I have recently become a borrower on BorrowMyDoggy.com and I too had many reservations, so I thought I would give you an overview of my experience.
I separated from my husband 2 years ago and, as part of that, my 2 gorgeous Cavalier Spaniels were re-homed. It was not an easy decision to make, (in fact I was heart-broken), but it was the right thing to do for my dogs. As such, I do not feel that I can get more dogs of my own now that my life is settled again, but I do miss taking a dog for a walk, the interaction with other dog owners and walking places that I wouldn't walk on my own. I only heard of BMD a few weeks ago and was very concerned over whether I felt comfortable with it. I know I certainly would not have been able to let a complete stranger take my dogs out so why should someone trust me?
Anyway, one night I decided to register and see what happened. On Tuesday I received an email update with dogs local to me. I contacted 3 and received a reply from one lady. She has a Springer Spaniel and was looking for someone to give him extra walks as she had recently had an operation on her foot and will be on crutches for 6 weeks and her husband works away from home during the week.
We talked on the phone and agreed I would go round and meet both her and her dog. We spent a couple of hours chatting and decided I would take the dog for a short walk the following day to see how we were together. He walks well and is no problem, so at the weekend I tried him in the car and took him for a longer walk.
So far, it is going well. We are flexible on when I walk him, I can fit in with her hospital appointments. I am still very aware I have responsibility for someone else's family pet but hopefully, this will work well for everyone involved, and I may even have found a new friend, which is a real bonus as I moved 200 miles away after my marriage ended, and I have found making friends a slow process.
I did consider helping at a dog refuge but, I just know I would end up wanting to take them home, which is so not right for me at the moment, so BMD is perfect for my current needs.