Benefit badgal mascara

[TrillianAstra]

I have a little trial tube and love it - not sure how much of the goodness is in the brush but it's great.

However, I see there is a waterproof version. Is it as good?

Anyone ever used it?

I like benefit stuff but the badgal doesnt do it for me - too clumpy.

Badgal has a fab brush and made my lashes look fab but smudged almost instantly so i'd never buy it (I had a trial tube too.) I wonder if the waterproof one is any good too.

I don't like it. And I am doubly cross as my mum bought me some for Christmas, I tried it and thought it was crap and tried to exchange it but they refused. I thought they should have enough conviction in their products to have a refund policy. Estee Lauder do as I recently took back some of that supposedly brilliant night repair thing as it just made my skin dry. I don't make a habit of taking things back, I just don't like paying a lot of money for shite.