Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Is Rhiannon (Waterloo Road) presented as an offensive , 2D stereotype?

7 replies

HowlingTrap · 23/01/2014 13:10

I have noticed this before , but I was watching it last night and saw a moment which to me seemed too OTT and a 'what a fat girl would do in a bar' moment,
she ends up in the wrong bar and sulkily asks the bar tender for a packet of crisps,...then adds "And a coke ...full fat!!!'

I'm a big girl myself, and been around a lot of other big girls, although i don't think you have to be to get that nobody does that, in a bar having a night out.
It seemed unnecessarily offensive almost like a parody, I'm sure in more than one episode she passes out from like ...5 minutes of P.E or whatever, , and in the episode after Grantly dies the first scene is Audrey looking pitifully in Rhi's direction going "aw Poor Rhiannon she's comfort eating".

And i think one of her early episodes where they wondered why her personality was so abrasive unlikeable, instead of what could have been a good look into what it's like to be growing up in care, give her a good, fleshed out backstory it became about she's defensive about being fat, audrey forces her to go jogging and she passes out. ...

I feel if an Ethnic, LGBT etc teen was made such a stereotypical 2d character people would be more offended and like a sufferer of anorexia would be granted deeper story lines, i do feel as if Rhiannon was almost purely created as a figure to poke fun at. And on a programme about young people, watched by young people in a country which a high level of overweight teens its irresponsible to portray them in such a 2D sense?

AIBU?

I know this is the wrong board lol.

OP posts:
DollyHouse · 23/01/2014 13:46

I think sometimes she is a bit stereotyped, I cringed at that crisps and full fat bit too. She has had some good storylines though. She passes out in PE because she's been starving and cutting herself, not just because she's fat. She also had the sexting storyline. And the bullying storyline. They were handled seriously so not fun poking there.

HowlingTrap · 23/01/2014 14:40

LOL i'm glad its not just me,

Hmm she just seems to have less depth than other characters , to me anyway maybe i'm wrong.

What happened to her bf, the asian lad?

OP posts:
TheOriginalSteamingNit · 23/01/2014 14:48

Yeah, she is - but I'm not sure who she has less depth than! Grin
Sonia the silly typist? Mrs Losely, the silly science teacher? Mrs Mulgrew, the alcoholic who now only occasionally thinks of wine, before eating cupcakes instead? Umugun, the perennial sixth former whose third degree burns seem to have vanished - or her boyfriend, the arsonist and girlfriend-burner who now just wants to bake cakes (no creme brulee, please, Conor!)?

I mean, I could go on..... Grin

DollyHouse · 23/01/2014 14:52

Best character summary ever Grin

I'm having a blank moment now! Did she have a bf?! Where was I?!

HowlingTrap · 23/01/2014 17:06

You mean the rich display of class acting Original? Grin

yeah dolly for like one episode.

OP posts:
mrsjay · 23/01/2014 21:47

she has low self esteem doesn't she and she comfort eats so I guess she is sterotyped as the fat girl she plays a rubbish drunk though but she is 16/17 and easily led lots of girls like her out there

and seriously would she really want to be friends with miss violet boudigaurd (sp) anyway she is a bitch surely they all see her but she is going to be barry barrys bit of stuff soon anyway

GW297 · 23/01/2014 22:49

That is the best character summary ever!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread