Please or to access all these features

Sponsored Q&As

This topic is for Q & As run by Mumsnet. If you'd like to sponsor a Q & A, please email [email protected].

Would you know what to do in a cardiac emergency? Ask our expert

107 replies

EllieSmumsnet · 13/03/2026 10:45

It’s a common belief when we hear about sudden cardiac arrest or heart attacks, that it affects someone older, someone unwell, someone else. But cardiac arrest can happen at any age and as MyDefib has noted, 80% of cardiac arrests that happen outside of hospital occur at home*, where family members become the first responders.

Survivor and Sudden Cardiac Arrest UK advocate Gareth Cole is helping to challenge the myths and answer the questions many families are afraid to ask, from who’s really at risk, to what you should do in those first critical minutes and what life is like after.

As a survivor and advocate for cardiac arrest awareness, he is partnering with MyDefib to turn awareness into action at home - empowering families to respond confidently to cardiac arrest before it happens, with the mission of saving lives.

Do you have a question about heart health, heart attacks, or cardiac arrests? Gareth is here to answer them.

Share your question by 17/04/026 for a chance to win a £200 voucher (T&Cs).

References - *
mydefib.co.uk/about/

About Gareth:
Gareth knows firsthand the challenges of life after cardiac arrest.

As a survivor, he has turned his experience into a passion for supporting others on their recovery journey. Through his role with Sudden Cardiac Arrest UK, he helps raise awareness, advocate for better aftercare, and foster a strong, supportive community for survivors and their families.

Gareth believes that recovery is more than just surviving—it’s about reclaiming life, finding purpose, and connecting with others who truly understand. His positivity, resilience, and dedication make him an inspiring figure in the cardiac arrest survivor community.

Would you know what to do in a cardiac emergency? Ask our expert
GarethCole · 21/04/2026 11:50

purplecomet · 24/03/2026 22:22

A family member had a previous cardiac arrest and now has an ICD. If another cardiac arrest occurs the ICD should take over but should we attempt CPR or leave the ICD to deliver shocks? Of course we'd call 999.

The ICD is there to administer a shock, or shocks, if your family member is unfortunate enough to have another episode. ICDs are generally very reliable and very effective and they are designed to fire whist the patient is still conscious. If however the ICD doesn't fire, or the shock doesn't maintain consciousness, the yes, you should definitely attempt CPR and find a defibrillator in exactly the same way that you would for a patient who doesn't have an ICD.

Experts' posts:
GarethCole · 21/04/2026 11:53

Rummikub · 25/03/2026 22:43

Can you improve heart health? After a cardiac incident?

The short answer to your question is yes, you can, but it takes time and effort. Medication to restore heart function after a cardiac event is significantly approved from even a decade ago, but it can only do so much. The rest is down to lifestyle choices and commitment, however there is no reason why a patient cant become as healthy, or even more healthy, than they were prior to the event.

Experts' posts:
GarethCole · 21/04/2026 11:53

sashh · 31/03/2026 11:24

On the heart attack vs cardiac arrest (and it drives me mad when things are reported as one and not the other).

Think of your circulation like your central heating system. The main purpose of your heart is to work like the pump in the boiler. Get the blood around your system.

When you get a blockage in the pipes it can be a problem, a heart attack (blockage basically in the pipes near the pump) or if the blockage is elsewhere it can be a stroke or thrombosis. If it is very near the pump this is a heart attack.

The other part of the heart / boiler is the electrical timing. In your heart this is an electrical system that initiates every bet of your heart (technically it isn't but we are not going in to that much detail). A piece of the heart muscle is dyeing.

When this stops working it is a cardiac arrest.

An ECG shows this activity from different directions so it shows a cardiac arrest but it can show lots of other things, eg bundle branch blocks, the electrical activity can indicate what is going on in the pump eg if you are having a heart attack the electrical information will show, "ST elevation" in the ECG.

A pacemaker can take over the timing of your heart if your own electrical system isn't working well.

What you have written here is entirely correct and doesn't need any further input from me ! Like you, I do get frustrated when people refer to cardiac arrests as heart attacks, and vice versa, but after more than a decade in this field I do understand it to a certain extent. Most people don't know the difference unless they have been directly affected by one or the other (or both) and honestly, why would they. If the media misreport it then my hackles go up !

Experts' posts:
GarethCole · 21/04/2026 15:16

pteromum · 17/03/2026 13:23

Good topic to be discussed here.

the most frightening statistic that stuck with me is that women are far less likely to be given CPR a in the street than men, because people are scared of touching a female.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cly1wk02ylvo

Sadly you are absolutely correct, in the UK women are roughly 10% less likely to receive bystander CPR than men are. This is often down to fear of being accused of, or prosecuted for, inapproprita touching. Cultural differences also come into play here. One important thing to note is that, whilst the UK does not have a "Good Samaritan" law as such, there hasn't been a single case of someone saving a life, or attempting to save a life, being successfully prosecuted for inappropriate touching, in fact courts tend to take a very dim vew of the accuser, and have even ordered compensation to be paid to the accused. Incidentally, its not just CPR thats the issue here. Even if CPR is performed defibrillator pads are supposed to be attached to bare skin which means removing the bra and many men won't do that if the patient is not known to them. This is another area that needs to be addressed. There is a fantastic charity called Bra Off Defib On (BODO for short) that is doing really well at raising awereness in this area but there is still a lot more to be done.

Experts' posts:
AnotherVice · 21/04/2026 17:38

GarethCole · 21/04/2026 11:35

Its important to bear in mind that a heart attack and a cardiac arrest are very different conditions and require different intervention and treatment. In the case of a heart attack your mum would still be conscious and breathing so CPR would not be appropriate. In the case of a cardiac arrest your mum would not be conscious and would have stopped breathing, and at that point CPR would be vital. I understand your concern of her being frail and petite, but to be brutally honest if you were to break a rib or two (which is highly likely) that's still infinitely preferable to the inevitable alternative. A broken rib will heal itself, a stopped heart won't. As for something to have in the home first aid wise, a home defibrillator, such as Heart Hero, would be a good option. In cardiac arrest scenarios, seconds, not minutes, matter.

I can’t believe you’re trying to flog a home defib for hundreds of pounds to someone to use on their elderly frail mother. If you were any kind of ‘expert’ you’d know the difference between a ‘cardiac arrest’ and a natural death. Shameful to prey on someone’s anxieties like this and deprive their loved one of a dignified death.

sashh · 22/04/2026 05:16

GarethCole · 21/04/2026 11:53

What you have written here is entirely correct and doesn't need any further input from me ! Like you, I do get frustrated when people refer to cardiac arrests as heart attacks, and vice versa, but after more than a decade in this field I do understand it to a certain extent. Most people don't know the difference unless they have been directly affected by one or the other (or both) and honestly, why would they. If the media misreport it then my hackles go up !

Thank you for the kind words. I've been out of cardiology for about 25-30 years.

Confession time, I did once defib someone who was still conscious. He was in VF and the printout of the ECG showed I'd defibbed less then 30 seconds after he started fibrilating.

A fairly large dose of midazolam was administered.

Periperi2025 · 22/04/2026 12:32

sashh · 22/04/2026 05:16

Thank you for the kind words. I've been out of cardiology for about 25-30 years.

Confession time, I did once defib someone who was still conscious. He was in VF and the printout of the ECG showed I'd defibbed less then 30 seconds after he started fibrilating.

A fairly large dose of midazolam was administered.

I've seen it once and done it once. Not fully conscious but enough for them to yelp. One was pre hospital (shocked twice), one just after arrival. Both had great outcomes.

What is worth noting in this thread was that with the pre hospital arrest, was that the reason he was still in CPR induced consciousness when we got to him was due to the high quality chest compressions his niece was doing. Good bystander CPR really does make a difference! He was discharged from hospital 5 days later.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page