Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

The doghouse

If you're worried about your pet's health, please speak to a vet or qualified professional.

What dog would you recommend for us?

42 replies

Champagneforeveryone · 19/02/2022 17:00

At the outset I should point out, this is all hypothetical at this point as DDogs 1&2 are middle aged but showing no signs of going anywhere just yet. We've had conversations about our next dog and are aware that if we went for a puppy, we would probably need to be finding a breeder a couple years in advance (depending on breed)

We are experienced owners and over the years have had a variety of different breeds. Mostly lurchers or gun dogs (that worked under the gun) but also Rottweilers and currently a hysterically anxious staffie cross.

Have previously had both puppies and rescues. In my earlier life I worked for a rescue and have had a couple of the really tricky cases that were not suitable for general rehoming. This was enormously rewarding but was prior to DH who we both think would find this level of damage / commitment too daunting. Aside from these, more manageable rescues would be happily considered.

Family would be DH and I and ChampagneCat who is spectacularly indifferent to dogs. DS will be at uni by then but will return in the holidays. I work full time and DH will likely be retired by then, if not will be working a couple days a week. We would be happy to have a dog walker etc if necessary but due to my shifts have never really needed it in the past.

Own house with small, very secure garden (near a road so is cat proof, therefore also dog proof)

Basic criteria would be:

  • not a toy dog. Small terrier types not a problem but pugs, pomeranians etc don't float our boat. Extremely tall (Great Dane for example) would necessitate a new car which I would prefer to avoid
  • not very high energy but happy to go on long walks, in grotty weather etc, but also equally happy to slob about the house. DDog1 is restless in the house and the constant tip tip tip of his paws drives me potty Wink
  • not a breed prone to anxiety. DDog2 is a highly anxious rescue and having managed her many and varied issues for the last few years, I would prefer something a little more chilled if at all possible!
  • not excessive grooming (OES / Afghan hound types) Happy for regular sessions at the dog groomers and at home, but not to that degree!
  • ideally we would like to stick to one dog, having always had multiples. Therefore not a breed that craves other dogs around.

DH has met several fantastic doodle types while at work, but I'm wary as they seem such a cliche now. We do know a fantastic breeder of springer / poodles if we did decide to go down this route. He's also a big fan of scruffy lurchers but ChampagneCat makes this a harder prospect.

I would happily have another Rottweiler, or thinking working lab or golden retriever type.

Basically I think our criteria is too wide and we therefore cannot see the woods for the trees. Obviously at this stage this is all for fun but I would welcome any suggestions Smile

OP posts:
CrackerGal · 19/02/2022 19:39

Pointers are lovely dogs, they make lovely family dogs & are very even tempered, not nervous & are very cuddly. A short haired German or english pointer.

Watchingpeppa12 · 19/02/2022 19:40

I thought rottie immediately when I read your post

Goawayangryman · 19/02/2022 20:53

I guess no breed comes with any guarantees. I grew up with shepherds, collies and whippets (guess the area of the country Grin) and none were really true to type. I've now got a golden retriever who is quite highly strung and high energy. Lovely but not straightforward. I kind of think you'll be alright with whatever dog you go for, you sound.like you've been round the racecourse a.few times ;) may be best to find a dog you know and love and seek out one from their lines.

Susu49 · 19/02/2022 21:34

@Dancingsmile

I'd avoid labradoodles , they can be very anxious and needy. Mine is and everyone I know who has one are too. I think they are a bad mixture and I feel very sorry for mine. He's on alert all the time. I only have to shift position on the settee and he's up pacing by me.
Also true of Cockerpoos! I know of 2 who've needed dog therapy for the severity of their separation anxiety
Frenchfancy · 19/02/2022 21:51

Pointers are lovely dogs but as you say you don't want high energy I think that rules them out. It also rules out setters unless you are planning on getting one that is 6+

Champagneforeveryone · 20/02/2022 12:54

gerbo I originally worked in greyhound / lurcher rescue so have a lot of experience with them. I have had several live successfully with cats so I know it can be done, but I think DH would be unwilling to take the risk as ChampagneCat is his favourite child (not even joking!)

gerbo I've always hankered after a GSP but we never worked on suitable shoots to run a HPR breed. I fear they would be too high energy for us in our current situation sadly.

goawayangryman, such a wonderful turn of phrase, and yes, I have "been around the racecourse a few times"! It's been as long time since I did puppy buying though, and even longer since I actively had to choose a breed and it all feels rather daunting TBH Grin

OP posts:
Champagneforeveryone · 20/02/2022 12:56

Sorry, the comments about pointers were for crackergirl and frenchfancy Blush

OP posts:
GaladrielHiggins · 20/02/2022 13:09

Crufts is on next month, if you can get there you could have a look at the Discover Dogs section and speak to breeders who know their breeds inside out ( and are happy to mention the downsides to their breeds as well as the positives). There are about 150 breeds there.

bluetongue · 21/02/2022 11:39

@GeneLovesJezebel

Poodles can be anxious. I’d say a whippet
I love my whippet and often recommend the breed but OP but wants something happy to walk in any weather and not prone to anxiety.
CrackerGal · 21/02/2022 12:32

@Champagneforeveryone

Sorry, the comments about pointers were for crackergirl and frenchfancy Blush
I don't take my dog on shoots either, in fact my dog is just our family pet. Taken on roughly a 2 hours walking a day & does just fine with that. So I wouldn't necessarily think you have to keep them as hunting dogs. Maybe too high energy if you couldn't do a couple of walks a day or don't have land they can run around on if you can't walk them. Best of luck with finding your dog! Keep us updated when you decide:)
Champagneforeveryone · 21/02/2022 12:38

Wouldn't be able to do this year galadriel, however that's a great idea for next year - thanks!

OP posts:
GaladrielHiggins · 24/02/2022 17:57

I think they also do Discover Dogs in London in November too

Auntieobem · 24/02/2022 18:03

I know you said not high energy but but but.....a boxer. They are the best dogs in the world!

What dog would you recommend for us?
4cats1dog · 24/02/2022 18:14

@trumpisagit

I have a Springer Poodle Cross and she is perfect! Good with cat, loves people and walks. Chilled at home. Also clever/biddable and easy to train, and a good size imo. Have a look at sproodle/Springerpoo groups on Facebook, but I think our dog couldn't be bettered!
I also have a Sproodle. 9 months old, 25kgs and likes both a good walk and a cuddle. Gets on with the cats but is a bit of a chewer on cuddly toys! Love him to bits ❤️
What dog would you recommend for us?
Champagneforeveryone · 24/02/2022 23:49

auntie I actually nearly bought a boxer many years ago. I ended up with a Rottweiler instead which is where my love affair with them started Smile

OP posts:
weaselwords · 25/02/2022 13:08

My sister has had 5 boxers over the years and they’ve been all lovely dogs. A lot more trainable than I was expecting and much less “hair-trigger” than my Weimaraners.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread