I am giving it 7.5 out of ten, marks off for price, and the neckline, which feels a little restrictive (which might be a good thing when it gets to gale force winds and driving rain weather.).
It isn't very bulky, though it has a quilted lining, it has a covered zip, then there are duffle coat toggles - it is reasonably fitted, but with room for layers. I still feel a bit, eh, sturdy in it. Good snug fit on the wrists, and comfy too.
The length is good, though it would have been better if it finished on my knee, rather than above my knee (glad I am short for once), but it is good having a warm back and thighs being covered.
The colour is well just brown, not very exciting, I wish I could have had more choice there, it is available in black or white too.
I will wait and see what dh thinks - but I am quite happy with it, it is fit for purpose(going to school and standing around in the freezing playground for 30 mins + every day), and it should be good for winter walks too. I wouldn't say it is stylish, but it has a certain duffle coat snugly charm.