Mascara which stays on!

[Pantsinthewash]

Can anyone recommend a mascara which stays on please? I often get panda eye smudges underneath my lower eyelid. Should I avoid getting moisturizer on my area in case this helps?

Agree with the tubing mascara suggestions. I rate doublewear and Clinique which both have staying power. If you are a beautypie subscriber I’m also impressed with their new tubing mascara. I’ll probably save my membership fee in mascara alone this year (I do not go for a natural look!)

Thank you all again for your suggestions. Will update you on what I get and how it behaves. It's so expensive to keep being disappointed though, isn't it?

Tubing mascara helps me as oil removes traditional 'waterproof' mascara. I have both oily skin and hooded eyelids so it's smudge city on me.
Tubing isn't affected by this unless it's a particularly sweaty humid day whereby bits might start to flake off after about 5 hours but again easier to simply wipe off than trying to scrub off 'waterproof' which has smudged.

Don't you just soak it in warm water for a bit ? It slides off really easily when soaked in water.

Clinique lash power never smudges for me.

Can anyone please recommend a low-cost yet good tubing mascara, please?

No 7 Intense Volume

Maybelline sky high is tubing. Works very well for me.