Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

The doghouse

If you're worried about your pet's health, please speak to a vet or qualified professional.

Does anyone regret the breed they chose?

104 replies

LostFrog · 21/12/2021 20:03

Asking for a friend Grin

We have a 13 week old springer. Considered beagle (scared off by tales of appalling recall and difficult to train), Labrador (2 horrid barky ones next door and decided too large for us), whippet (my first choice, but had heard horrors of accident proneness and high prey drive and we also have a cat), various others I can’t remember. Chose a springer in the end largely because dh grew up with one, but also because we wanted a dog that would enjoy a good couple of long walks a day, easy to train, not too big.

I keep wondering whether we made a mistake. Don’t get me wrong, we love him, no going back, I just worry that he is quite highly strung - our dog trainer looked at his pedigree and said because there were lots of field trial champions in there on one side we may find that he has a high drive and will be challenging and will need to be kept mentally occupied - so walks without a purpose incorporating lots of sniffy games will make him anxious because he needs to know what he’s doing it for. For some reason this has really worried me that even when we are past the puppy stage we will have a difficult dog. The breeder breeds for pets, not as working dogs, kennel club assured.

Is this just normal puppy blues? Did anyone else not regret getting a dog, just felt that they had picked the wrong type of dog?

OP posts:
stillvicarinatutu · 22/12/2021 00:26

Leon !

I have a long haired German Shepard who I love with all my heart but I would love a Leonburger - been looking at them for 15 years.....where would I look ? I adore them .

StillMedusa · 22/12/2021 01:12

I have a Eurasier. At home, the soppiest, most loving, and well behaved sofa surfer ever.
Let loose... huge prey drive, doesn't like strangers (nervous and doesn't want to be touched) bolshy with some dogs so can be reactive...can be perfect. She gives me metal whiplash!
My next dog will be small enough to tuck under one arm and not scare strangers with her Hound of the Baskervilles bark Grin
But dear Lord I love her, and no one has ever loved me like she does.

I sometimes envy people with 'easy' dogs. But then I know I am her world, and she may be Maria Carey in a hairy coat, but she's also amazing...

Fatarseflanagan09 · 22/12/2021 03:03

I’ve got a whippet, he’s high energy when we take him out and he will chase if he’s off the lead but he mostly sleeps or demands food, he’s a thief as well, he’s very loving though and a bit of a drama queen, he sulks if he’s told off, a bit like a teenager.

Furries · 22/12/2021 04:37

I’m just size-ist when it comes to dogs! So many of the smaller breeds seem to have so much more energy and exercise requirements.

Can’t cope with drool either, much as I blooming love Newfies etc. And, much as I love the look of them, I don’t see a Great Dane as being an easy breed.

Leonberger - all day, every day, for me. My absolute heart dog (RIP). She seriously took up less “space” than the cats. They very rarely bark (let alone whine or bug you for attention). The VERY odd occasion she barked (at a stretch, I’d say 3 times in 9 years out in public) it actually made me jump (not a good look when walking a giant breed!).

Either side of my house, various smaller dogs who constantly bark. Not moaning about that, it’s a trade off I accept re the rest of semi-rural life is ok here. But my girl, mooching about the garden, wasn’t bothered by the fairly constant barking either side.

Am only posting this as I think that, sometimes, people think that smaller is easier re dogs. It’s not!

The most important thing is to understand what your preferred breed has been bred for. Two of my favourites are border collies and greyhounds. I wouldn’t ever get a BC because I know there is no way I could accommodate it’s needs. And I wouldn’t get a greyhound because I love my cats.

13 weeks is a difficult point. You’re kind of over the euphoria of ‘new puppy” and dragging your way through toilet training, teething, biting etc. It’s perfectly normal to be thinking “wtf have I done”. The best thing you can do is to keep things as routine as possible. Which can be hard if you have multiple people in your house. You all need to agree to rules (eg, no point one of you not letting dog on sofa when everyone else lets it happen). Dogs like consistency. So, all agree on your commands (sit, stay, down etc). Do t have one family member saying “sit down” as that’s confusing!

Regular loo breaks - after eating, after exciting play,, after walking. Don’t just open the door and let them out. Go out with them, have a “command’ (mine was “be quick”) and reward them with treats.

It’s mostly about building up a routine. After a whi,e, it becomes so ingrained that neither you nor the dog need to think about it. But it’s all down to positive repetition. Which will take time and patience more on your part than for the dog!

IIt does pay off, but it’s often hard to do when you have the normal everyday rubbish that you have to deal with in life.

One great thing to do, even for just the basics (sit, down, stay, leave) is to introduce hand signals. Once your dog has the verbal commands down pat, pick a hand signal for each of those commands. Start to use that signal each time you say the word - they will soon pick it up (reward them the whole time they’re learning these).

Even if you only learn hand signals for those commands it will be a big help, especially if all family members use the same signals. Dogs respond (and react) to tones. If you, your husband,or kids have had a bad day - your tone of vocal commands will differ. A hand signal is constant - it doesn’t reflect whether you’ve had a good day or are at the end of your tether (in relation to your dog, not if you’ve been cut up on the motorway!)

I obviously had a Leo - I knew from the beginning that she’d be big! I wanted her to have good manners. Having hand signals helped as it’s better than yelling in public spaces. To the point that a few people over the years asked if my dog was deaf - no, it was just easier for her and me that she understood a hand signal rather than me yelling across a field “down”!

Furries · 22/12/2021 04:40

@StillMedusa

I have a Eurasier. At home, the soppiest, most loving, and well behaved sofa surfer ever. Let loose... huge prey drive, doesn't like strangers (nervous and doesn't want to be touched) bolshy with some dogs so can be reactive...can be perfect. She gives me metal whiplash! My next dog will be small enough to tuck under one arm and not scare strangers with her Hound of the Baskervilles bark Grin But dear Lord I love her, and no one has ever loved me like she does.

I sometimes envy people with 'easy' dogs. But then I know I am her world, and she may be Maria Carey in a hairy coat, but she's also amazing...

Mariah Carey in a hairy coat - blooming brilliant description! I hope the diva brings you many more (if demanding) years of happiness.
BiteyShark · 22/12/2021 05:23

I didn't regret the breed but the dog for ages as puppies are hard.

Working cocker here and yes they are nuts but lovely with it. Mine flushes and chases and bounds about like mad in the forest but that's his 'Job'. Find a good gun dog trainer so you understand their breed traits and you will be fine

It's easy to say in hindsight about getting an 'easier' breed but I think once any dog has grown up all the good things tend to outweigh the negative.

Lifeispassingby · 22/12/2021 06:10

We have a working cocker direct from working (deer) parents. My advice would be train train and train. Use their brains up and some. Then teach them to settle, be that bed or in kitchen or whatever but that is a godsend. Treat them like toddlers, give them plenty of exercise and stimulation and rest/sleep!

mrsbitaly · 22/12/2021 06:20

Yes I have an alaskan malamute and we did all the research about shedding but NOTHING prepared us for what it's really like. In the summer there are clumps of hair everywhere I literally cannot wear black as she's white. She's a lovely dog though I just wouldn't get the breed again

tizwozliz · 22/12/2021 07:12

I briefly wondered if I should have got something smaller like a spaniel rather than a lab when we were teaching loose lead walking. She was so strong when pulling, even at 15 weeks, that I thought I might struggle as she got bigger. Having since met several young spaniels I've never been more sure of my decision to get a lab Smile

Totalwasteofpaper · 22/12/2021 07:24

Don't fret!

We had a similar sounding springer when I was a teen.

I second the get a good trainer now advice.
Train train and then after that.. a bit more training.

She was mad as a box of frogs but a dote and we all adored her and sobbed buckets when she died. She was so loving 💔

Also you will find certain games and tasks that go into your routine that give the dog simulation and the day structure too. we did a bit of trial and error to get ours right her witching hour is 4 - 6 pm so entertaining ìs required!

Our yorkie loves puppy casino and sniffing games like dentastick hide and seek, puzzles etc.

Onandoff · 22/12/2021 07:30

They’re hard work at that age op but it will get better and they will be a lovely dog. You probably need a gun dog trainer as I don’t know what yours is on about! Dogs don’t think that deeply. Frequent exercise, games, training, consistency and they will be a lovely dog with time.

I’ve not regretted a breed but know I couldn’t be happy with a yappy breed.

honeyandbutterontoast · 22/12/2021 07:44

A “flat faced” dog.
Thought I knew about the breed and was careful choosing a puppy. But omg the vets bills and worse still the constant worry about all the health issues. Knowing it can never do things like a “normal” dog can. The embarrassment of owning one of those breeds.

But my absolute best buddy in the world, favourite dog I have ever had, makes me laugh every day. So many fabulous characteristics. I wouldn’t ever want another breed of dog but would never get another one and contribute to the problem. Hopefully will win the lottery one day to afford the vets bills for a houseful of rescue ones.

MissyB1 · 22/12/2021 07:49

We have a mini schnauzer, friendliest dog you could ever meet, other dogs adore her. But bloody hell what a diva!! She’s soooo stubborn. Her behaviour exhausts me.

hiredandsqueak · 22/12/2021 07:51

Well we rescued a Lhasa Apso and in many respects she is perfect, small, doesn't shed, gentle, pretty biddable but the barking, I didn't realise how much they would bark. Apparently they were bred to alert royalty to intruders and she takes her role seriously considering any movement on the street a reason to bark. Obviously we love her and she has her home for life but a day without barking occasionally would be great.

Starbonnet123 · 22/12/2021 07:59

We have a Welsh collie and a westie , I find the collie is such hard work , he's absolutely huge,greedy,reactive and neurotic but he's the most lovable dog wants to sit on your knee and would cuddle for hours . He's obedient , easy to recall and very clever but I would never have another large dog .
He has so many good qualities it's such a shame he's a complete arse 😂

Allaboutyou222 · 22/12/2021 08:07

Springers are lovely dogs. Had one growing up. He needed a lot of exercise!

I now have some kind of mongrel. She’s a rescue and just happy to be in a nice home I think. No regrets.

Iheartmysmart · 22/12/2021 08:15

I’ve got a show cocker who I love dearly but I don’t think there has been a single phase of his life that hasn’t been problematic in some way.

A really bitey puppy, completely unruly adolescent, stubborn as hell middle age and now an elderly whinger! I absolutely adore him and will be absolutely devastated when the time comes but bloody hell my life will be so much easier without him.

Random789 · 22/12/2021 08:57

The breed I would NOT buy again? Italian Spinone. He was brilliant with the children when they were tiny. But bloody hell the scaverging and greed! That put me off gun-dog types in general, because rightly or wrongly I associated them with his fecking bulimia.

My next dog was aParson Russell. He did have some problems that were hard to manage - snappy with other dogs and generally mistrustful of people outside of his human family. A nightmare at the vet. But oh how he made up for that in other ways. Clever, highly trainable because he was so motivated by anthing related to his prey drive (like squeaky toys). Very responsive, but not constantly demanding of attention round the house. On the contrary, he needed 'down time' left alone in sunspots or safe little corners.

Now, I have another parson russell, five months old. I'm blithely hoping he will have all of his predecessor's good qualities, and that we will be able to pre-empt his predecessors bad qualities with lots of training and positive experiences. Well, we'll see!

He is a joy so far, and just getting old enough to move further away from me on walks - chasing squirrels, blackbirds, anything His recall is very very good at the moment, but I know that is partly because he is enough of a baby to need to have me close by. I've just started training with the wistle as a failsafe recall, to minimise the stressful experiendces that a poster upthread mentioned, about her partson russell disappearing for hours!

icedcoffees · 22/12/2021 09:07

We have a beagle and he's fantastic as an adult but I definitely threatened to send him to beagle welfare when he was going through his little shit teenage stage Grin

I don't regret him though - he's an amazing dog - excellent with children and very food motivated, lazy in the house and energetic on walks. He's my best friend Smile

Pencilface · 22/12/2021 14:00

Yes I regret getting a whippet! Sweet dog but massive prey drive, wants to kill every cat, can’t go off his lead if there are any other dogs around because he chases them down like prey. Zero recall, untrainable, neurotic, just generally hard work.

Grumpyosaurus · 22/12/2021 18:23

Nope. High-drive gundog breed, very intelligent, lots of prey drive, can be bloody-minded, but intelligent, funny and affectionate.

I work the older one and nothing beats seeing her do what she was bred for.

Tiramesu · 22/12/2021 21:25

I have a staffy as my first ever dog - this is a positive story, as I am so glad with his character and temperament. They can be great dogs.

BurntO · 22/12/2021 21:31

We have a collie and she is…intense Grin she can be so chilled at home but we can’t leave toys lying around cause she won’t ever stop dumping them on us, waiting for them to be thrown and is utterly fixated. Similar on a walk with a ball. Completely obsessed and slightly possessive so we are working on commands that overrule her obsession to an extent. She is a working breed though so none of this is more than we expected but I won’t get a collie next time. I was actually keen on spaniels Grin either a springer or working cocker. Love beagles too

Indoctro · 22/12/2021 21:34

I've had greyhound, lurcher, JRT, boxer and staffies before

We went for a Staffie most recently due to young kids. Absolute perfect breed for us, amazing with the kids and very easily trainable

He is 1 year old and extremely well behaved and I can take him anywhere. A very easy breed I find to deal with, and fit excellent into family life.

I would never have a spaniel/ lab or collie as to me they very much need a job to work in a family environment

Agility, shooting or such like. To just live with a family I think they are bored and Not stimulated so become difficult.

BurntO · 22/12/2021 21:35

@SummerSazz she is beautiful! Always been on my list

Swipe left for the next trending thread