigate dogs/people rather than a constant straining at the leash and we know that with Pyreneans they slowly become more aloof to the point where they have little interest in people unless it's someone they know. With regard to pulling towards other dogs it is a pain but is all just part of puppy socialisation and hopefully it will slowly diminish as she matures. Our previous two pups went to puppy class and later ringcraft but with Brie we haven't bothered and are just focussing on numerous short walks.
My question comes more from a behavioural angle than from an actual need for training videos. From hanging out on the puppy survival thread, where they are predominantly gundog people, I'm just getting a different perspective and a renewed interest in dog psychology/behaviour. After seeing Will Atherton's comments (almost annoyance) about Huskies being independent minded I was just curious as to whether any of the top training people have done any work with giant breed dogs but LGD's in particular. It's just in relation to getting inside the LGD mindset and understanding the reasons why they are resistant to any reliable level of recall and why they just switch off from commands because they think they know best. They continually override the handlers decisions because these dogs have worked off their own initiative for hundreds of years so they find it hard to understand why they are being given instructions. But would a trainer necessarily take that into account? A lot just seem to have the attitude of a one-size-fits-all type of training - a dog is a dog is a dog kind of thing.
So basically I just wonder if dog trainers in general are ever willing to acknowledge that certain breeds are not able to be, for want of a better term, reprogrammed, to override their inbred need to do a particular job... It would be interesting to see them work with an Anatolian, Maremma or Komondor and try to really get inside its mind from a handling perspective.
I'm just an armchair dog psychologist really though, nothing more.