Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Sleep

Join our Sleep forum for tips on creating a sleep routine for your baby or toddler. Need more advice on your childs development? Sign up to our Ages and Stages newsletter here.

No cry sleep solution - has this worked for anyone??

18 replies

mamachat · 04/07/2008 22:18

I have just started reading this book, I really like this method more than cry it out or PU/PD.

Has this worked for anyone, opinions needed please...

OP posts:
ARAG · 04/07/2008 22:28

How funny that you posted this... I just bought the book today and will start tomorrow. I am praying it works for mt 5 month old who will not nap. Good luck to you!

Habbibu · 04/07/2008 22:30

Didn't buy the book, but browsed it A Lot and liked the principle, esp having stages, and being able to go back one if you have a blip. We've done a sort of homemade version, and it has worked well for us. Sometimes it's just good to have a plan to stick to - gives you confidence, which transmits to the baby.

S1ur · 04/07/2008 22:30

Sorry didn't work well for me but goodness my first was/is a nightmare sleeper!

Bits of it worked though, the not feeding to sleep just not the no more cosleeping element or the getting to sleep alone bit.

I think it would've worked for my second if I had time and energy to do it without interuption from dc1

giddykipper · 04/07/2008 22:32

Yes, the principle of gradual withdrawal definitely worked. I can now leave DS happily awake in his cot and he falls asleep when he's ready. Really the book is about finding the method that works best for you and baby.

mamachat · 04/07/2008 23:15

Arag - Thanks good luck to you too, it would be great if we could keep each other posted for support...

OP posts:
mamachat · 04/07/2008 23:15

Thank you all fo the replies

OP posts:
mamachat · 05/07/2008 22:44

Anyone else tried this

OP posts:
Shoegazer · 05/07/2008 22:48

We tried it, it worked alittle bit but never managed to get outside the door. After 12 months we resorted to a mixture of gradual withdrawal and crying it out abit. However our DD is now 2 and she still cries to wind down to sleep - its just that now she is 2, when you go to her when she is doing this she can say "Go away mummy, I go bed" so I guess its just her way of doing things.

cmotdibbler · 05/07/2008 22:50

Worked really well for us, and continues to

downbutnotout · 05/07/2008 22:57

I sort of did it but without realising that I was... From about seven months onwards I would feed dd till she was nearly asleep then take her off the nipple and put her into the cot. If she fussed, I would put her back on for a couple of minutes and try again. Little by little I took her off the nipple when she was less and less drowsy and she gradually accepted it and just went to sleep in her cot. By 14 months she went to sleep on her own with just a drink of cow's milk and a good night kiss. She was a fantastic sleeper until she was three (but that's another story!)

mamachat · 06/07/2008 00:20

well dd is one now and still not sleeping throgh the night, i manged to get her to sleep at 7.30 tonight and she didn't wake up untill 11, which is good for her as usually would have been up 1 1/2 to 2 hours after being out to bed...

OP posts:
onebatmother · 06/07/2008 00:37

It did, but we did end up doing a bit of leaving to cry when she started going backwards.

susiemj · 06/07/2008 13:14

Mamachat - How are you getting on with it? I've just started with it - am on the 5th day of the first '10 day log'. First two nights were bliss - she went to sleep in moments and only woke up twice. Now she's wise to it and fighting it. Some positive signs though. She woke up at four and did go back to sleep. She did also settle in her cot after a while last night and she was a teeny bit awake Having said that she woke at 1, 2 and 5 wanting feeds. I'm thinking, two steps forward one step back. I'd be interested to know how it's going for you.

phraedd · 06/07/2008 19:27

I work as a night nanny and a doula and have read several books on sleeping (as well as parenting ones)

My children were (and are) great sleepers but i have to say that if they hadn't have been, then this is the book that i would have tried first.

It has lots of gentle ways to get your baby sleeping through the night.

Controlled crying may have a place with some families but only if kinder methods have been tried first (IMO)

ARAG · 06/07/2008 22:09

Just finished reading the book and we're picking our solutions from her 'menu' of options now. Nice approach.

I must admit that I very much appreciate her encouraging tone and emphasis on each mum/family finding her/its own way. That's nice, especially after having had a problem with interfering in-laws.

mamachat · 07/07/2008 18:59

susiemj - i have not started the methods yet really but have started getting her to bed earlier as have taken more note of her tired signs...

I have not even finished reading the book as have had alot on, but I do really like the methods I have read so far and I am very hopeful...

OP posts:
susiemj · 08/07/2008 18:28

ARAG - I've had so many 'just leave her to cry' comments, you wouldn't believe it! Unfortunately, I remember being left to cry and I didn't like it one bit!

lou031205 · 08/07/2008 18:41

Ok, this was my desperate post on 20th June:

"I had DD 1 month early, and she has/had reflux. She slept through the night from 3 weeks old, up to 14 hrs, which was amazing. Then she started to wake for feeds. At 4.5 months she suddenly got scared of her crib, and wouldn't be put in it at all. She came in bed with us. At 8 months we bought a bedside cot, which has helped.

She won't go to bed in the evening. If I do try, she will only BF to sleep, then I have to slip away. She wakes within 30-40 minutes. If I try and settle her, she will only settle by feeding again, then the process is repeated.

She will feed to sleep on me in the lounge, and stirs regularly to 'plug herself in'.

When I go to bed, I feed her to sleep, and her night wakings are getting worse and worse. Between 11pm when I go to bed, and 7am, she wakes 4-8 times. Each time she will only settle with a feed.

In the day she will go for a nap if fed to sleep, and it lasts anywhere from 20mins to 1.5 hours. Sometimes she will wake after 20 mins, but then fall asleep on me feeding straight after.

The 16 hour day followed by waking every 1-2 hours in the night is slowly draining me of life! I can't imagine it is doing much for Jasmine, either. She wakes up distraught sometimes. She can be very fractious with others, because she is tired and wants my breast for comfort!

Please help! I did have a stab at PU/PD and easy when she was 8 months, but obviously did something wrong."

Since then, I had no improvement until last week. 7 nights ago I decided that after I was sure she was not hungry i.e. had already fed alot that night, I would say no to a BF, but give a big big cuddle. I made sure that my duvet was over my breasts. She wasn't keen on that idea, but everytime she tried to nestle in I said "Oh, thankyou, a lovely cuddle.

Then 2 nights later, I stopped feeding her in the night altogether. She feeds until 8-9pm, as she still won't go down in the evening (YET), but then when she falls asleep on me, I don't feed her again that night. Even when she wakes before taking her up to bed.

She accepted it really well, and last night even accepted a simple rub on the back at 02.30 rather than a big cuddle.

My hope is that she will gradually need less and less input to settle.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page