So, a Billy Bag VS. a David and Scotti bag OR both???

[OhCobblers]

i've gone a bit nuts in TK MAxx recently!!!

i found a Billy Bag (remember seeing these in NYC years ago) in what they call "almond" - thats a pinky/beige to you and I and it was originally £200 down to £60 - bargain.

i then saw a beautiful David and Scotti leather bag (never heard of them before) reduced from £463 to £80 - yet another bargain.

i love both. i'm fed up of my "kids" bag so am turfing it out and going to use one of these.

the BB bag is a completely impractical colour for daily use but lovely, HOWEVER, i don't know if its leather. i just can't tell and there is no "leather" tag inside (wouldn't there normally be one in such an expensive bag?). the D&S bag is a lovely colour and very practical for daily use though a tad big, but i can live with that.

So, ladies, do i keep them both (can't afford to but thats not stopped me before) but only if the BB bag is leather - i'm not paying that much for PU OR does the BB bag go back??

i leave it to the MN jury

Oh I love Billy Bag, they are my work bags of choice but find it v hard to say without seeing both. Are they on TK website?

billy bag

Febreeeze, its the "Grey Hobo Shoulder Bag" but the one i have is very very pale pink (almost cream), but do you see how they detail some bags as leather but not others?? this is what concerns me that mine may not be leather and therefore a good enough reason to take it back!!
the DS back is definitely leather plus has cloth bag to match which i always thought leather ones would have??

bumping for evening crowd as i need opinions!!!