I've always taken a softly softly approach and until a month ago was co-sleeping with my DD when she woke in the night. Laying with her to go to sleep and joining her in her bed when she woke.
This stopped working for us. She was getting harder and harder to settle, sometimes it'd take me an hour to get her to sleep despite her being exhausted and during the night I was awake more than asleep with her fidgetting and sleeping litterally underneath me.
I'm also preg with DC2 so I'm exhausted and need some zzzzz's so we embarked on a tough course of action and put her to bed with the normal routine and leaving the room rather than laying with her. Everytime she got out of bed would pick her up and lay her back down with minimal fuss. Obviously she was devastated at being left and I'm not enjoying the tears either but i thought it'd get better. Immediately she started sleeping through however it's the going to bed thing I'm still struggling with.
Almost 4 weeks later it's still not great. We've had a couple of nights where she's gone to sleep without a whimper but most nights we have tears ranging from a minute or two of protest to a full on screaming fit that might last half an hour or more and require us to go in repeatedly. Last night she was hysterical. She knows we're outside the door and she can get in and out of bed so it's not like she thinks she's been abandoned.
I'm loathed to go back to where we were but I don't like her going to sleep so upset. Any advice? I tried a sticker chart which has some success but not when she's that upset.