Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Teenagers

Parenting teenagers has its ups and downs. Get advice from Mumsnetters here.

Guardian teenager weekly article

29 replies

1357 · 01/09/2007 21:17

am i alone in thinking this mother needs a shake-up? Why does she come over as such a walkover and why allow the swearing. am i being naive?

OP posts:
Weegle · 01/09/2007 21:24

oooh, she does my head in. This week's is particularly nauseating.

cat64 · 01/09/2007 21:26

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

1357 · 01/09/2007 21:30

Here is this weeks article
www.guardian.co.uk/family/story/0,,2158370,00.html

OP posts:
yogabird · 01/09/2007 21:33

i can't bear it, some weeks i don't read it at all. I can't accept that that's what i have ahead of me. The swearing is vile, the petty theft too. Her children treat her with contempt most of the time and it makes me feel horrible reading it. Not even smug that i think that we just won't be going there - or is that really tempting fate??

THe rest of that bit of the paper is fab though, especially the recipes with stories attached

1357 · 01/09/2007 21:36

well my DS is 14 and we've had odd moments but i think they need boundaries. sometimes he reads the guardian article and says'she's stupid'.howver i guess its largely made up-hope so.
rest of the paper is excellent-i agree

OP posts:
tyeanddye · 11/09/2007 21:14

I love the teenager article,its very true,mine dont steal,but dear god im afraid its so true!!!!i have boundaries,rules etc,but when they are BIGGER than you,and shout louder,it gets difficult.

julesrose · 06/10/2007 18:26

I was just about to post about this when I saw this thread- my dd is 4 so was thinking is this what lies ahead? It's unreal - I mean 'get out of my life you fing c*t'. Surely this mother is insane putting up with that - how's her darling boy going to treat the other women in his life?

Sazisi · 06/10/2007 18:30

Mm, her kids do come acroos as total shit-bags, butu OI always thought it was tongue in cheek?

themoon66 · 06/10/2007 18:35

Its very OTT. Mine have their moments, but they would never dare to utter the 'F' word in earshot of their parents.

Amethyst8 · 06/10/2007 20:39

I don t have teenagers yet but I think I would be heart broken if one of mine called me a silly f*ing c**t when I was trying to help him. Do teenagers really speak to their parents like this? Is this what I have to look forward to?

Freckle · 06/10/2007 20:49

I have one teenager and two nearly-theres.

If any of them used that sort of language within my earshot, let alone directed at me, they wouldn't know what had hit them. And they jolly well know it.

I think the article is less "let's help you get through the teenage years" than "let's make the teenage years appear as bloody awful as we can".

More a warning than an education.

seeker · 06/10/2007 21:04

I've posted about this before. Surely it's not typical - and surely you shoulcn't let them talk to you like that? Or can't you stop them?My dd is 11, and I can't imagine letting her use language like that in our home. I don't even allow 'shut up" Maybe I'm in for a rude awakening!

renaldo · 06/10/2007 21:15

I hate this column but have to read it every week! Please tell me my DCs will not be like this in a few years time, they are such an unhappy family with no respect for each other. It is sooo the mothers fauls shhe is desperate for the teenager's approval and cannot parent them

seeker · 07/10/2007 07:07

It's not real, is it? I feel like writing an alternative version where a happy family has a nice time together. It's a bit like all that talk last week about Tracy Beaker reflecting what life is really like for children these days. Not my children's it doesnt! And I suspect that life for children in care isn't much like that either.

Oenophile · 07/10/2007 07:19

Renaldo, no, the likelihood is your DCs will NOT be like this - I do recognise some faint patterns of typical teenageriness in her horrific and saddening accounts, but I never met anyone who had teenagers as cruel, unpleasant and selfish as hers, all of the time.

I did miss my cuddly little ones and being at the centre of the comforting book-bag, Teletubbies, play-doh and bedtime-story nursery years as my DDs passed out of childhood and into puberty, but they remained essentially themselves. My youngest is 18 now and we are still a happy family - and any awkwardnesses of the teenage years (we did have some - who doesn't) are smoothing out as they become just people. The article writer is either making a lot of it up for provocative copy, or has been extraoridnarily unlucky.

leo1978 · 08/10/2007 08:03

I agree - she does my head in. They printed letters about it one Saturday - people saying the same thing as on here. I would be alive to tell the tale had I spoken to my mother the way those kids do.

leo1978 · 08/10/2007 08:04

I would NOT be alive today. Whats wrong with my computer????

slowreader · 08/10/2007 08:45

I know loads of teenagers and have one myself. They are kind, witty, sensitive, messy, disorganised, constantly hungry, expensive and NICE. They would never behave like the Guardian monsters, not because they daren't but because they don't want to.

Sherbert37 · 15/10/2007 11:18

It's so sad that this is exactly what people WANT to believe about teenagers and it is being printed in a national newspaper. Agree they could do with some coverage of all the fab, unselfish things teenagers do to balance this out.

clop · 15/10/2007 11:53

I think you lot are being unfair, she says a lot of good things about them, too (can you tell I'm a faithful reader). But it's always a mixed bag, bittersweet. I like to think I wouldn't let my son call me THAT NAME either, but obviously it just doesn't bother her. Maybe that's how to make the name-calling just a passing fad; besides, we do not know what language the parents use in front of the teens!

Once the boys were being shits but the girl was being helpful & nice, goes out to lunch with mum, and then warms up to asking if mum will buy her a new nice leather jacket. Or the boy who had been a superstar at school bombed out his A-levels, saying "I don't want to be like you Dad" (even though mum could see little difference between father & son). Meanwhile the girl comes home saying "I know I'm not as bright as big brother so please don't be disappointed that my GCSE results aren't like his", and the mother is just so chuffed that the girl has tried her hardest, never mind the actual results.

Last week she said how the younger lad ALWAYS came home at time he said he would, which is why when he was late one night the mum got so worried.. .he turns up drunk and having been very sick. Suddenly he was just a stupid vulnerable 15 yo.

Although I did think she should have made him sleep in the sick clothes and left him to clean himself and the bed and the rug up in the morning.

mrsmike · 16/10/2007 00:15

Well actually, apart from the bad language, I find it quite life like . Their attitudes and activities seem pretty typical of teens I know including my own 2. And I usually feel a bit better after reading it, thinking I'm not the only one . I do find it all very sour sweet if you know what I mean.
Re the bad language, I'm sure I read one a long time ago where she said they had consciously decided to let the kids use swear words, hoping that if it wasn't forbidden, then the novelty would wear off. But it didn't and then they couldn't back track ...

Tortington · 16/10/2007 00:35

clearly they should call me. i would whip them into shape ( never read it didn't know it existed) am dissapointed i have been looked over ONCE AGAIN by the press - how hard can it be?

Elizabetth · 16/10/2007 00:35

Her daughter seems to get the worst of the deal in the family.

She came in one time finding her son attacking her daughter and instead of telling him off and getting him to stop, she made out that it was both their faults. Then she called her daughter a "silly cow" so we know where they get the habit for calling one another insulting names from.

She appears willing to let the two boys get away with just about anything on the other hand.

mrsmike · 16/10/2007 00:42

custy you won't like it, liberal wishy washy stuff

Tortington · 16/10/2007 00:47

i am a liberal!