Please or to access all these features

SN children

Here are some suggested organisations that offer expert advice on special needs.

FLK? More like f*cking stupid GP!

95 replies

Merlot · 18/05/2005 21:36

I had such a shocking experience with my GP today that I am making a formal complaint. I know some of you who read my Insensitive GP thread here will say `you should have done this earlier', but no excuses....I just didn't feel robust enough to complain 6 months ago. Well I'm bl**dy well robust enough now and he's not getting off the hook .

Please see the letter of complaint I have written below - it is long - I warn you! It speaks for itself! It is sitting by the front door waiting to be delivered by hand tomorrow, but if there is anything anyone can suggest that I add or take out, please feel free - the better the letter the more chance I feel of making my point. So here goes....
Dear Madam

COMPLAINT ABOUT DR X

I had a consultation with Dr X this morning, regarding my son ds2, and I would like to complain, in the strongest terms possible, about the nature of that consultation.

My son ds2 has developmental delay ? he is 20 months old, but with very little expressive or receptive language skills.

Dr X asked me why I had brought ds2 along to the surgery ? I explained that I felt he was in pain of some sorts (he had had a couple of fretful nights), and that I suspected he had an ear infection, but that it was very difficult to know, because of ds2's communication problems.

? Dr X said that he could see that Matthew was developmentally delayed from the `Team Around The Child? letters in ds2's notes. He said it in a very dismissive, sarcastic and undermining way ? he gave the impression that the TATC was a complete waste of time and a very grandiose title for what it actually is. I was shocked at Dr X lack of regard for what I perceive to be a useful service and told him that, actually, I feel that the TATC is a very good idea. He seemed to show no understanding for the difficulties that are faced by parents of children with complex special needs.

? Once Dr X had established that ds2 did in fact have an ear infection (in both ears) ? I expressed my surprise at the extent of the infection and said that whilst I felt that he was on the verge of an ear infection, I hadn?t realized quite how raging it was. I couldn?t believe my ears when Dr X mumbled something along the lines of `well, its probably a case of no/little brain, no pain.? At this stage I was completely stunned. He spoke to me like a medical student not the loving mother of a very special little chap. He was completely callous.

? Dr X then went on to ask me what the experts felt was the cause of ds2's delay. I replied, that no-one really knows at this stage, but that all the relevant tests are being done and that ds2 has a paternal aunt who has learning difficulties so perhaps there might be some genetic connection. At that point Dr X asked me whether I had ever heard of the term FLK? ? a term that doctors used to use a fair bit, but which had fallen out of fashion. I said, that I don?t think I had. He went on to explain that FLK? means Funny Looking Kid? and was used when medics felt that something was not quite right, but was without diagnosis. He then went on to say that ds2 was obviously a FLK?, but that he is still rather sweet and that with any luck he might turn out as well as his aunt! At that point he handed me my prescription for ds2.

On leaving Dr X consulting room I was upset, but was in a state of shock. The full extent of what Dr X had said to me didn?t hit me until I began to drive to the Pharmacy ? I had to stop driving as I was very distressed. I decided to return to the surgery to lodge a complaint. Does this man have any understanding of what it might be like to discover that your child is not neurologically typical and how difficult it is to hold your life and the life of your family together ? apparently not!

Life is difficult enough when you have a child that doesn?t fit the normal parameters, without your GP making matters worse. I didn?t receive any words of encouragement this morning ? not that I was looking for any ? but I left the surgery emotionally fragile. Without exaggeration, if Dr X had said these words to me seven/eight months ago when I was feeling very low indeed, these words might have sent me over the edge.

If I were to be generous to Dr X ? I might describe him as having lack of insight or an atrocious bedside manner. However, this man has said thoughtless things to me before about Matthew, but I was generous with him then and I will not suffer repeatedly at the hands of this insensitive buffoon. I wonder whether Dr X has a ic streak ? for search though I might, I cannot find any justification for his talking to me the way he did this morning.

I returned to the surgery, determined that I would let my feelings known about this man (NO-ONE should have to put up with such treatment. I do not want anyone to have to deal with such cruel insensitivity again).

I feel very sorry that Dr Y had to take time out from her busy schedule to have to comfort me and apologize that I had found the consultation distressing. What a complete waste of NHS resources!

Please make it known that I do not wish to be seen by Dr X again, nor will I have him treat my children again. He has strated qualities today that I find abhorrent in a GP ? he is unfeeling and callous.

I have not had an opportunity to discuss this matter with my husband, so I cannot speak for him, but we may well want to take this complaint further when we have a chance to talk about it.

I look forward to hearing from you about what action you propose to take.

Yours sincerely

Merlot

If you have got to the end of all that - thank you!!

I was a gibbering wreck this morning, but I feel so much better for having gone and complained and for having written this letter. We have since decided to also take the complaint higher.

Lou33 - Is your local surgery at Milford? and is your health visitor B (she is a real sweetie) and if by swapping surgeries I would also get access to her, it would be worth it alone

OP posts:
JakB · 19/05/2005 18:29

Can only reiterate what has been said here. Brilliant letter.
Do you know, my 'specialist' health visitor said that DD wasn't a 'FLK' and so probably wouldn't get a diagnosis on her first visit

Merlot · 19/05/2005 18:35

Thanks for all your kind words and support

The letter has been tweaked to accomodate all your helpful suggestions and delivered by hand this afternoon.

Just got to wait for the sh*t to hit the fan now!

I will keep you all posted

Was even more incensed this morning when I woke up and looked at my beautiful little boy - how dare he make such degrading remarks about him

OP posts:
tamum · 19/05/2005 18:40

Merlot, I have nothing to say that hasn't already been said very eloquently by others. But really, what an abolute bastard. Go on you for writing the letter.

emmatmg · 19/05/2005 18:51

I am utterly stunned.

Hausfrau · 19/05/2005 19:18

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

hunkermunker · 19/05/2005 19:19

Merlot, his behaviour says a great deal more about him than it does about your beautiful DS (as I know you know) - looking forward to hearing very positive updates about terrible things happening to the ignorant tosser.

batters · 19/05/2005 21:02

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Socci · 19/05/2005 21:05

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

strugstu · 19/05/2005 21:33

This is horrifying. i have worked in the nhs for over 20 yrs (10 yrs on a paediatric unit) and i have never heard the term 'FLK' ever used. hopefully this happens rarely. i'm glad to hear u r complaining its important that this GP is dealt with .

(have just read Tony Parsons 'Family Way' and the term was used in that book -it is the first time i have ever come across it)

connorsmum · 19/05/2005 22:44

OMG Merlot, I am sooooo sorry that you had to go through that. My jaw also hit the floor when I read what he said, what a dispicable man. I really hope that he gets what's coming to him. Well done for complaining!

(((BIG HUGS))) to you and your ds.

Merlot · 19/05/2005 22:57

Thanks again guys

I have just come in from a meet up with my friends and after hearing my tale about this pratt, I think half the village are going to boycott him - dont know how the surgery will cope if everyone refuses to be seen by him.

OP posts:
rickman · 19/05/2005 23:03

Message withdrawn

hi5 · 20/05/2005 00:10

What a tw....qwack. Having left my insensitive doctors in tears last week, I can completely support your actions - you didn't go there to be made to feel terrible,how could he possibly think it was appropriate to say such things to you?
How much damage is he causing to other patients too?
Glad to hear that others in your surgery are standing by you - as all mumsnetters surely are.
Be strong, continue this for those without the courage to stand up against such abuse of positon.

Salmonick · 20/05/2005 00:22
  • I'm lost for words - definitely take your complains as high as you can take them no-one deserves to be treated like that!
milge · 20/05/2005 00:23

Perhaps also copy the letter in to your local Community Health Council - they seem to like to know what is going on locally, as well as the local NHS trust. Would be horribly tempted myself to copy it to the GMC too, just to be sure.

Davros · 20/05/2005 09:16

Another thing Merlot, you should definitely copy your local Councillors, its amazing what they can do on local issues (if they want!). Imo much better than MP and I'd keep Press for later on if necessary.

Merlot · 20/05/2005 15:45

Great ideas guys

I delivered the letter by hand yesterday evening and I still haven't heard anything....what do you think will happen next?...

Will they ring me or just write?

OP posts:
Hausfrau · 21/05/2005 12:59

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Merlot · 21/05/2005 17:31

Heard this morning Hausfrau

It was a standard letter, but it outlines the complaints procedure. Apparently I should be invited to a meeting at the surgery within the next 20 days.

OP posts:
hoxtonchick · 21/05/2005 17:54

awful. i would definitely send a copy to the primary care trust & the gmc.

Merlot · 24/06/2005 20:50

For those of you who followed this thread, provided invaluable support and made really useful suggestions, here's an update:- Sorry, its a bit long.

I have had this letter of apology from the GP in question.

I have decided that I am going to have a face to face meeting with him now, as I think he needs to be confronted. I suspect, from his letter, that people probably complain about him and then refuse to see him.

I would appreciate any comments you have on his letter - and ideas that I could use in my meeting with him (I will of course have either dh or someone else with me - I might not be responsible for my actions otherwise!)

Here it is:-

Dear (Merlot)

I have just read your letter to our practice manager, and I would like to apologise to you and your son for the distress I have clearly caused you. I regret to say that since I entered General Practice in 1975 (he doesn't mention that he only came back as a GP two years ago, so he's not actually been practicing since 1975) I have from time to time upset patients quite without noticing that I have, and certainly without intending to. On each occasion (when I have discovered what has happened) I try to find out where I went wrong and to learn how to avoid repeating the mistake. I shall attempt to do the same in your case. I shall not discuss each of your points in turn, as I don't want to appear to be arguing withyou, let me simply say that I was trying to do my best for you both. Clearly I failed. I shall take note of your criticisms and try not to repeat my mistakes. If you wish me to answer any of them in detail I am happy to do so, but I guess you would not be interested. Please let me know if I am wrong. I must say that at the end of the consultation I had no inkling of your distress, and that, if I had, I would have tried to repair the damage there and then. I am very sorry.

I try to be cheerful and optimistic with all my patients; that is my nature. Usually (I hope) this is interpreted as a gesture of kindness and support, though occasionally it comes over as insensitivity. I fear this has been the case here, and I am dreadfully sorry for it. I have no wish to be cruel, although I have clearly had that affect on you. I hope that your ds is recovered from his ear infection, and that you will recover from my unintended unkindness. Please let me know if there is anything further which I can do to make amends.

Yours sincerely

Dr X

OP posts:
lou33 · 24/06/2005 20:55

That's good he wrote you a letter apologising merlot. Have you decided to stay with the surgery or not?

coppertop · 24/06/2005 20:57

It sounds to me as though he's trying to fob you off with his "I guess you wouldn't be interested..." line. I'm probably a cynical old cow too but I suspect the reference to becoming a GP in 1975 was a veiled way of saying "I've been in this job a long time and therefore know what I'm doing." It's probably why most people don't take it further.

I think I would just take along a list of your points/ a copy of the original letter you sent and make him go through each one.

Good luck.

heartinthecountry · 24/06/2005 20:59

Though I hate to say it Merlot i think you should have a face to face meeting with him. He clearly doesn't really know what it is he said wrong (fear that he may never get it) and I also think the letter is written in a slighty manipulative way to encourage you NOT to take it further.

BUT definitely make sure you have someone else with you and if possible the practice manager.

Well done you for not just letting it pass....

lou33 · 24/06/2005 21:01

yes, meant to add , you should definitely see him face to face, and get him to address the specific points you have.

(sorry had to cut off early cos of kid squabbles)