Opinions on this coat

[Spidergirl8]

I really like this coat. I like that it is waxed so offers some rain protection but doesn't look like a walking coat!

I buy clothes from COS, Jaeger, Zara and Toast - so this style kind of fits into the style I like. However it isn't cheap so wanted to get opinions. What do you think?

It's horrific

The tartan and navy version doesn't look too bad. The sand and plum is an awful colour combination....vomit inducing.

I don't like it, but if you do then go for it. I buy clothes that I think are stylish and functional for what I want them for. I couldn't care less if they have credibility with fashion critics. Their opinion is less important to me than the real people on here or in RL.

it is just ugly, regardless of whoever has designed it. Sorry

This sound like The Emperor's New Clothes! Just because an up and coming designer is behind it doesn't make it attractive; it's not. It doesn't really have any design, it's shapeless. It's the kind of thing Tracey Emin would produce if she made clothig (thank God she doesn't!) As far as possible, clothing should be practical AND flatter! Sorry if I sound annoyed but they are taking the piss at that price!

Well I quite like it OP! I prefer the sand and black personally.

yuck yuck yuck - shapeless, horrible colour - think you would look as stupid as the model does. Actually looks like one of those bags you get mail in sometimes - the kind of really heavy paper with the seam sewn up at the bottom....
its as bad and overpriced as the Victoria Beckham

I'll be the lone voice then I love it. More so buttoned up than with the collar splayed I admit though.

I like it, but like pp, prefer it buttoned up.
It's only going to look good on people built like the model though.

Oh dear that is bad .. Looks like something you would see in a ' they saw you coming ' type boutique ..

The shape is terrible. Have a look at ted baker coats.