Anyone who thinks that Lucy’s law is going to make a blind bit of difference to the puppy farming industry is naive in the extreme.
The kinds of people who buy from puppy farms, from gumtree or Pets4Homes aren’t the kinds of people who care about what the law says, and given breeding and resale of animals is so incredibly unregulated things will always be as they always have been.
The only things which would make a difference are:
Making it illegal to sell animals for profit, if you’re a reputable breeder then some of your litters will offset the others, there is literally 0 reason why puppies need to be sold for £3000 plus or even £1000, and there is 0 reason for kittens to be sold at all for profit with regards to moggies.
Make the advertising of animals illegal except for on registered breeder’s websites, so if you are planning to breed your animals then you need to register as a breeder with a website to prove it and sell that way. Pets4Homes needs to be shut down and gumtree needs to be legally made to ban the advertising of live animals.
Make it illegal to breed more than two litters in a year per address. So no having 4 or 5 bitches you’re breeding from.
Lucy’s law is so wishy washy that I am wondering how it took ten years to come into effect.
People shouldn’t need telling any more that buying a puppy on the m4 is a bad idea, or that going to a house where there are 14 puppies with a bitch who probably couldn’t produce more than 5/6 likely means that those puppies are not all from that bitch.
People shouldn’t need telling that if you go to a puppy farm and the puppies are in a dreadful state, then buying one is only fuelling the trade which you are supposed to disapprove of.