Sorry for the delay in coming back to you all. I've been knocked off my feet with this bug 😞. I'm really grateful for all of the messages. They've given us loads to think about.
Agnes- Thank you so much for writing such a detailed message. I have been reading lots about ABA, but it's very new to me so I found your post really helpful. We are keen to explore all options, so finding out more about the various approaches is exactly what we need (and we will also look into ABA behaviour consultants).
Truth be told, I have always been a bit nervous of rewards. Not in an ideological way (as you say, we all use some kind of reward with our kids, often without even knowing it), but because I have envisaged my son getting fixed about the reward itself and that opening up a whole other can of (rigid routine) worms. I also worried that he may not be motivated to do things other than when we offered a treat! I realise, though, from what I've read and from reading your posts that the approach is a lot more nuanced than that. I'm going to find out more and keep reading up as despite being hugely encouraged by the progress you have made in dealing with these rituals (your son sounds very similar to mine, who is also very ritualistic!), I'm not sure I have the confidence to try an ABA style approach myself yet. (I'm worried that I'll inadvertently approach it in the wrong way and do exactly the things I've noted above!). I will have a good think about the steps you have outlined and I also need to give thought to what would be really motivating treats for my son. Ultimately, we have to work out what is the best thing for our boy, so we are not wedded to one approach or another and we are trying to find out what that may be.
You made a great point about praising him for good walking or behaviour in the car while it's happening. Often, I'm so tense during a journey about an ensuing meltdown that I forget to praise him for the parts where it is going ok. Practising little journeys and getting into the car also makes so much sense rather than waiting till I'm actually on route somewhere and needing it to work out.
It is so encouraging that you were able to make headway with the fixed rituals. It really has been debilitating having to face such huge battles about journeys.
I know there was some concern (which I'm grateful for) that I would interpret your advice as suggesting that I had to make my son go into nursery even if he hated it. I didn't read it that way and I would never force him to do something that was making him miserable like that. As you picked up, he actually loved the nursery on the two days that I managed to get him inside. Journeys are the problem, and would equally problematic with another nursery.
Some of your alternatives for dealing with the journey obsession sound great (Google Earth etc). Unfortunately, as we've been tv and screen free for a long while now (as they were also a cause of huge meltdowns when they were turned off), I don't think they would work for my son, at least not quite yet.
I am definitely going to get the buggy-I'll need to keep both my son and the baby safe and to make life easier for all of us so it makes sense, at least until things (hopefully!) improve.
Knitting- I completely agree that it would be futile (and cruel) to force my son to do something that he hated, and we would never be happy to use any approach that required us to do that. (Not that you've said this, but it's not about control for us. We have a very headstrong little boy and we love that about him. We don't expect him to do what we want or say all the time, save for non negotiable safety issues (and even if we did it would never happen with his personality!). We just need to make all of our lives a bit more manageable.
I'm not so wedded to the idea of nursery that I would put him through the ringer over it. It was to give him some more time with little friends, as he loves playing with other kids. It's been the two of us at home together for the last 3 years and this is the first time he's been to nursery so we are really keen to go easy with him (so much so that we made clear to the nursery that we didn't intend to leave him on the settle sessions till we were 100% sure that he'd be ok and they were fine with this). As it was, he loved it when he was there. For us, the issue is not just how to get him to nursery (which ultimately we could leave if it was just not working), but how to manage any journey as they have all been a battle. Of course, some trips just have to be done (to see the doctor etc) which is why I've been so desperate find a way through it. ABA is something that I don't know a great deal about but I'm investigating everything in the hope that I'll be as informed as possible re the referral. Like everyone has said, flexibility in our approach is key.
My DH has been holding the fort while I've been unwell and has been practising the 'social story' on journeys. He tells me that it really does seem to be helping, which is fantastic. While we thought we had been doing this already, your post made us realise that we have to break it down much, much more than we have been, and really amp up the picture of what was to come. Thank you!
Tamara - thanks very much for your suggestions, especially the Dr Weil website (some great stuff in there). We will definitely make sure that we don't limit ourselves to seeking help from just the speech therapist as we need to get to the bottom of whatever else is going on. (You mentioned that we should look at his interaction with other kids. He is very sociable and has some friends that he sees regularly. Apart from being a good bit behind them in speech and a much busier, rowdier baby - he's not one for sitting down/still and never has been, apart from when he's reading which he loves)- it's hard to see too much difference (for us at least). He's very gentle with them, has never hit any of his friends and basically just wants to have a laugh and play with them). That said, I've had a fair few play dates desperately trying to encourage him to go to the place where we're supposed to be meeting or playing (soft play, friend's house, park etc) and because of his rigidity it has been a horrible battle to get him in there (even when he can see his friends).
MeirAya - I guess I used a kind of 'dog training' route for teaching my son to hold hands. When he first started walking outside on the pavement, literally every time he stopped holiday hands or tried to wriggle away it was straight back in the pram even if we'd only walked a few steps. (I was motivated by fear! He's always been fast and is very stubborn so I knew he'd be a bolter!). So I agree that 'dog training' can have its place.
Poulter - Can I ask how you used backward chaining? Sounds like it was a hit for you. I very much agree that no one approach is set in stone and these are all tools.
Thanks again to everyone. Your time and suggestions have been hugely appreciated 💐