Please rate this shoes, skirt, top combo

[AMinorBird]

I am trying to work out whether to charity shop this skirt now that my legs have seen better days. Is it okay or do I need to get rid of it.

On legs being the last thing to go: I think that can be true of the lower leg but less so of knees and thighs sadly. At least that's my own experience although everyone's different. Anyway looking at that photo, op you don't need to worry - your legs look good. I would just bear in mind how much a short skirt can ride up but that's true at any age.

Looks great I'd keep it. You have nice legs.

I would say depending on quality of H&M maybe look for another skirt similar (if you want one).

I've recently bought an &Other Stories shorter black skirt and wore my Cos red skirt (just above knee) the other day. Got a great Louche floral skater skirt too (above knee, maybe 2 inches?) which I love, great with opaques and boots.

Oh the top is fine, not 100% sure whether it totally goes with skirt. Shoes, not with the skirt as another person said. But can't see them... if brown brogues then maybe keep if you'd wear them.

You have nice legs but I think the skirt is too short.

The skirt looks fine...but you may hate it when you sit down. I think the shoes also look fine. I frequently wear tan shoes and black but i do think that if you have black brogues, they would look better and make your legs look even longer!!!

Lovely! You look fabulous in that OP.

Is the skirt thick grey material? If so I have it and it's one of the best quality things I have ever bought from H & M. It's a bit short on me, but you have better legs