Please or to access all these features

SEN

Here you'll find advice from parents and teachers on special needs education.

DS is newly diagnosed with SN am I kidding myself in wishing professionals wouldn't keep talking about "these children"?

6 replies

deaconblue · 10/03/2010 17:34

He has some aspergers traits and sensory processing disorder but I am constantly irritated by references to "these children" as in "these children struggle with reading comprehension" which I heard today - actually this child doesn't. grrrrrr. Do I just have to get used to it or is it worth making the point that I'd like to discuss my child rather than an assumption about a child with his symptoms?

OP posts:
MaryBS · 10/03/2010 22:16

I would say something, maybe "these children? AFAIK, I only have one - are you seeing double?". My DS has AS, but have never had anyone say "these children" to me. I have heard some stupendously ignorant assumptions made though. But "these people" are NOT going to know any better unless they are told!

deaconblue · 11/03/2010 14:28

thanks, you made me smile with that. Is really frustrating as it seems as soon as a diagnosis has been made people are making assumptions about what he will be unable to do - I'm determined that we work towards him being able to do everything any other person may be able to do.

OP posts:
MaryBS · 11/03/2010 16:23

Good, glad I made you laugh!

I get that too, people make assumptions. What's even more weird is that I was recently diagnosed myself, and firstly people tell me their assumptions and then I floor them by telling them I have it too. THEN you get the people who have known me for years, and only NOW see problems in my behaviour, and think I can't do things I've been doing for years.

Definitely work towards doing things - I had to do it the hard way, but that now means I cope a lot better than I did as a child.

Do you know the story of the frogs and the tower?

There once was a bunch of tiny frogs...

... who arranged a running competition. The goal was to reach the top of a very high tower. A big crowd had gathered around the tower to see the race and cheer on the contestants...

The race began...

Honestly, no-one in crowd really believed that the tiny frogs would reach the top of the tower. You heard statements such as:

"Oh, WAY too difficult!!"

"They will NEVER make it to the top".

"Not a chance that they will succeed. The tower is too high!"

The tiny frogs began collapsing. One by one...

... Except for those who in a fresh tempo were climbing higher and higher...

The crowd continued to yell

"It is too difficult!!! No one will make it!"

More tiny frogs got tired and gave up...

...But ONE continued higher and higher and higher...

This one wouldn't give up!

At the end, everyone else had given up climbing the tower. Except for the one tiny frog who, after a big effort, was the only one who reached the top!

THEN all of the other tiny frogs naturally wanted to know how this one frog managed to do it?

A contestant asked the tiny frog how the one who succeeded had found the strength to reach the goal?

It turned out...

That the winner was deaf.

Marne · 11/03/2010 16:32

Yes, i also hate it when people say 'these children' .

And they should get there facts right, dd1 (6) has Aspergers and is years ahead with reading and writing. Any child can have problems with reading and writing (not just children with ASD's).

deaconblue · 12/03/2010 07:33

MaryBS, I LOVE that story! will save it and keep it for when ds is a bit older
Your story is fascinating, I really hope that an early diagnosis for ds should mean he doesn't have the struggle his dad had as a boy(dh is pretty sure he has some aspergers traits himself although hasn't gone along the route towards diagnosis).

OP posts:
Goblinchild · 12/03/2010 07:56

One of the problems with saying 'These children,' especially with children on the spectrum, is that the speaker often tends to generalise about them in a one-size-fits-all sort of way.
So if, as we all do, you have a unique child, you have to batter through all the misconceptions and errors that 'the professionals' have about them.
For example, my Aspie is rubbish on the computer.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page