This probably won’t be popular because they seem to be a fairly controversial and misunderstood breed but here goes.
I have a ‘proper’ farm bred working border collie.
Not a show line as I don’t agree with show versions of working dogs.
Not an agility/flyball or trial line because I find them neurotic and hyper.
She is loving and likes children.
Soft and gentle with them.
She doesn’t exactly relish shouting screaming kids, what dog does? but she copes well in a family of kids.
I made sure that when looking for a puppy it was reared in a home with children so she’d been well socialised with kids before I got her.
No separation anxiety whatsoever.
I know because I have filmed her before.
I don’t typically leave her alone much as I am a SAHM but I am confident I could leave her hours without issue.
I think she is beautiful and not at all scary but some people do find her intimidating.
She is a decent size and I have had a child scream wolf! Wolf before and people run away from her!
She has emitted a very low, threatening growl at the takeaway man arriving late at night though she doesn’t anymore as she understands now that late night callers bring food.
She has also emitted the same threatening growl at two young drunk men but I don’t actually think she would follow through and protect in a real life situation.
She doesn’t smell but she does shed a lot.
Exercise, she will take as much as I give her.
She is happy to run literally all day but equally she won’t go crazy without a walk.
I only walk her 5 days a week as I don’t want to walk her and deal with 3 kids in tow on the weekends.
She is happy.
I have taught her lots of things but I deliberately keep ‘mental stimulation’ and anything that gets her wound up, even in a good way, ball throwing for example, to a minimum.
Ball throwing is kept as an occasional treat not an everyday walk thing.
I personally believe that if you offer a dog large amounts of exercise plus large amounts of brain work they get overstimulated and anxious and unpleasant. My dog definitely does.
People underestimate the importance of sleep and calmness for dogs I think.
My dogs only big fault is she does not like other dogs and will try to avoid them.
Due to being attacked not a breed thing.
The potential bad things about the breed I would say are:
- high prey drive/very movement reactive/want to herd stuff so you need to take care to teach them to be calm and reliable around cars, children, cyclists, cats etc
- all herding breeds are prone to nervousness so take care to pick from confident parents
- all herding breeds tend to be very sensitive, they can react badly to too stern voices etc