Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

The doghouse

If you're worried about your pet's health, please speak to a vet or qualified professional.

I need help in selecting a breed of dog?

21 replies

desnatada · 01/11/2011 12:01

I need help on selecting a breed of dog.

Here's the brief. I had a dog as a child which we rescued at a few days old, it was not a pedigree dog. We kept that dog for 16 years and it was part of the family and dearly loved by us all. Whilst it was ultimately my mothers job to look after it, I think I do understand that a dog is for life and I am fully prepared to do 99% of the work to take care of it. The other 1%, hopefully more being delegated to my husband and sons ;)

We are living abroad at the moment. I cannot believe the amount of people who get a dog, then decide it's too much hassle for them to take them home and look for another family for the dog. Because of this we have not taken on a dog in our family.

We are returning to the UK and putting down roots. We will be buying a house in a rural area and plan on having quite a big garden. I will be a SAHM initially, with the hope to working 2 full days or part time during the week.

The type of dog we are looking for will hopefully fit into the following criteria:

  • One that doesn't mind being alone whilst I do the school run, shopping, or work 2 days a week. Obviously, I would not do this whilst the dog was a puppy. Alternatively, I would put the dog with a minder whilst I worked.

*One that likes children. We have 2 very active boys age 2 and 6.

  • I like dogs with personality, although, not aggressive dogs. My friend swears by her retriever, however the fact that her dog sits there all day quietly and she happily tells me that it doesn't bark much does not appeal to me. I do not mind a dog barking and being a bit boisterous. I think that is the normal nature of a dog!

  • I am looking for a dog to keep me company and to make me feel a bit safer when I am home alone. I'd like my dog to be able to kick up a bit of a fuss if someone walks on my property.

  • Something that does not molt till the cows come home!

Any suggestions for a breed/ type of dog that would suit our family? I am not necessarily looking for a pedigree dog.

OP posts:
desnatada · 01/11/2011 12:02

Or even, I need help ion selecting a breed of dog...it's wine o'clock, the grammar is going!

OP posts:
toboldlygo · 01/11/2011 12:07

Staffie. Staffie staffie staffie. Hundreds in rescue who will have been fully assessed with regards to kids, being left for short periods etc. :)

KatharineClifton · 01/11/2011 12:09

It's the dog not the breed really. If you get an adult dog from a rescue then it will of been assessed and you can be matched with one that fits all your requirements. Took me ages to find a suitable dog - looked at all local websites, and Many Tears which isn't so local, and ended up getting a crossbreed from MT who is just perfect for us, and (I hope) are perfect for her).

Good luck with your move!

Rhinestone · 01/11/2011 12:13

Love your dog philosophy! Agree it's the dog, not the breed. Any rescue dog is going to love you to bits.

Maybe you could approach a rescue and offer to foster for them for a while? A good way of trying a dog out first and you will fall in love with it and not be able to give it up before you make a final decision.

AgathaCrusty · 01/11/2011 12:14

Standard Poodle. Fantastic personality. Don't moult, don't need to have the classic 'poodle clip' - ours looks rather like a sheep. Love being involved with children, but almost intuitive in knowing when to be gentle with smaller ones. Really want to be involved with the whole household rather than being a one-person type of dog.

pud1 · 01/11/2011 12:33

I have a boxer and he is lovely. He does not shed too much s he is short haired. He is very gentle and both my dds who are 3 and 2 love him to bits. As long as he gets his he is very chilled in the home but will bark when the door bel goes. It can be a pain when kids are in bed but it is defiantly a detterant. He is quite happy to be left on his own for a few hours

PerryCombover · 01/11/2011 12:35

dachshund all day

MrsZoidberg · 01/11/2011 12:37

Until the last criteria I was going to say German Shepherd! Mind you, they only moult once a year (it just last 365 days Grin)

daisydotandgertie · 01/11/2011 12:42

The only item on your list which is specific to a breed of dog is the mention of moulting. The remaining things will depend on both the character of the dog you have and they way it has been treated/trained.

To help a little think about the adult size of dog you are able to cope with - what will fit in the boot of the car, how much space you have available etc.

Decide how much exercise you will realistically be able to give to a dog.

Is the moulting thing about allergies or hoping (hahaha) to keep down the mess?

Also how much time will you be able to find to put into training a dog. Puppies need a lot of time - really a lot. Adult dogs are not quite as demanding in the main.

Some breeds of dog are easier to train than others - which is something I'd definitely take into account.

A labrador will tick all of your boxes except for no moulting - brilliant dogs IMO.

Don't write off rescue dogs - there are many, many wonderful dogs waiting for a lovely forever home - both in breed specific rescue and generic rescue organisations.

chocolateyclur · 01/11/2011 12:59

Rescued staffie. Definitely.

Elibean · 01/11/2011 13:20

Personality? I'd definitely go for a rescue mutt Smile

The beauty of the internet is that you can start pining for looking at the huge variety of dogs that are out there looking for homes...if you know the area you will be living in, you can pinpoint local rescues (ask here, v experience people can point you in direction of GOOD rescues, with no-kill policies and who will give you all the back-up and support) or you can look at those like Many Tears, who foster out all over the country.

We have a 6 month old labrador/beagle/staffie mixed boy who is all the things you mention. And more!

DogsBestFriend · 01/11/2011 14:48

A dog from a REPUTABLE rescue which homechecks, vaccinates, neuters, offers lifetime support and which will take the dog back even if it's needed in 10 years time and which does these things AS STANDARD, no exceptions.

Ask rescue - they will suggest dogs which they think might suit you. Don't go for a breed, keep an open mind (though to be honest a Staffie is an excellent choice, right down to the limited moulting), as you never know, you may find your ideal dog is a type you'd never have considered.

It's no good you adopting a dog who looks like X - what you want is a dog who BEHAVES in a certain way and has a certain personality and temperament.

KatharineClifton · 01/11/2011 14:50

Looks do help a little though DBF. Small dogs just don't do it for me.

Quick Q - is moulting something which only happens a couple of times a year as my dog isn't leaving hair anywhere.

DooinMeCleanin · 01/11/2011 14:52

TVRD - thoroughly vetted rescue dog. Although I cannot speak highly enough of staffords, lurchers and greys. Try and go in with an open mind. Be honest with the rescue abbout your commitments and how much time you have to commit and what your circumstances are. Let them guide you to the right dog.

topsyturner · 01/11/2011 14:57

MrsZoidberg Grin
I was going along the same route as you till I noticed the amount of fur my GSD has deposited under my kitchen table today !

MrsZoidberg · 01/11/2011 15:40

topsyturner - tell me about it! I have two long haired White ones, plus a husky (I must be mad!) We are selling our house and we sweep 1/2 hr before viewings, and by the time they get here we have a white "carpet" again.

But if the OP wants character, you can't go far wrong with a GSD - I've had 5 and all had very different characters and all great fun - not to mention loyal and cuddly - unlike the Husky!

GrimmaTheNome · 01/11/2011 15:49

If you want a dog which barks but doesn't moult, Perry is correct - specifically standard shorthaired dachs Grin

But really, the others are right - Its Not The Breed Its the Dog, and an adult may be a better bet than a pup.

DogsBestFriend · 01/11/2011 16:07

MrsZoidberg, that's not fair! I only have one long haired white GSD, plus a short haired black & tan GSD, plus a Labrador. The short haired GSD moults FAR more than his long haired white friend.

Agree with you re GSDs, they are perfect - once you've known what they're like it it's hard to view another breed with quite as much affection. :)

Elibean · 01/11/2011 16:17

I used to be a bit scared of GSDs - well, maybe nervous rather than scared - but after reading about them here, getting more dogified generally and meeting the most adorable GSD/Rottweiler cross (who was in foster - but has now been rehomed, and we will miss him on our walks!) I am getting a little Envy of those who have them.

Don't tell Mouse, though Blush

topsyturner · 01/11/2011 16:33

Our GSD is the worlds biggest softy !
He knows thinks he is our third child and is fabulous around our children . Infact I childminded with him in our house for 4 years and never , ever had a problem with him .

He is presently trying to tunnel through our garden to God knows where Grin
And yes , he is a hairy bugger ! (photo of him on my profile)

izzybiz · 01/11/2011 18:34

A rescue Staffie!

Once you have owned a Staff I bet you'll never want any other breed.....Grin

New posts on this thread. Refresh page