Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

The doghouse

If you're worried about your pet's health, please speak to a vet or qualified professional.

DH says Whippets are shaky and neurotic, is he right?

47 replies

Pegglebot · 14/10/2015 06:22

So after loosing my lovely but bonkers Patterdale terrier to cancer last year DH and I both agreed 'no more terriers'

I've been researching and I love the sound of Whippets but DH is not keen, saying they are shaky,aloof and won't interact with the boys (we have three) He'd rather a Golden Retriever or Lab which are lovely but I'm worried about the exercise requirements and having such a big bouncy dog in the house. Oh and not to mention the shedding!

Can any whippetty experienced people tell me honestly if they are aloof and prone to being neurotic? Our household is very noisy at times and I don't want an overly sensitive dog. I should add my boys are very used to dogs and very gentle with them!
ThanksSmile

OP posts:
bimandbam · 14/10/2015 06:36

Your dp is wrong!

I have a whippet. She is the best dog we have ever had. She is fun, just bonkers enough, absolutely adores the dc especially toddler ds who shares his grub with her. She is very, very loyal and very loving.

She does shake occasionally but only in very stressful situations like the vets or the bath.

The only downsides to whippets is you won't keep them off the furniture and she is a pest for stealing food. But to be fair she spent the first 6 months if her life in kennels with 2 other pups and had to fight for her share of food. But she isn't a fan of actual dog food and far prefers leftover people food.

She isn't yappy or snappy in any way. Is mega fun to walk as the sight of her in full stretch on the field fills you with joy. She will happily chase a ball or stick and is pretty good with other dogs apart from lab sized black ones after an incident with an over exuberant lab pup chased her.

Get your recall spot in though early doors and keep it brushed up as they can apparently ve difficult to train. Her food issues made her a doddle though.

Whippets make fabulous family dogs and are clean in the house, she doesn't really have a doggy smell and a nice short coat. And they don't suffer any inherent health problems. So are cheaper to insure than some breeds.

Pegglebot · 14/10/2015 07:21

Thanks bimandbam your dog sounds lovely, interesting you say about ball chasing as that is one of the things DH was convinced they didn't do.

The health aspect is an important consideration too, one of the things that would worry me about a lab/retriever is the number of inherited health problems they can face.

I just don't know how to persuade DH!

OP posts:
TrionicLettuce · 14/10/2015 10:34

Yup, totally wrong, sorry Pegglebot's DH!!

We've got three and they are fabulous dogs. Sweet, loving, quiet, incredibly cuddly, breathtaking to watch run and endlessly entertaining.

As bimandbam says, keeping them off the furniture isn't really an option and the food thievery (in fact thievery in general) is pretty normal behaviour as well. They've learned to be polite enough whilst people are eating but unattended food? Gone in seconds Grin You soon learn not to leave food where they can pinch it, in our house that also means not leaving food + whippets unsupervised in the kitchen as one of them can and will jump up onto the worktops Hmm

Mine all love playing with toys, both at home and out on walks, and it's absolutely amazing to watch them playing chase with each other. They've all got excellent recall and they go off lead on every walk but it is something that needs to be refreshed constantly, I'd never go out with them and not take some pretty tasty treats just so that coming back is always pretty awesome.

They're really chilled in the house, mine haven't been out yet today and they're currently all draped around the front room fast asleep. I always find there's something incredibly relaxing about being surrounded by snoozing whippets. They're really flexible as far as exercise goes, they'll go all day if you give them the opportunity but equally they're content with a 20 sprint around the field (or even a day off), especially if the weather is bad!!

Mine absolutely refuse to go out in the rain, a light drizzle they'll just about tolerate but if it's raining properly they hate it. They do need clothing for winter, mine have fleece jumpers for going out in winter and when it's really cold they get them layered up to keep them warm.

They're a lot more robust than they look and are very healthy as a breed. Some breeders are now screening for heart murmurs but it's currently a pre-emptive thing in case heart issues do show any signs of becoming a common issue in the future.

Some can be quite sensitive but not to the point of being neurotic. It's less about coping with normal, every day situations and more about how they cope with truly bad experiences. One of mine is what I would consider to be extremely sensitive for a whippet but he's still a great little dog and would have no issue being a pet in a busy family home. He's mostly a perfectly robust little thing just takes a little longer to get over a really horrible experience.

We've no children but they see my niece regularly and they're absolutely fabulous with her. So gentle and really happy to play with her. They also like saying hi to the kids who live on our street and they're always more than happy to get a bit of a fuss from strangers, adults or children, out on walks.

At homes they are so cuddly, it's almost impossible to sit down without a whippet ending up either on your lap or snuggled up against you. They make excellent hot water bottles in winter Grin They're incredibly affectionate, always up for a cuddle, but they're also not necessarily going to trail after you all the time. Mine will if they think something interesting is going to happen but more often than not, especially if they're comfy, they'll stay put listening out for anything exciting. They know the sound of the dog biscuit box being opened or cheese being taken out of the fridge very well and all come running!!

They're bright little dogs and enjoy training if you make it fun for them but they don't need masses of mental stimulation to keep them happy. They are quite good at solving problems, one of mine is getting worrying close to working out how to open doors!! They're also endearingly mischievous and tend to be very silly when they're playing.

I could go on about them endlessly looks like I already have tbh but they are such amazing, funny, sweet and lovely little things.

KoalaDownUnder · 14/10/2015 10:38

Agree with everyone else - whippets are amazing family pets. I have looked after a whippet for a few weeks, and fell totally in love Smile

Pegglebot · 14/10/2015 11:37

Thank you both, TrionicLettuce that's an awesome post, I wish I could show my DH but don't want him to know I'm talking about him ha!

They sound such lovely dogs I'm convinced they would be a good match for us. The recall thing doesn't phase me too much as no dog could be as bad as my Patterdale who could only ever be let off on the beach despite constant attempts to train him.

Hmm I need to find a way to put DH off getting a retriever now!

OP posts:
CMOTDibbler · 14/10/2015 11:49

You could think about a whippety lurcher as well. Alas, there are quite a number born in rescue if getting a puppy is important to you.

My ddog2 is whippetish, born in rescue as his mum was dumped, and whatever else he is makes him a bit sturdier than a pure whippet. He isn't worried by the weather, but doesn't have big exercise requirements, doesn't shed or smell (apart from his regrettable love of fox poo), and folds up very small.

This is him and evilgingercat

NeededANameChangeAnyway · 14/10/2015 11:49

They sounds lovely dogs! Are they a complete no no with cats though? (Sorry to steal your thread Peggle)

NeededANameChangeAnyway · 14/10/2015 11:54

Cross post with CMOT Grin
They appear to be on with cats.....!

brokenvases · 14/10/2015 12:00

Another he is wrong. Owner of a whippet. She's bonkers, will spend all day chasing a ball. Doesn't bark much , not happy. Runs crazy with the kids. Best dog and breed I've ever had. Many of my friends whippets are fine with cats especially I brought up since pups. Ours does chase my Mums rabbit if we aren't careful.

brokenvases · 14/10/2015 12:04

Not yappy sorry.

brokenvases · 14/10/2015 12:06

And yes to food thieves and yes to a dog who will claim the sofa, bed or lie on top of you.

Tokelau · 14/10/2015 12:08

No, he's wrong!

Our whippet (cross) is amazing. We had her from a rescue, so don't really know what happened to her before she was with us. She is sweet and gentle, and is not a food stealer, unless it's on the floor, which is fair enough, I think.

She loves walks, and equally loves sleeping at home, but as others have mentioned, she doesn't like the floor, she needs a comfortable dog bed, or sofa!

She does chase a ball, and will even throw it up in the air herself and then chase it.

She only shakes when she's cold. She does seem to feel the cold, so we always make sure she has a blanket, and we take a towel if she goes in the sea. She absolutely loves lying in the sun.

Last night she lay on DH's lap, with a cat practically on her back, and the cat was kneading its claws into her back.

Pegglebot · 14/10/2015 12:08

He's lovely CMOT, would definatley consider a lurcher.

OP posts:
Pegglebot · 14/10/2015 12:11

Ahh great, looks like this is going in my favour! Thing is if we actually had one I think he would love it...its just trying to change his negative veiw of them. He likes quite in your face dogs like staffys and labs so I think he worries a whippet won't be 'dog' enough for him.

OP posts:
CocoChanel22 · 14/10/2015 12:37

Here's my 7month old whippet! I would also say your DH is wrong. My whippy is very sweet natured, calm and great with my 2 dc who are 2 and 4. He mostly chills out and sleeps at home however when we're out for walkies he does get very over excited to see other dogs and chases anything he can Grin but he's great fun!!

DH says Whippets are shaky and neurotic, is he right?
DH says Whippets are shaky and neurotic, is he right?
CocoChanel22 · 14/10/2015 12:39

Oh and my dp was the same! Didn't want a 'skinny dog' wanted a 'mans dog' ... He now loves our whippy and thinks he awesome Grin... Especially when he's outrunning everything else in the park!

tabulahrasa · 14/10/2015 12:39

I'm going to go against the grain a little bit and say that they can be a bit neurotic and nervous...it's usually down to bad breeding though.

But if you're going down the breeder route, find one with dogs you like and with rescues, just pick one that is confident...it won't be hard to find one that suits you (well DH)

If he likes staffies, you wouldn't have to try too hard to find a staffy/whippet lurcher, bull lurchers are pretty common.

jgm · 14/10/2015 12:47

We have a 6 month old whippet, she's our first dog so don't have anything to compare her to, but she's been a great dog for our family so far!

Like your husband I was led to believe that whippets don't retrieve, but she will happily chase and bring back a ball for ages :-) She's quite bouncy, we have problems with her jumping up other people when she gets over excited, but that seems to be true for all puppies. She is also veeeery lazy however, especially in the mornings, which is fab because I have two young children to get ready for school and the dog just stays in her bed! She loves to be covered up, we have a cosy cave for her that she can crawl into and bury herself under the covers. She also likes sofas, beds etc - definitely not a floor dog!

She is indeed a dreadful thief, she can easily jump onto the kitchen counters, and is obsessed with stealing pens and the children's cuddly toys so we have to be very tidy!

She loves all dogs and humans, so we have had to work really hard on her recall (and its still a work in progress) because tasty treats are no competition for wanting to greet another dog or person (for this reason we only let her off in quiet places at the moment). Nothing seems to phase her, she's not scared of people / dogs / fireworks / the hoover etc etc. The only time she ever barks is at the cats, but that's because they hate her and so tease her constantly ;-)

She was a breeze to housetrain, the only problem is getting her out in the garden when it is raining! And I definitely wouldn't call her aloof! She is very cuddly, and very good with my children, and they absolutely adore her.

Oh and you can buy lots of pjs / onesies / coats - but maybe don't mention that bit to your husband ;-)

Pegglebot · 14/10/2015 14:06

Cocochanel he's lovely, what a handsome boy!

Tabulahrasa We are planning on getting a puppy this time so you make a good point about picking the right breeder, I've really no idea about how to go about that so definitely something to research (once I persuade DH that is...)

Jgm I'd already clocked the coats on eBay and the lovely selection of collars...but yes probably a good idea not to mention that!!Grin

OP posts:
brokenvases · 14/10/2015 14:21

My whippet pup I in your face. She snoozes and relaxes in the house but if she wants your attention she makes it known. Mostly by flopping on top of me Grin

brokenvases · 14/10/2015 14:22

*is

ChairRider4 · 14/10/2015 14:31

I have a lab who while is good is very active and needs lots of mental stimulation on top of the physical stuff so not ideal in some ways if do not want be out in all weather

My next dog would be a whippet

Pegglebot · 14/10/2015 16:13

I do really like labs, I would consider them if we lived somewhere rural with a nice big garden! However that's unlikely to happen.
Personally I think as the lone female in the house I should get the final say!

OP posts:
RandomMess · 14/10/2015 16:22

We have a Parsons Terrier (long legged Jack Russell) I swear they are whippets in disguise as they mimic whippet traits more than JRs. Will play with the ball for hours, adores cuddles, doesn't go out willingly in the wet/cold/wind. Good recall, timid (but she is an abused rescue) completely loyal and such such good fun.

I prefer large "proper" dogs but she is wonderful.

Impossible to keep of the furniture/lap/table and will scavenge any food left around!

brokenvases · 14/10/2015 16:28

You can have my whippet if you like. 12 months old. Just rolled in fox poo...