Fallen in love with two coats.....please help me choose!

[velourvoyageur]

I have wanted a cape for ages. Just fallen on this:
gray cape coat

It is so cute. It has a hood and I think would look amazing with skinnies and boots. I just wish they would show a photo of it on a model, right now I've no idea how it falls or fits or anything.

Then there's this:

gray Zara coat

Which I've tried on in the shop. It has one button only, at the top, so it's sort of a cape....and it's a thin sort of material so you can wear jumpers underneath and not get too hot.

(am in France so don't know if you'll be automatically redirected to the UK site or what....)

I just want both. I can't choose.

what do you think?

Love the cape.
Dislike the second one.Looks like a cut off dressing gown with too short arms to me.Sorry.

I've tried the Zara one on, it's really nice, well cut too.

Now that they have the image on the model up I think the Cos cape is lovely, really cute, it would look great with skinny jeans and boots.

It's not a winter coat IMO, it's more for milder weather, you could wear long sleeve tops and wristwarmers with it though, hush had nice wristwarmers last year, so you get longer out of it, and it's not like every day in winter is freezing cold anyway.