Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Teenagers

Parenting teenagers has its ups and downs. Get advice from Mumsnetters here.

Teen and overly controlling parents.

32 replies

EdenFlower · 10/10/2021 11:40

I am worried about a 16 year old I know and wondered if I should do something to intervene. Her parents are very controlling to the point that I think it's damaged her mental health, especially as they have been like this throughout her whole childhood.

They are very pushy academically and expect high results from her. She has spent a lot of her childhood doing extra school-work and practising to pass exams. The mum is also overly involved in everything she does, interfering at her school, intervening in friendships and generally creating lots of angst around eating and health, always taking her to the doctor and giving her 'remedies' and vitamins for everything which in my eyes seems unnecessary. The mum seems to have either a personality disorder or anxiety herself. The girl was never allowed to sleepovers or friends houses, or to play out with friends or go to play gyms as a child. She has had very little independence or autonomy in her life. Even at home she was always under constant close supervision. She was prevented from going on school trips and days out with friends- the excuses usually being financial or health related and certainly never allowed to take risks like going on theme-park rides, climbing frames, getting dirty etc. - even swimming and bike riding were limited due to mums perception of how risky it was.

She is now struggling with what appears to be anxiety issues, although the mum says her symptoms are all due to health conditions. I am dubious. She has a boyfriend she met online- he lives locally. He is not allowed to her house or her his, she is not trusted to be left alone at home so has to go everywhere with her parents, she has to do all her studying in the family kitchen because they don't trust her to work independently, They constantly monitor her social media, removing all her devices each night at bedtime. She is never able to go out with friends independently unless they drop her off and pick her up at very specific times and places. She seems to struggle to make friends in general. She is beginning to think about university and it looks like she will have to stay locally and live at home even though this is not what she wants- financial reasons are the excuse, although I think it's more about keeping control. The dad has a good middle-class income and the mum doesn't work- she spends a lot of money on designer clothes but then cries poverty.

I don't know if I should just keep my nose out. I try to offer parenting advice to the mum when she is being a bit unreasonable with her poor dd, but it doesn't really help her. I feel so sorry for her when I look at the life experiences and fun my own dd has compared to hers.

WWYD?

OP posts:
heretohelpGB · 11/10/2021 10:28

What got me out of similar situation was finding a uni course that could not be done locally (obviously a good one that knew parents would approve of). Some members of family stayed and went to local college and genuinely believe never fully recovered. I had a tough time as left home with zero coping skills but pulled it together and a happy middle aged woman now with LC with mum.
Please subtly advise child to consider the benefits of leaving for uni and give her ideas of what could make that happen.

Craftycorvid · 11/10/2021 10:31

All I can suggest is that you find subtle ways to let the girl know you are supportive of her. Is there a way the parents might be persuaded to allow her time on her own with you for even some ostensibly practical reason? A lift to some activity etc? If you could get time on your own, I would suggest not diving in with your concerns but just showing a warm interest in her. It certainly sounds like an unhealthy environment in which to grow up. My mum was over-protective but not to that extent, though I had my battles when I became a young adult because she saw attempts at independence as betrayal (never said so directly but made a scene over my having a boyfriend, for example). I think the best thing for a young person on the cusp of adulthood is gently encouraging them to use resources outside the family. She clearly has the ability to say no if the story about the ‘tantrum’ is an accurate account, so that’s encouraging.

LaetitiaASD · 11/10/2021 11:01

@Butterfly44

Yes keep nose out. This is a very common way to bring up children particularly in certain cultures.
That response makes me sad.
EdenFlower · 11/10/2021 17:22

Thanks for the advice everyone- I wouldn't normally see the dd alone- but maybe I can subtly hint to her about choosing a course that can't be studied locally when I get a chance- although it will be tricky for her because there is a large Russell group university nearby!

OP posts:
lockdownmadnessdotcom · 11/10/2021 17:54

@EdenFlower

Thanks for the advice everyone- I wouldn't normally see the dd alone- but maybe I can subtly hint to her about choosing a course that can't be studied locally when I get a chance- although it will be tricky for her because there is a large Russell group university nearby!
She's have to be offered a place there though. The best thing would be if she wasn't offered a place there but was offered one maybe an hour away - enough to be away from the parents but not so far that they will object too much, hopefully.
Caramellatteplease · 11/10/2021 17:59

I too picked up on the brief mention of a health condition and I wonder if it is more significant than you credit it with being

EdenFlower · 11/10/2021 18:21

I actually think the health conditions are used as another way of controlling her- they are not really health conditions as such- mum has issues around food and the dd had a food intolerance as a baby- she has no epipen or anything like that so it's minor- but mum uses it as an excuse for her not to eat out or go on trips with school. There is a lot of anxiety from the mum about hygiene and food in general.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread