Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

The doghouse

If you're worried about your pet's health, please speak to a vet or qualified professional.

Lab v spinger

43 replies

superplumb · 01/03/2021 16:51

1st time dog owner - and im very lucky in that I have the chance to get a puppy lab later this year (fingers crossed) or rescue a springer bitch who we think is around 2-3 years old. I have two children aged 5 and 7, happy to walk the dog but not sure which would suit us best. I have concerns about rescuing a dog i know nothing about and have been told to expect to toilet train her, crate train her and teach recall...
or do i go for a well bred puppy and start a clean slate. We've been looking for a dog for the last 2 years so this isnt a decision we have made lightly. thanks for reading.

OP posts:
Einszwei · 04/03/2021 08:19

The lab ...however do not underestimate the amount of training required.

Labradors are fantastic when trained correctly, but you need to train them correctly from the beginning. You will also need to seriously monitor their weight and give them plenty of exercise. The majority of labradors in the UK are overweight...it's depressing to see. They also shed like no tomorrow.

superplumb · 04/03/2021 08:56

Thank you so much everyone. I appreciate the guidance

OP posts:
DogsandBoysmeanMud · 04/03/2021 09:08

@superplumb

Thanks for all your responses. I've been told we can meet the spinger tomorrow but ill meet her logically and not thinking with my heart. I'm definitely leaning towards the lab puppy for reasons mentioned above
Sorry I've only just seen this, I am the expert!! I have one of each and would choose a Labrador every time. dSpringer is 10 and Dlabpup is 11 months. Genuinely the lab is already the calmest!!

Lab is our 2nd lab and so much easier. Walks once a day and is happy the rest of the time. Springer walks once a day, never fully sleeps, always has once eye open waiting for something to happen.

We love the springer dearly but the relationship we all have with our labs is so much closer. I have 2 DS and they adore both

BobsDouble · 04/03/2021 09:25

I’ve had two springers and now two retrievers. I’d never have a springer again, even though I absolutely adored one of my springers and was devastated when he died.

Obviously there are good breeders, but I think there has been two much inbreeding and, more often than not, springers have lots of issues.

My first springer came to me as an older puppy and had lots of aggression issues around food. He was later diagnosed with a version of cocker rage. He would just suddenly get red eyes and start growling to himself and snap and it was very scary! My second was perfect with people and around the house but hated all other digs, which made walking a nightmare.

Labradors/retrievers are such a dream in comparison!

TheVanguardSix · 04/03/2021 09:27

Well, both dogs will require toilet training, recall training, etc. You talk about the springer as if it's hard work, with all the training required. The lab pup isn't coming to you fresh out of the box, ready to go either. The work will be just as hard with the lab pup, OP. No dog is easy street. Being 'well-bred' won't give you a get out jail free card. Wink Training is everything... whether you get a 5 year old kitchen sink mix or a 'well bred' pup.

I would say, either way, you will have to be totally dedicated and you will have your work cut out for you.

We have a lab-vizsla cross, so I can't really comment other than labs are very food-focused.
My dog doesn't have this issue but I've looked after a lot of labs: they are foodies, especially chocolate labs. This is something you'll have to watch because they can, even with training, grab your breakfast off the table, the ice cream out of a child's hand, etc. It's cute and funny in when you see this in films but that behaviour can be relentless and exhausting in everyday, real life. That said, they are lovely dogs and the foodie aspect of them can be worked on, but it can take a while.
Springers are wonderful dogs, high energy, but lovely. I'm partial to both breeds! You know, you'll have to walk either breed for at least- at the very minimum- 1 hour a day. IMO, an hour is not enough. A walked dog is a happy dog. Whether you have a lab or a springer, two hours a day is great. Try and do an hour and a half a day, at least. The lab pup won't be up for long walks until it's older.

With ANY dog, training has to start from the get-go. You have to be consistent and persistent. So whether you go with the lab pup or the springer rescue, you'll- as I said above- have your work cut out for you.
Because of your children's ages, however, I'd go with the pup.
Good luck!

TheTempest · 04/03/2021 09:32

I have a 18month old rescue springer. He’s brilliant, great recall, very well trained and well behaved outside. He’s also an absolutely untireable nut case in doors, and never fully stops even with 2-3 5k walks a day, extensive ongoing training and multiple times a day brain work. I have had many rescue &rehomed to us dogs and he is the hardest work one I’ve ever had. I’d go for the lab personally!

SaifTea · 04/03/2021 09:39

You'd be nuts to take the springer. Let her go to an experienced home. Go for the show lab.

Difficultdora · 05/03/2021 21:57

My first dog, many year ago now, was a springer. Following the springer I’ve had 6 labradors. Enough said!

Iremembertheelderlykoreanlady · 05/03/2021 22:39

Lab. Lab lab lab Grin

muddyford · 21/03/2021 20:14

I am on my second Labrador (nearly fifteen and a half) and I also have a working springer spaniel. I don't think a springer spaniel is a good first dog. They are more sensitive than Labs and are always on a mission, though mine has been wonderfully relaxed in the house and excellent to train. But I don't think I would have managed as well with him without the experience gained from two Labs. I had them all as baby puppies. Realistically I shall be on Lab3 some time in the next year. Gulp.

sillyrubberduck · 24/03/2021 19:14

I have a Springer boy and absolutely adore him. Yes, he is boisterous and excitable but I love this. He is also gentle, cuddling loyal and funny. And very clever and easy to please. Outdoors he is mad in an exciting way but great recall no aggression whatsoever, maybe a bit aloof with other dogs as only interested in his ball or something to fetch. The only negative, on the lead he pulls a lot. Indoors he is calm and relaxed , a pleasure to have around. Please don't dismiss Springers . They are fabulous dogs, child friendly, quick learners, funny and active. Love, love Springer Spaniels.

GappyValley · 24/03/2021 19:17

As the saying goes...

A lab is born half trained
A spaniel dies half trained

sillyrubberduck · 24/03/2021 19:17

Eager to please ! However easy to please is also true Smile

sillyrubberduck · 24/03/2021 19:20

@GappyValley Grin, I would not have it any other way. Smile

Colourmylife1 · 24/03/2021 19:52

@sillyrubberduck your post made me a bit teary. I have a 6 month Springer puppy and you described perfectly all that I love about him!

sillyrubberduck · 24/03/2021 20:05

@Colourmylife1 awww, the fun that lays ahead !! Enjoy your boy ! Not a dull moment with a Springer 😊

Colourmylife1 · 24/03/2021 20:11

@sillyrubberduck Thank you 😊 I do have a few ‘what have I done?’ moments but I wouldn’t change a thing about him

Justcashnosweets · 25/03/2021 08:39

I've had a lab, and currently have a Springer. Both are fantastic breeds, but labs are definitely easier. Springers need a lot of exercise and mental stimulation, even when they are older! Whereas labs become really laid back once they get past the mad puppy phase.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page