A couple of years ago I got swept up in the "cleansing oil" trend and had a wonderful few months with Body Shop's Chamomile Cleansing Oil before it turned on me horribly - took months for my chin to recover.
I carried on using the oil as an eye makeup remover though, and loved it. I even replaced the bottle just to keep using it as an eye makeup remover. I massage it in all around my eyes, it feels lovely and keeps them nice and hydrated, and obviously doesn't give me spots on my eyelids 
I'm running low now again though and it feels a bit extravagant to buy more just for eye makeup remover - can I sub in plain old EVOO?
Thanks!