Best tubing mascara

[user7654263]

Can anyone give a recommendation. Ive used the same mascara for years but its difficult to remove and it isn't great for my lashes.

Lash Power

I use this one - doesn't smudge and is removed with just warm water.

I also use this one, I tried the no 7 one and it's not a patch on this, it smudged and didn't really enhance my lashes at all

I think that's L'Oréal Beauty Tubes?
I've been finding it here and there on the internet (using one atm and have another spare) but following this thread as, AFAIK, it has been discontinued

I was gutted when I realised this was discontinued, was my absolute favourite!

Yes this is it.

The clinique is called lash power and the elf is called Lash XTNDR Mascara. Hth.

https://www.boots.com/no7-stay-perfect-mascara-10156448?srsltid=AfmBOoroVX2NOhp2QhIOY5R0uUF5rI5e4M5I32Nvri0AkUB7BbIZyVkb

This is proper tubing aka little spidery lashes come off with water, rather than flakey bits like with Clinique or Sky High.