Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

The doghouse

If you're worried about your pet's health, please speak to a vet or qualified professional.

Going from one dog to two...

20 replies

Popbiscuit · 21/11/2011 16:57

Anyone have experiences to share? We have three children (9, 6 and 4) and an absolutely fantastic West Highland Terrier. We have so much fun with her that we're very seriously considering getting another dog. I stay at home, so have lots of time for walks and training especially now that the children are all in school.

What is the dynamic like when bringing a puppy into a home with an older dog? Has anyone found that difficult? Is it much more challenging to walk and manage two dogs? (we'd be looking at getting another Westie or a Scottie).

I'd love to hear your thoughts...

TIA

OP posts:
ezzie21 · 21/11/2011 23:07

we upped our dog count at the start of the summer from one to two

our very laid back labrador was joined by a rescue 3 yr old westie

ive never had a small dog before, its been 'educational' Grin

the walking is fine, the synchronised poo'ing at opposite ends of the lead lenght takes a bit of getting use to!

big dog was a bit sulky for a few days, but lots more walks soon perked her up

i have found we are more -if that was possible- dog focused with having two

in the summer we only ate out at places where we could sit outside with the dogs as i didnt want to leave big dog and small bossy dog alone for any lenght of time at first

its been great having two dogs, i have a hot water bottle for both sides of me now Grin

mrswoodentop · 21/11/2011 23:44

Interested in this two as we are wondering about adding to our cocker spaniel,have been wondering about a scottie

gothicangel · 22/11/2011 13:34

i have gone from one to two,

we got our pup nearly two weeks ago,

older dog has been great, but you def need to have enough time to give each dog alone time, trying to train the new one has been a pain with the older dog around she just gets in the way,

but its lovely watching them play together, and pup will be bigger than our older dog when fully grown

good luck xx

Popbiscuit · 22/11/2011 17:08

Thanks for all your replies :) I think we've decided to go for it. We're an absolutely dog-obsessed family and always out walking and exploring so we think another dog will fit in really well. And YY to the "double hot water bottles".

Have any of you found that having an older dog made house-training easier? Does the little one catch on faster?

OP posts:
gothicangel · 22/11/2011 17:55

If im honest, my older dog has helped with the night times ect, we have quite nights and im not worried about leaving pup alone as older dog is there.

i havent noticed it make house-traning easier if anything it has made it worse as my older dog gets in the way when i try and take pup out or praise or treat her,

good luck, im just feeling very down about it all atm :( sorry

xx

mrswoodentop · 22/11/2011 18:43

Gothic can I ask what breeds your dogs are?what age difference have you got ?

Don't be down you spund like you are doing really wellBiscuit

charlearose · 22/11/2011 19:34

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

springlamb · 22/11/2011 20:00

We introduced a female terrier cross pup to our 6.5 yrs Golden Retriever about a month ago. They have gotten along extremely well, though I have to say he is the most laid back dog ever.
Nights were an absolute walkover, no problem at all. Puppy in crate, big dog curled up beside her. During the day they cuddle up together for naps.
Housetraining has been a nightmare this time around. My Golden just seemed to know what to do. We are struggling a bit with this.
Our Golden always wants in with the training as well which complicates things and of course I don't want to be giving him loads of training treats.
Important to give them individual time and supervise feeding times closely as our Golden is very canny about sneaking the pup's food.

mrswoodentop · 22/11/2011 20:02

The house training worries me as our spaniel just seemed to know what to do,it was a cinch really ,I am not sure we would be so lucky second time around

overthemill · 22/11/2011 20:54

we are just thinking about this too - have 3 yr old labradoodle (having lost our old one 3 years ago just before getting this one) and wanting asecond dog for company for him and cos we love dogs. Am looking at a rescue dog but don't want a terrier type (because we have oodles of small 'prey' as pets!) nor being a fan of staffie type (know they are lovely pets sometimes but just not keen). Am thinking rescue doodle or lab/lab x type.. LOVE labradoodle temperament.

Popbiscuit · 22/11/2011 21:12

More great replies! Thanks :) I was wondering about the logistics of using a crate for puppy and how that dynamic would play out. We had great success with crate-training our Westie (who no longer uses it). Not too worried about the feeding-scenario as Popdog is more of a grazer than a wolfer.

Charlearose - I love the sound of your pack Grin

OP posts:
Joolyjoolyjoo · 22/11/2011 21:28

I don't want to be the sole voice of gloom here, but I had 2 dogs, 4 years apart in age. Dog 2 never really took to house-training at all! (she's a beagle, to be fair) and oldboy went in a sulk when she came, although evetually seemed to accept her presence.

The walking was fine, although if both were on the lead (as they were a fair bit!) it could be awkward picking up etc.

Fast forward 12 years, and they seemed to be ok, learned to live together, but in some ways they each hampered the other's life, if I'm honest. Dog 1 loved his big comfy bed, but dog 2 ate it. Then its replacement. So they ended up with a plastic bed Sad Dog 1 got old and incontinent eventually, and dog 2 seemed to get less tolerant of him.

I sadly put dog 1 to sleep a week ago (aged 16.5), and dog 2 seems to never have been happier Sad We have decided to let her be an only dog until the end now.

Having said that, I know lots of 2 dog families when the dogs are the best of friends, so my story is probably an abberation. But I think it does very much depend on the personalities of the individual dogs, and you don't know that until they are together. I thought old boy would love a canine companion, as he always loved other dogs (too much!) when out walking, but he didn't seem to keen on having witchy-dog there constantly. I thought an older dog would help witchy-dog settle in, but they seemed to vie for attention, and she actually seemed less secure. Now, looking back, I feel like I forced them into a kind of arranged-marriage situation!

But that doesn't mean it won't work for YOU, OP. Just that it's not always as straightforward as you might think. As I said, lots of success stories, so chances are it will be great. I miss having 2 dogs. I keep saying "the dogs" and having to correct myself. Sad

Popbiscuit · 22/11/2011 21:41

I'm so sorry about Dog 1, Jooly Sad. What kind of dog was he?

OP posts:
Joolyjoolyjoo · 22/11/2011 23:30

He was a beagle too (you would have thought I would have learned after the first one!)

It was hard to let him go, but had to be done. I brought witchy-dog to see him, and she couldn't have cared less!! Don't get me wrong, I'd secretly (don't tell DH!!) love to have 2 dogs again, but we'll wait and see...

Don't let my tale put you off, per se! lots of dogs live happily in twos. But I've noticed we have a lot more time for witchy-dog now that oldboy has gone, and she does seem happier (little witch- how can she not miss him?!)

PuddinAforeDinner · 23/11/2011 12:17

Well I can't answer your question yet as we don't collect our new addition until mid Dec (pic on profile).

We already have one Springer and wanted another as a companion for him.

These replies are great to read. Thanks Smile

gothicangel · 23/11/2011 14:07

mrswoodentop

my older dog is a cocker spaniel, and she is 4 and my new pup is a border collie x husky (tiny bit husky)

just feeling really poo, tbh.

woke up to just a little poo this morning no wee, and we went out for a few hours and came back to no wee's

took 1st dog on a hour and half walk with out pup,

xx

Popbiscuit · 23/11/2011 17:03

That's exciting, Puddin! Best of Luck to you. Your Springer is lovely.

Sorry you're having a hard time, Gothic. I grew up with a Cocker; they are super dogs too. A border collie-husky cross sounds like a handful but they are both such clever breeds I'm sure you'll have a wonderful dog once he gets the hang of everything. Do you have the time to walk them separately in the meantime? Don't let it get you down...I bet you'll soon be out with both of them running about, letting off steam. It's a bit like having a new baby, isn't it? The arrival of a newborn definitely does have an impact on the routine of the other members of the family but you get into your groove soon enough. Chin up! Smile

OP posts:
mrswoodentop · 23/11/2011 18:08

Gothic our first is a cocker too ,he is so good I wonder if we should rick the boatSad

gothicangel · 23/11/2011 18:14

Popbiscuit i love my cocker and she is a very pamperd pup so i think she is learning she has to share my time, and she loved our 1.5 hr walk today.

cant take pup out for another week, 2nd lot of jabs tomorrow. and until pup can do a proper walk with me and dog1 they will be walked seperatley,

i can make time to do walk them on their own, (i hope lol)

traning the pup is hard, older dog just gets in the way or pines if im alone with the pup, but she will just have to get used to it. going to look at puppy classes asap.

i have a baby too so atm its like having 5 kids (hubby and 2 children plus 2 dogs)

just need to get pup trained she is getting better, i think.

if anyone has any traning tips, i would love them :)

gothicangel · 23/11/2011 18:17

mrswoodentop

my cocker 2 weeks ago was an angel, best behaved dog ever! but since having the pup her manners and doing as she is told has droped, she is still good just not as good, im being firm with her and hoping she goes back to normal,

she was very good out today, didnt need to call her twice and the last few walks i have had to call her twice (before pup i never had too, one call and she was by my feet within seconds)

might just be due to fact she is very spolit and just being a pickle

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread