Opinions please on these two bags

[culturevulture]

www.jonesbootmaker.com/main/details/Womens/06030329N92/SEYMOUR_3_BluePatent

or

www.jonesbootmaker.com/main/details/Bags/06030304N10/SESAME_Blue

Thanks

I don't particularly like either but if you pushed me for a choice it would be the second one.

First one is more stylish, vintage looking lady like bag in a bright patent, BUT the second one is more mainstream, prob more practical..

I'd buy first. Actually, at that price I'd buy both :)

Thanks. I bought the first one in store today but have just seen the second one online and now not sure which I prefer.

The first is much nicer in the flesh and is a gorgeous blue but the second one looks really soft leather.

Don't like either but think the second one looks less tacky than the first. Sorry

Oh, does it really look tacky do you think?