Hi all,
I wish I had had the wherewithal to know about/use this site when I was going through all the early stages on this - I thought I was the only one and it was something I was going wrong (not helped by the fact that this was more or less what doctors etc. were telling me as well).
I also thought that the idea of CC for ANy bay, let alone a reflux baby was harsh and I was very anti. My HV had suggested it to us as well. A couple of things I would say on this:
There is a continuum here. From leaving the to 'grizzle' for a few minutes, through to putting them at the bottom of the garden! Even a few minutes is, techncially, letting them cry and giving them the chance to fall asleep withut other props.
From my own practical (and hard) experience I know that even leaving DS to cry for a couple of minutes in the early days was absolutely more than I could bear, but I also know that giving him the chance to learn how to settle himself was, in the end, one of the best things we did for him (and, no, I never did leave him at the bottom of the garden!).
There is a huge difference between a reflux cry of pain and an, "oh bugger, I'm awake and I don't want to be" cry. Age does, of course, play a huge part in this as well (though DS was younger than is generally advocated, even where CC is proposed at all)but so does your own instinct of when to wait outside the room for a few minutes and when to scoop him up at the speed of light.
I don't want this to be contraversial at all - I just want to help by putting down my own experience. I know there are many who would villify what we did on principle and I normally stay away from any discussion on the matter because I don't want to offend or upset anyone. I would also have been one of those people who was horrified by the idea. However, I also know that, in our case, dealing with the pain was the first step but then we were not out of the woods in terms of the sleep problems with which he was left - and from which he was suffering horribly. None of us could cope any more. It was a last resort - and only really a step up from letting him grizzle. But yes, I did find it incredibly hard and it did make me feel when I started that I was a failure as a mother (felt that anyway with the PND ).
Long post. Just wanted to explain myself a bit. Bellabear, I'm still happy to e-mail you privately with details of the sleep trainer if you are interested -even for future reference. I do absolutely agree though that controlling the pain is at the root of the issue - everythng elae is dealing with the aftermath.
As for the PND (which we have not really talked to you much about). That also gets better I promise - for me it was like a dense black cloud gradually fading and lifting. Took time, but you do get to feel human again - you just need help, support and as many hugs as you can get. Keep talking it through -even the bleak thoughts. You are not alone in them and you are a great mum who WILL feel joy again.