Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

SCD 21 #16 : Overmarked, Undermarked, Paddelling Free

1000 replies

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 28/11/2021 15:38

Started because @PolkadotsAndMoonbeams doesn't seem to be around

As you were

Usual Terms And Conditions Apply

OP posts:
BogRollBOGOF · 29/11/2021 07:52

I've enjoyed Tilly in recent weeks as she's found her confidence after a slow start. I suspect she'll have gained a lot from the experience and has dealt well with the dance-offs when she hasn't been the weakest contestant.

What I liked in Dan's dance was that it looked natural. He's not the most polished (quite the reverse!) but the dance was set up to what he could do (which is the reverse situation that Tom encountered last week in that he was put in a support role and outdanced). There is entertainment in what Dan does and his rapport with Nadiya goes a long way.

I think the general issue with Rhys and Nancy is a lack of balance in their styles. They can bounce well together, but slowing it down to nail the technique on the livelier dances is his issue. The ballroom this week was well-timed for him.

I want to see the final of Rose, AJ and John and won't fret about the order of Dan/ Rhys on the way to getting that outcome Grin

I only started watching regularly last year to put something light and sparkly into life.

TheDrsDocMartens · 29/11/2021 08:11

@bonfireheart

I'd be happy if DD13 grows up to be like Tilly.

Also with rich and famous parents , I'm sure it must be tempting to spend your days partying and not having a proper job...rather than going on a dancing show, putting yourself through hours and hours of physical training, having people comment on your weight, allowing yourself to be judged...not easy.

One of Gordon’s other kids has joined the marines so I don’t think he will let them laze about completely.
MaggieFS · 29/11/2021 08:55

Thanks for all of the analysis on available dances and what's been done so far. It's very interesting. I've said it before... I so wish we still only had two per week as it would remove the debate around scoring as it would be easier to compare, but I guess they want that drama.
I've had a similar whinge (on different topics obvs) on the bake off thread. I'm only in my early 40s but I just feel like so much TV isn't for me any more. I just don't need contrived dramatics.

Frezia · 29/11/2021 08:56

I agree Tilly came across very well as a young woman. I wasn't a big fan of her dancing but without doubt she worked very hard and gave her best, and almost certainly did better than I would have.

God help me but if I voted I would've voted for Dan too. I like his attitude and partnership with Nadiya. Their dances are funny without being clownish. He has as much right to be in the competition as any of the other dancers people enjoy watching.

StopGoQuitStart · 29/11/2021 09:37

I liked Tilly. I would have preferred Rhys to have gone (he does seem lovely but I haven’t ‘connected’ with him at all like I have the other remaining ones). However, I do think Rhys had a better dance on the night so it was right he stayed. I think Tilly is very mature in how she handled the dance offs and with her leaving speech. She’s very polite and calm. No drama queen moments no over emoting. Her parents should be proud and if her dad wants to cry let him. I have also found some of the comments on her really off.

Dan is good. He’s actually better than I expected although agree this week it was hard to focus on him and not Nadyia!! I’m sure he is aware she is beautiful it doesn’t mean he has to swoon over her or have a personal attraction to her - those comments were odd also. I also like the way he is handling the criticism and trolling on social media. He should be proud and happy to be in quarter finals he’s there because; per the competition rules, he’s been voted there. It’s not like he’s been pushed in against the rules so why shouldn’t he stay.

I think next week will be very enlightening in terms of the power house 3 and their public votes. AJ has been saved from the bottom but was that a one-off due to public feeling the injustice of low marking or does she have a big public backing. John and Rose seem to be getting the votes. But are those 3 going to pull in enough votes against Dan?! I think Rhys is a safe bet for dance off regardless of judges scores but I wouldn’t like to bet on who would be joining him next week.

As someone said above I fear Rose may have peaked too soon. I haven’t been wowed by any of her dances since the early weeks (with the exception of her amazing couples choice!) and I do think there was a real buzz around her at first in terms of “how amazing she can dance like that when she can’t hear the music”. I mean it IS still amazing but people have likely come to expect her to be amazing regardless of high is a bit of a shame. I’m sure she must still have a big following though and should go to the final.

AJ love love love her. That dance was so hot. I’m not convinced there is anything going on either but they obviously like each other as friends if nothing more. Im sure it will come
out eventually if they are an item but I didn’t find it awkward watching their dance like some have said.

I think this year is so hard to call. I think I am going to focus votes on AJ now (assuming she dances well which I’m she will!) and give at least 2 to her as she really deserves place in final and I’m not 100% she’ll have as big a voting base as Rose (deaf community, Eastenders, generally seems sweet and Gio voters) or John (gay community and Johannes fan base votes) or potentially even Dan (morning tv, nice guy, clearly has a lot of voters and Nadyia is beautiful so sure some vote for that reason!).

For the final AJ is my must have but then I think I’d be okay with any 2 of the other 3 (Rose, John or Dan!) being there with her. And yes I’m shocked myself including Dan there but why not I’ve enjoyed a lot of this dances much more than the Big Threes he can’t get in though that would be quite strange!

StopGoQuitStart · 29/11/2021 09:41

Arrrg for an edit button!! Or for ability to type with less mistakes. Sorry hopefully that is still readable. The scores out bit is suppose to say Dan can’t win though as would be strange but I’m really leaning towards seeing him in the final. I think it would be quite fun.

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 29/11/2021 11:06

Dan and Tilly have personified Kipling’s poem If in this year’s Strictly, I feel.

If you can meet with Triumph and Disaster
And treat those two impostors just the same;
……
Yours is the Earth and everything that’s in it,
And—which is more—you’ll be a Man, my son

After a tongue-lashing from Craig or words of praise from Cynthia, Dan’s ready with the same grin, a perky thumbs up and a thank you.

Similarly, Tilly is adept at bouncing back from disappointment and not investing too much in the prospect of success.

Sometimes it can be more difficult for an early favourite with dance experience - albeit in a different genre - who ends up getting a mixed reception from the judges and audience at home. Such has been the case for Rhys. And who could blame him if he had some hopes and expectations going into the competition?

He is a really good dancer. He excels at Street Dance - and possibly even out-danced Nancy when that was their Couple’s Choice. But judging from demeanour and facial expressions, he has been more velcro than teflon in response to some negative critiques for other dances. (I would be even more crestfallen, I’m sure, so I feel for him.)

While I think the producers have made good choices for partnerships this year - who could imagine Rose with anyone other than Giovanni - I would like to have seen Rhys with someone like Dianne, who could surely be a children’s TV presenter in another life and would be able to bring out Rhys’s latent CBBC zaniness more. And maybe Nancy would have found her inner twinkle more with someone else too.

I’ve just read that Rhys is an ambassador for a children’s mental health charity and I’d like to think he will be able to take all his experiences in the competition forward into that role in a positive way.

Just hope he isn’t haunted too much by Tess’s faux concern!

SoupDragon · 29/11/2021 11:54

I would like to have seen Rhys with someone like Dianne, who could surely be a children’s TV presenter in another life and would be able to bring out Rhys’s latent CBBC zaniness more

I wonder what he would have been like with someone calmer?

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 29/11/2021 11:59

Who would you put him with SoupDragon? Nancy seems quite intense.

MrsDoctorDear · 29/11/2021 12:09

Tilly was lovely but I don't think she was finalist material.

Rhys has improved a lot but he's never going to get the public vote. I felt sorry for him last night realising however much he tries it won't make any difference.

I would like AJ or Rose to win. JJ is carrying John. Dan will be in the final because he's got a lot of public support but I'm hoping he doesn't win.

MrsDoctorDear · 29/11/2021 12:10

I've never got over Chris Hollins🙄

SoupDragon · 29/11/2021 12:17

@OutwiththeOutCrowd

Who would you put him with SoupDragon? Nancy seems quite intense.
I don't know.... maybe Amy would have slowed him down. She's very calm and patient and might have been a good influence in that respect. He's just too frenzied!
OutwiththeOutCrowd · 29/11/2021 12:22

Yes, Amy did well with CBBC presenter Karim, who had that manic jollity too. That could work....

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 29/11/2021 12:24

I was thinking Dianne because she's high energy but also airy and breezy.

IntermittentParps · 29/11/2021 12:35

I was surprised to like Dan's rumba Grin
He wasn't technically great, but he dances with Nadiya so well. I really enjoy watching them.

J&J were hot. Loved the two-men dynamic.
Tilly was OK but clearly not in her comfort zone. She was so game. I liked how quick she was to thank everyone at the end. Unlike some on this thread, I find it very touching how emotional her dad is about watching her.
AJ and Kai were excellent. If she really is a true novice, she is a massive natural talent. Agreed with Craig that they made a dance that could so easily have been bitty seem like one routine. I would only say, it felt more like a showdance to me than a CC.

I love Rose and Giovanni but was underwhelmed this week. She did well but not brilliantly. The weird song choice didn't help. I was worried they might be in the DO and I thought, looking at Giovanni while they waited, he was too.

I have not been a Rhys fan but I'm starting to really feel for him. Craig was HARSH and he seems quite fragile. I agree with pps that the travel and the strain, not to mention the criticism and the frequent DOs, might be getting to him. I thought his waltz was nice; he danced with Nancy more than he has before and he's clearly put in a lot of work.

RemorselessNorsemen · 29/11/2021 12:49

Kai has been a breath of fresh air with his choreography this year. Coupled with AJ's natural ability they are mesmerising.

OverByYer · 29/11/2021 12:53

I thought Rhys had improved this week and deserved to stay.
Tilly was very gracious in defeat and is a real credit to her parents.

SoupDragon · 29/11/2021 13:25

Tilly was very gracious in defeat

That really stood out for me. No over emotional farewell speech or dance, just a sheer joy of having done it at all. She seemed to be smiling and laughing all through her last dance.

Chunkymenrock · 29/11/2021 13:29

@Riverlee

Loving the thread title! Definitely a ten from me!
Even with the spelling mistake?
Elderflower14 · 29/11/2021 13:38

Janette liked Wilf and Alice's video on Twitter!! ♥ ♥ ♥

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 29/11/2021 13:40

Even with the spelling mistake?

In my defence, I rushed it Grin

OP posts:
EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 29/11/2021 13:42

@MrsDoctorDear

I've never got over Chris Hollins🙄
Me neither. I was convinced, right til the end, he wouldn't win, which is why I have already reached acceptance Dan might at this stage, so as to be less annoyed.
OP posts:
PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 29/11/2021 13:50

Thanks for the new thread Eine, I was out yesterday! I like the title too. Grin

I think I probably liked Tilly a bit more than Rhys, but can't really complain about the result. I thought her exit speech was lovely. And when you saw the clips of her dancing from the beginning you could really see how much she's improved — not just in the dancing, but in the 'presenting' the dance.

I hope she does carry on with it — lots of universities have a ballroom society!

LIZS · 29/11/2021 13:51

Nikita kind of risked throwing it away by whipping his shirt off but think they knew it was the end. Tilly looked quite comfortable towards the end of the dance by his flamboyance and suspect the producers would have been unhappy that he got himself tangled the mike wire as a result.

bonfireheart · 29/11/2021 15:58

Jeeee give me Dan as a winner over Ore!!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.