Which of these boots do you prefer?

[Pinkfrocks]

Does anyone have any strong opinions on either of these? They both like better in reality than on the web. The first pair has a much thicker sole and grip.
Have ordered both, like both, one is much cheaper than the other.
The 2nd pair seem slightly wider around the top and don't have a zip( that works)
Would probably wear either with slim jeans tucked in or they would also fit under narrow/ straight leg jeans. (just)

Clarks boots

www.clarks.co.uk/p/26104319 Clarks boots]]

no they don't have to be biker style....but I have some Chelsea boots- but am still open to idea for another pair! I need a flat or almost flat heel- which rules out quite a few- and I have narrow ankles so nothing too gapey.

First pair. Second pair look odd.

I rather like the look of these and these at first glance.

Thanks- both worth a look :)