@Cavalierchaos my lab puppy always went in her crate for bed at set times, and still does. She’s never once whined or refused, she’s now 8 months old and still does a quick nap in the morning and two longer naps during the day. I don’t know if she sleeps or if she just chills in there but she has her chewies and her other toys. She quite often will stay in there with the door open once I open her crate. I wfh so this has been necessary. She is a very busy little dog and she doesn’t really ‘settle’ during the day unless in the crate. As she is getting older, she’s getting a bit better at taking herself off to the window and just chilling there for a bit so I hope as she continues to mature she’ll have less crate time.
She goes to a dog sitter one day a week and they say she uses their crate, by choice at theirs too.
I’m not an experienced dog owner, this is my first dog, but she is such a happy placid girl and I really don’t think the crate is having a negative impact on her. In contrast, she hated the very expensive and completely wasted pen that we tried, and doesn’t really like to be shut in the kitchen. She gets lots of love and play time and isn’t in the crate as much at weekends. I think you just have to do what works for you all and what is right for your puppy.
picture of her pigeon watching in her favourite spot. (Ignore the Labrador smears all over my windows 🤣)