Best Amazon Prime Day deals: Mumsnet favourites

Best Amazon Prime Day deals:
Mumsnet favourites

Shop now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Mitchell and Webb. It won't do.

31 replies

maktaitai · 21/07/2010 13:37

More of a general BBC comedy rant, really.

Even if you take as read, which I don't, that all-male Oxbridge acts are the best source of sketch comedy, haven't you lot at the BBC noticed that 2 front men is not enough competition to produce a funny result unless the 2 front people are incredibly experienced performers, as in the Morecambe and Wise/post-war generation?

Without the pressure cooker development of all that live work, you need at least 4 front people to get enough of a competitive atmostphere going to chuck out the unfunny stuff. Viz Monty P, Not the 9, Mary Whitehouse, Goodness Gracious, League of Gentlemen. Compare and contrast with French and Saunders, Smith and Jones, Fry and Laurie, Armstrong and Miller, Hudson and Pepperdine, Mitchell and Webb, etc etc. The most recent M&W is full of extremely tired stuff that needed to be CHUCKED for the new series, plus, God help us, a sketch called 'Sketches We Couldn't be Bothered To Write'.

Perhaps you could establish a regular slot, say 11pm on a Monday or something, called The 30-Minute Revue, basic stage and live audience only, and send all the Oxbridge double acts to fight it out in a comedy bear pit so that what survives is ACTUALLY FUNNY.

OP posts:
EightiesChick · 21/07/2010 17:02

SanctiMoanyArse

True. I have friends for whom the Sir Digby was their favourite sketch, and it's never done anything for me. Yet DH and I cried with laughter at the Sky Sports one. Ah well, it'd be a dull world if we were all the same..

I also agree that last week's was better - the parents with the new baby sketch made DH and I howl last week but this week it didn't have the same impact. They may be best not to persist with that one IMO, it's probably best as a one off.

The DM cunnilingus sketch did seem like a deliberate ploy and a repositioning of him, compared to RW as the ladies' man previously. Maybe he got fed up with playing the cerebral one all the time...

edam · 21/07/2010 17:13

I think the worst offenders for churning out stuff they think the plebs will like while not actually watching much TV themselves are people like Bazalguette in light ent, tbh.

Agree Oxbridge comedy has a big hold on the Beeb though.

winstonstimpson · 21/07/2010 21:02

I liked lead balloon. Especially the au pair and the American man. Oh and the wife and kids. Actually Jack Dee was my least favourite character (tho that may have been the point)

Love Peep Show tho think a lot of M&W is poor. Did like the Laboratoire Garnier and the Didlidldedee (or whatever) sketches. Octopus shaped sweets with added glitter.... tee hee.

Am R4 fan so a lot of that clever men sarcastic humour appeals. Like David Mitchell on The Honest Truth and quite like him on Would I lie to you (on tv).

secunda · 21/07/2010 21:03

It is shit. Peep Show was excellent, but they didn't write that...

winstonstimpson · 21/07/2010 21:11

the unbelievable truth in fact I think

Fibilou · 24/07/2010 22:35

winston, I also prefer them on r4 - I find a lot of the current crop of comics far funnier on radio - take Milton Jones for example. I like his R4 show - possibly because I can't actually see him

And the M&W show has one massive thing in their favour - Russell sodding Howard does not appear in it.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread