Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

Cutting out skin care products improves skin?

82 replies

bertiebow · 07/10/2015 21:17

Really curious about what others thing of this. I have had mild acne for about a year and have tried various things to try and fix it. When I was younger I was lucky enough not to get teenage spots and so never really bothered about my skin, just used wipes or baby lotion as make up remover and splashed my face with water in the morning.

I've been reading quite a bit about people who have cured their acne by cutting out all skin care products. Seem like a lot of people have pretty drastic success with letting skin heal itself e.g. here - www.acne.org/not-washing-or-water-only-reviews-1202/

Has anyone else tried this?

OP posts:
PassiveAgressiveQueen · 08/10/2015 12:04

Muslim cloth and hot water only

this was why we called them sick cloths, i was worried about calling out in public "can you pass the muslim please, she has been sick again"

Nabootique · 08/10/2015 12:07

I think nancy75 has a point. Genes does come into it. Both of my parents look good for their age

Glittery Sorry to hear about your breakout (I'm in the same boat at the moment), but those Clearasil pads are high in alcohol and I really would put at least a slick of moisturiser on top or your skin might get irritated further. I hope I don't sound patronising. I'm sure you know about the alcohol. I'd just hate for it to get worse for you!

WaggleBee · 08/10/2015 14:20

Both parents have always had really normal, clear skin, never a blemish in their lives. Which makes my super needy skin even more annoying. Grin

They have passed on the looking really young gene though which I'm just starting to appreciate.

I

WaggleBee · 08/10/2015 14:23

Wolper I'll try the Clinique stuff. I only get very mild acne these days and anything stronger seems to trigger off cystic acne. Thanks for the recommendation.

HazleNutt · 08/10/2015 14:27

What Judy said - I did all the usual stuff when I got some random spots - harsh oily skin care, alcohol spot drying stuff etc. What I really needed was to calm my skin down and use sensitive skin care (Dr Hauschka in my case).

Of course there are some lucky people who can just wash and go and look amazing, but that's not the case for all of us.

MeganChips · 08/10/2015 18:10

Waggle, sorry for the late response.

I use FAB Facial Radiance pads which do the job but are really gentle. They get good reviews from the skincare experts too.

FrustratedFrugal · 08/10/2015 20:30

Yep this has happened to me. I cut out everything recently (developed a precancerous thing on my lip and had it removed) and have only worn a tiny bit of bronzer and some Biore sunscreen. My skin is fab. I still use salicylic pads occasionally and cleanse with Bioderma and black soap. Best routine ever. I am usually extremely acne-prone.

bertiebow · 08/10/2015 21:06

Frugal, what is this black soap you use? I thought soap was supposed to be too drying, but maybe this is different.

I might try the Paula's Choice 2% but I am really not sure that acids are the way forward for my skin.

Considering sticking to the following:

AM

  • cleanse face with warm flannel and water
  • moisturiser/spf

PM

  • take off make up with E45
  • Cicaplast baume to moisturise (supposed to be healing/good for skin barrier)
OP posts:
ToysDontWorkNoMore · 08/10/2015 21:24

I was talking about this stuff (obvs. more expensive in the uk):

www.amazon.co.uk/Lactacyd-Derma-Liquid-Soap-500ml/dp/B00NGQ07DK/ref=sr_1_16?ie=UTF8&qid=1444335659&sr=8-16&keywords=lactacyd

TheGreenNinja · 08/10/2015 21:52

I don't use anything, and my skin is great. I occasionally use a bit of Nivea moisturiser (and I mean maybe once a month) but otherwise nothing. I think you get caught in a cycle of putting things on your face, then cleaning them off and having to replace the natural oils or whatever with something else, whereas if you'd just left it alone you wouldn't need to correct anything.

Laska5772 · 08/10/2015 22:10

I never use anything either..wash only with water on my face and have never used any cleaning products or nmake up on my face in my adult life.

My grandmother (who had fantastic unlined complexion) advised me when i was a teenager not to wear foundation etc and not to wash with soap and (probably through uter laziness) i took her advice .. so at 57 and having never worn make up nor cleansed my face with any product you'd think my skin would be horrid , but its not.. clear , ( a bit pale as im fair skinned ) but hardly any lines, not dry or greasy .

People often compliment me on my complexion and 'young looks' ( its could be gust good genes though) because i smoke sometimes and drink Wine.

I do these days get my eyelashes and brows dyed though..

.. Don't you just hate me? .. dont worry.. im a bit fat and proper pug-ugly though!! Grin

Laska5772 · 08/10/2015 22:14

perhaps aftre that you might think should change my name to LaskaDirtyMcSquirty Grin.. so am just coming back to reassure you I do wash with shower gel everywhere else!!

Glitteryred · 09/10/2015 10:21

So last night I just used micellar water to remove my make up ( CC cream not my full on clarins foundation) and it looks and feels much better than when I use my cleanser and wash with a face cloth.

I did this after reading so many people with rosacea find the hot cloth method aggravates their skin. So I'll cut it down to just a couple of times a week as opposed to every night.

Floisme · 09/10/2015 12:49

I developed really sensitive skin through using too many products. I've posted about it before so won't repeat myself but I now stick to almond or wheatgerm oil, moisturiser and sunscreen. It works very well for me.

FrustratedFrugal · 09/10/2015 16:35

I use a Middle Eastern black soap - nigella aleppo soap - but Western African black soaps (Akamuti etc) are equally great. They are too dry for very dry skin types but not my normal/dry skin. I've used the bar for two years now and it's still going strong.

Waves to Toys and Lactacyd. I've used that too in the past and it is great stuff.

buspuppy · 09/10/2015 19:32

I've never used make up or many skin care products and suffered all my life with mild acne (bad acne as a teenager!). When I did try skin care products they never cured the problem so I just stopped spending money on them.

A couple of years ago I went gluten free (as part of changing to a 'primal' diet) and my spots disappeared...totally disappeared. I had started to get really dry skin on my hands too and this has also disappeared. When I indulge in the odd cake or french stick (they ARE nice!!) I am guaranteed to get a few spots, but as long as I avoid the gluten (and for me it does seem to be specifically gluten) I don't have spots! So acne can be related entirely to diet ime.

We went 'chemical free' in my house this year so use virtually no skin care products (shampoo, shower gels, moisturisers, sun cream etc), and the dc have absolutely perfect luscious skin and my skin has only improved too. I do miss 'smelling' of something nice sometimes though!

ItchyArmpits · 09/10/2015 19:36

The lady in the hammam in Turkey gave me a bar of plain olive oil soap ("You have a nice face... is a pity..." while peering at my spots) and made a huge difference. Not overnight, but within a couple of weeks. Mild enough to let swelling, redness and irritation go down, while still getting my skin super-clean. Love it. I buy it off eBay now.

bigbuttons · 09/10/2015 21:06

I bought some black soap from Marrakech this summer, it's sold in huge vats over there and is dirt cheap.
I have found that the best way to keep my skin spot free is keeping it clean and using acids.
I have also found that using the Argan oil I also got in Morroco to be brilliant for keeping my skin smooth and spot free.

travailtotravel · 09/10/2015 21:24

I stopped doing anything except cleanse in the evening and a light moisturizer in the morning. My skin cleared up immensely. I use Avene Light Moisturiser or Cetaphil.

Rivercam · 09/10/2015 21:30

Bus puppy - what domyounuse to wash your hair etc?

Also, I've heard people use cetaphil. Is it a wonder product?

What's good for teens?

absterfabster21 · 09/10/2015 21:48

Clean eating and cutting out alcohol always helps my skin. Acne sufferer and also rosacea for at least 14 years now. Yukult drinks (pro biotic) also help. Definitely best healing from the inside out IMO but nothing heals it forever I think some people just have crap skin, like some have thin hair, waxy ears or other undesirable traits!

ShowMeSaturn · 09/10/2015 22:29

Well, some of the more expensive face creams now have chemicals in them which 'give the appearance of vanishing fine lines' because the chemicals are like acid, they break down fatty deposits on the face. I think it's Retinol. I don't want that stuff on my skin.

I remember that feeling of Anne French cleanser on my teenage skin, thinking, this hurts! so it must be doing me good. My skin was so stripped of oils it shone like a supernova. But with it came patchy redness, flare ups, and psoriasis around my hairline. The psoriasis stopped completely once I stopped using skincare products.

Chemistry websites are better places to research skin care ingredients than the skincare manufacturers themselves.

My gran had velvety powdery clear skin and all she ever used was soap and water, and Atrixo cream if her face was too dry in winter. They weren't indoctrinated into buying products to make themselves less ugly, like our generations are.

I think if you notice a lot of older generations' facial skin (you'd have to be a bus person like me to sit near enough behind them to notice!) you'll see they mostly all have beautiful soft skin.

I stopped using products like cleansers and toners a few years ago and stuck to plain soap and water, but I do need a moisturiser.

If I had the wherewithal I'd even like to potion up some natural moisturisers like honey and a carrier oil or some such.

I'm convinced that the less chemicals we put on our skin the better.

YellowTulips · 09/10/2015 22:57

I have eczema and skin care is a nightmare.

The only think that really works (having spent a small fortune) is Eve Lom cleanser.

Her philosophy is too many products mess up your skin so all you need is a good cleaner, serum and moisturiser.

I love her TLC cream but think it would be too rich for acne prone skin.

A friend loves using Eve Lom cleaner with a Clinique oil free moisturiser (moisture surge I think but not sure) and she has acne prone skin but swears by this combo to keep it at bay (and she looks great).

MamaMotherMummy · 09/10/2015 23:23

I used to have acne. I stopped washing my face altogether, no water no nothing, and it is all gone. Sounds disgusting but a lot of people have had success with the Caveman method as it is known.

DistanceCall · 10/10/2015 00:06

Take a look at Caroline Hirons's blog. Her cheat sheets are really good.