Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Teenagers

Parenting teenagers has its ups and downs. Get advice from Mumsnetters here.

DS1 thinks DS2 gets away with everything

31 replies

MegBusset · 14/06/2021 12:55

Sure this is fairly standard teenage stuff but I'm still fairly new to the teen years so could use some perspective!

DS1 and DS2 are 14 and 12, get along well enough most of the time, like most brothers know exactly how to wind each other up. Are well behaved and generally lovely, and no SN. They do have spats but nothing out of the ordinary that I've noticed and can each give as good as they get.

DS1 has always been super sensitive especially to anything that he perceives as an injustice. His injustice scales are very finely tuned especially when it comes to DS2! In his ideal world I would intervene in every minor sibling annoyance or squabble.

DS2 OTOH is much more laid back and quick to forget squabbles. (Admittedly not a teen yet so this may change!) Can be annoying and does know exactly how to push DS1's buttons.

Example: over the weekend we have some friends over and DSes are on the Switch with other kids. An argument breaks out because DS1 wants to play a game in a serious way and DS2 is just messing about with it in an annoying way.

I come in and suggest that they find a different game to play that everyone can enjoy. DS1 and DS2 again start squabbling about the first game. I say (a bit more firmly) that with guests in the house we are not going to argue over a game and to find something different to play.

DS1 stomps off for the rest of the afternoon and at bedtime is still very upset, tears etc because in his opinion I let DS2 get away with 'spoiling the game', "he always does this" etc. Why should he get away with it with no punishment.

I try to explain to him that actually it was one minor squabble after they'd been playing nicely for ages, which they usually do, and that perhaps it is better to focus on the positive times he has with his brother rather than store up a list of grudges? But find myself having to justify why I didn't bawl DS2 out in front of a room full of guests.

DS2 meanwhile has forgotten the whole thing and gone happily to bed!

So not quite sure if I handled this right or could have done something different. I have Read How To Talk etc and generally try to listen to all their woes but was I bu to expect them to sort this out without all the drama?

OP posts:
CorianderBee · 14/06/2021 15:58

My older sibling always says I was treated better than her but in reality I was just less of a drama Queen so a minor telling off didn't turn into a big deal like it always did with her.

Remind him people are different and that even though he thinks he's always right he isn't.

TeanupFlutter · 14/06/2021 16:56

Good points made above especially Temp023, I'm using that from now on!

Resilience lesson for DS1 to learn that these things happen and sometimes you have to suck it up. Though DS2 should also be learning how to play alongside others and consider their feelings and how others play. I would have told DS2 to pack it in and do something else in those circs.

Mine are similar ages but wouldn't play together with friends like that, its quite a gap in maturity.

In regard to DS1 I'd say that if he is quite serious and fair minded and lots of perceived unfairnesses are dismissed this can build up to overreaction to even minor unfairness. Yes life's not fair but in a family it should be as fair as possible imo. My DS1 is similar and I find that dealing with unfairness he encounters properly or discussing why his perception of unfairness might be inaccurate helps a lot rather than just dismissing him and expecting him to suck it up. Also that I'm not a perfect arbitrator and sometimes will get things wrong or make the wrong call, also a good life lesson.

BarbarianMum · 16/06/2021 22:24

Maybe ds2 is more laisse faire because he gets his own way more? Certainly lots of little pinpricks of unfairness tends to make you more sensitive, not less.

cupsofcoffee · 17/06/2021 14:54

I'm also on DS1's side.

If DS2 is being annoying he needs to be pulled up on it (whether you have guests over or not), and him being annoying shouldn't mean that DS1 can't play the game - that's unfair and I can see why DS1 got upset, tbh.

If one of them is being annoying or winding the other up, they should be called out on it, but the punishment/consequence shouldn't have a negative impact on the other DS.

WeAllHaveWings · 18/06/2021 22:37

Another one on ds1's side, if he has hit puberty he will be growing fast and his individual needs have to be catered for as he matures. I have a younger sister and can still remember the frustration of being treated the same.

Clickbait · 19/06/2021 07:09

I don't think you did anything wrong here OP. DS1 needs to understand that, when there are guests present, making sure the guests feel happy and comfortable is more important than you refereeing the ins and outs of a little sibling argument.

(Hmmm. I'm the laid back second child with the intense older sibling. It's possible this has affected my answer!)

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread