Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

Has clothing quality gone downhill or have I just had a run of bad luck?

69 replies

WardrobeDisaster · 31/10/2016 12:10

I bought a whole pile of new clothes recently and most of them seem to have fallen apart within 2 wears:

  • trousers have split across the knee
  • hook and eye fastening fell off replacement trousers
  • buttons fallen off other trousers
  • tassel on shoes fell apart
  • sole coming away on shoe
  • seams have frayed and split on a dress

These aren't the most expensive end of high street, but decent quality brands - or so I thought (Clarks, Mint Velvet, Somerset by Alice Temperley etc). Admittedly my more expensive branded clothes seem to have held up so far.

Have I just been unlucky or is quality dropping generally? I'm so tired of mending or returning items.

OP posts:
Floisme · 02/11/2016 11:23

Taybert I was comparing the cost of clothing now with 20+ years ago. I'm pretty sure it's fallen - I used to buy far fewer clothes then and they took up a bigger proportion of my income. It dates back to when manufacturing moved out of the Uk.

RebelandaStunner · 02/11/2016 11:35

I always give buttons a good tug in the changing room. I have had a few ping off.
Nothing worse than loosing buttons that match.
I also hate t-shirts that twist after one or two washes.
H and M t-shirts are pretty good I find.
Some cheap makes don't even do the basic garment tests that's why they can sell them at those prices. The brands above those tend to test pretty similar.

FreeButtonBee · 02/11/2016 11:46

GAp do winter weight leggings for little girls. www.gap.co.uk/browse/product.do?cid=1056564&vid=1&pid=000297734031 "Coziest" leggings. There are not super warm but at least not spit through! Also Sainsburys have a nice link in heavy cable knit leggings. Not the most amazing fabric mix but nice and heavy and can stand up to some rough and tumble without the knees going.

Apart from that, I agree. it's so hit and miss. Bought 2 tops in zara (I know it's not the best quality ever) for exactly the same price. One is cotton/silk mix and a beautiful embroidered pattern (black on black)- washes like a dream. The other was a tie front shirt. It was polyester and I loved the style so bought it against my better judgment. 6 weeks later, the fabric has gone where a slightly too hot iron was used. Hmm No consistency. If I could buy 10 tops like the silk/cotton mix one I would and I'd pay a lot more as well. But it was one perfect top in the whole shop...

MartinRohdesBellybuttonFluff · 02/11/2016 12:00

My toddler DS is wearing hand me downs from his older brothers. Some of the stuff (mostly Boden and Next) is 10 yo, still looks beautiful and washes brilliantly. There is far better attention to detail (appliqué, pockets, buttons etc) than the clothes today. He's got a fabulous vintage wardrobe Grin

Also agree that there is tons of viscose and nasty polyester masquerading as slinky, silky, luxurious fabric. In reality it makes my hair stand on end and I give and get constant electric shocks Angry

Oldraver · 02/11/2016 12:05

I've just started wearing a short sleeved tartan blouse I got from Matalan 10 years ago. It hasn't been worn for years but the fabric is lovely not frayed or worn and the seaming and edges are well made (also a seamstress).

I've bought two blouses this year and the fabric has actually worn under the arm and 'rubbed'' off the design

boldlygoingsomewhere · 02/11/2016 12:43

I agree clothing quality has gone downhill - I don't mind paying more for something that lasts but I've not been impressed recently with stuff I've ordered from Hush and Boden. I'm finding it so frustrating trying buy things. I've found Uniqlo quite good and Esprit although the latter is tricky for returns. Stuff I bought as a teenager in the 90s was much better made.

Werkzallhourz · 02/11/2016 13:06

Yes, it has gone downhill terribly -- to the point where I'm getting quite pissed off about it.

I recently bought a few thick cotton tops that seemed good quality, weren't massively cheap, but after a few washes, they look like rags and are pretty much unwearable for another other than gardening or housework. Someone was telling me that it is down to using cheaper cotton with a shorter thread length.

Again, for the first time ever, both of the underwires have poked through on a Freya bra I only bought early this year. And the elastic band on a pack of pretty polly cotton knickers I bought earlier this year has come away from the rest of the knicker.

I've noticed it with DH's clothes too. Fairly new cotton underwear falling into holes and "bobbling", socks shrinking (since when did socks shrink?), an utter inability to find a decent pair of natural fibre work trousers for him ...

The thing is that it all starts to get quite expensive. Fast fashion is an illusion if a top costs you £10 but you only get two wears out of it. That's a fiver a wear.

I was big into fashion in the early 90s and used to buy some fairly pricey designer items. Everything was lined and finished off beautifully. But M&S back then was known for almost indestructible clothing. I seem to remember that there used to be regulations that M&S knickers had to survive something like 6000 washes.

I really don't know where to buy clothes anymore. DH and I are at an age where our clothing needs to look smart, tidy, and stylish, not very fashionable, and we don't have the time to constantly shop for clothes.

I tell you where else I've noticed the problem: bed-linen. I still have fitted sheets and duvet covers that my grandma bought in the late 80s and they are almost as good as new. Yet I've had to chuck a few sets that I've bought in the last decade over the last couple of years because the cotton had got so tissue thin.

TooPlain · 02/11/2016 13:11

I definitely throw out more clothing now because it's worn out than I ever used to. I've found knitwear especially bad with many jumpers only lasting one winter before they're a bobbly, mis-shapen mess.

Cos is good. I have some things from there that have been washed many times and still in good condition. I'm not interested in going shopping and replacing stuff if I don't have to.

TollgateDebs · 02/11/2016 15:25

I too used to spend more per item, but they lasted longer and looked far better. I am careful with washing and still some items just look tatty after a couple of wears, to the end that I have returned items, including to Boden, as they were just not up to scratch for the price. I am also constantly sewing on buttons, repairing the stitching on button holes and repairing hems that just seem to disintegrate.

maggiethemagpie · 02/11/2016 15:32

It's all a con to make us keep coming back and spending more. I can see the clothing companies thinking to themselves, hmmm how crappy shall we make these clothes. If too crappy, we'll get a bad reputation and no one will shop with us but if the quality is too good, people will buy clothes that last for years and not come back to spend more. Let's make them just crappy enough to maximise our profits....

VeryPunny · 02/11/2016 16:01

Werkzallhourz yy to bedlinen. I replaced our bedding three years ago - the old stuff had lasted 13 years and was going threadbare, the replacement stuff (from John Lewis, so not bargain basement) had stitching coming off within 18 months.

WardrobeDisaster · 02/11/2016 21:00

Yes, I've had similar with White Company bedlinen. Lovely sheets, but only lasted a couple of years.

It makes me really cross. I don't buy many clothes (short of time, can't stand shopping and I prefer to buy fewer items that will last) - I don't have time to be mending new items or taking them back to the shops.

But thanks for the tip for Gap leggings, I'll check them out.

OP posts:
missyB1 · 02/11/2016 21:23

Absolutely re the bed linen! Fed up of them going grotty after a few washes.

instantly · 02/11/2016 21:27

I feel like this is blasphemy but....

My Boden Ruched skirt has bobbled up on the inside of the double layer. So I now have a load of crappy bobbles inside the lining where I can't do anything about it.

It's really fucking irritating

instantly · 02/11/2016 21:30

Oh and next leggings for DD. Two pairs and she went through the knees on the second wear. Grrrr.

I ordered some sandals from Boden and the straps were so short I couldn't even do the bloody things up. Poor design really gets my goat too.

Flingmoo · 02/11/2016 21:33

I definitely agree and I sometimes notice quality worsening on the same items each year. For example I bought my toddler some pyjamas from Morrisons last year, the baby/toddler stuff there is pretty good. They were great quality, thick material, proper stretchy cuffs on the arms and bottoms of the trouser legs. This year I buy him an almost identical set and it's much thinner, no stretchy cuffs, and got a hole in the middle of the fabric, not even on a seam or a weak point, before it had even been washed once!

Yes women's clothes are way too thin so you need a million layers if you are someone who feels the cold. Plus thin material often just looks cheap and isn't flattering, it doesn't smooth out your lumps and bumps, you can see labels and seams through it too. Men's clothes are generally not like this so why do we have to put up with it?!

OhtoblazeswithElvira · 02/11/2016 21:34

Yes definitely quality has gone downhill. Yes we have cheaper clothes but some of the middle range brands are taking advantage of this - lowering quality but not prices: Boden and the like charging ££ for man made fibres and poor finish.

I sew, too. There is no way I could afford natural fibres clothes made in the UK, with a decent finish, paying minimum wage Sad The prices we are paying now rely on labour costs being very close to zero! So I don't think that going back to the golden-era-of-British-manufacturimg will sort this problem out.

instantly · 02/11/2016 21:37

Oh don't get started on pjs.

I bought two pairs from next. One shrank on a 40 degree wash, first time out. The second wore a hole in the crotch seam within a month.

Total crap.

Supermarket pjs just shrink in every direction.

Lanaorana1 · 02/11/2016 21:40

Whistles is grim, worse than Primark. Except shoes. Cos brilliant.

I volunteer in a high-end charity shop and I see about 100 kg of ladies's clothes for checking every day I'm in. IMHO the best brands for survival are:

  • Brora
  • Cos
  • Zara
  • Jaeger
  • Nicole Farhi
  • Warehouse silk stuff

The shameful ones are:

  • Whistles
  • Jigsaw
  • White stuff
  • Debenhams
  • those expensive French brands eg Isabel Marant, Maje, etc which appear to be made of tissue once washed

Brands most given away:

  • H&M
  • Zara

by a million miles, both worn and unworn.

Artandco · 02/11/2016 21:42

Olive is a brand online I have found some good things on recently

Finisterre are a good company for outdoor jackets, good basic knit jumpers and great thermals

I use Cambridge baby for thick good quality kids leggings. Not cheapest, but last forever, past down between children and onto friends

BikeRunSki · 02/11/2016 21:44

I have had success with Toast recently.

Chinnygirl · 02/11/2016 21:56

The last time I bought a quality item was a blouse in 1992. I threw it out when I moved 5 years ago because I was fed up after wearing it hundreds of times. It still looked like new. In hindsight I should have kept it, it could last through the apocalypse.

Pisssssedofff · 02/11/2016 22:03

My whistles jacket is bloody gorgeous, It's all very hit and miss, none are made in one factory so there's literally no telling

BlueEyedWonder · 02/11/2016 22:09

Quality is awful on the high street and I've returned the following in the last 6 months for refund:
Clarks shoes the buckle broke on
Topshop top the seam came undone
Gap jumper arrived with wonky stitching
Boden coat 2 buttons fell off

Oly5 · 02/11/2016 22:13

I agree though seem to have different experiences on brands than the rest of you!
My white company clothes last ages (washed v carefully), as do fat face and most boden!