Please tell me which of these boots I should buy - if any?

[Thelongroadhome]

Hi, have been fancying some new brown boots for a while and have wondered about the Karina riding boot from fatface (4th along) or
these duo ones. I want to wear them with long socks poking out the top and shortish skirts / dresses. Thanks for your help and if you hate them both could you suggest something else?!.

They are both very nice but I prefer the fat face ones as I do like a buckle on a boot!

i prefer the second pair.

yum.

Prefer the fat face one. You can wear that with long socks too, can't you?