Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Sleep

Join our Sleep forum for tips on creating a sleep routine for your baby or toddler. Need more advice on your childs development? Sign up to our Ages and Stages newsletter here.

Am I setting myself up for problems? Conflicting advice from HV

34 replies

cogitosum · 12/10/2013 08:24

HV suggests all naps should be lying in crib/Moses basket in dark silent room and babies under a year should go down for the night at 6pm alone in their room.

I'm quite happy with my ds's sleep at the moment. He's 11 weeks and breastfed. He has around 4 naps a day mostly in the sling but sometimes if I'm tired we'll go to bed together in the afternoon. He goes into his crib at night (it's a co-sleeper) when I go to bed (normally around 10pm) and on a good night will go til 5am for a feed (maybe waking once in between but easy to settle with a dummy). once he wakes at 5 he'll be really restless til we get up at 7.30. He'll sleep but keep waking and feed on and off so I usually keep him in bed and don't properly sleep just snooze.

I'm really happy with this bit now worried that he's going to bed too late and I'm setting myself up for problems later. Also that he'll only settle in the sling at daytime.

However I'm not sure I agree with HV (but she's the expert) but didn't want to argue or disagree so thought I'd ask here instead!

Firstly how does this advice work with SIDS guidelines about the baby sleeping in the same room as you including for daytime naps. Is this just me being over anxious or should she not be advising to disregard this? (which she basically did).

Secondly If I put him to bed at 6 this would mean the bulk of his long sleep would be when I'm awake which seems a waste! But I'm worried I'm setting myself up for problems later down the line with this.

Thirdly I'd heard somewhere ( I'm not sure where) that it's better to keep noise and light as normal during the day so they learn that daytime is for short naps and nighttime is for bed and long sleep. This works for me as it's very handy to have him in the sling and get on with my day!

I know it's likely to change anyway at 4 months sleep regression but I'm happy at the moment so is it worth trying to implement HV advice? I think I'd be too scared to leave him in a room alone so this would mean me lying in the dark with him Confused

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
neversleepagain · 12/10/2013 13:26

You are tied to the house a lot when you have twins :)

cogitosum · 12/10/2013 13:36

Neversleepagain I can understand that. The thing is with ds is that he does sleep deeply in the sling and will sleep for 1.5 hours or so whereas in the crib, pram, Moses basket etc he'll only sleep for 20 mins or so during the day

OP posts:
neversleepagain · 12/10/2013 13:41

Every parent should do what is right for them, there is no right or wrong. A happy baby is all the matters. Enjoy your new baby :)

JakeBullet · 12/10/2013 13:44

OP I am a HV too albeit not practising at the moment. What this HV is a advocating is based upon her own opinion rather than any evidence based research.

YOU are the expert in your own child and not the HV because you know your own baby far better than she does.

What you are currently doing is working for you so carry on with it. Fwiw I could never be doing with routines as a Mum and like your DS mine was happy to carried around in a sling and to co sleep too.

By all means introduce a bedtime routine...but do it in a way which suits you and your family....it sounds like you are already doing this.

YoniBottsBumgina · 12/10/2013 13:48

I would ignore her, unless you are asking for advice then she doesn't have to share her "insight" with you anyway. It sounds like she's read a Gina Ford book (perhaps it worked for her?) and now thinks this is the One Right Way.

Unfortunately (or perhaps fortunately??) One Right Way doesn't exist. Babies are all different, parents are all different - whatever works for your family is FINE.

CoconutRing · 12/10/2013 13:55

I'm Shock at the HV commenting that your baby was too attached at 6 weeks!

Disengage and avoid this dangerous individual.

minipie · 12/10/2013 13:55

I tried to introduce a 7 pm bedtime when dd was about 8 weeks old - I so wish I hadn't and I won't be doing that with any future DC till they are much older. All it meant was endless resettling of dd during the evenings (with hindsight she kept waking as she thought it was just a naptime and wasn't ready for bedtime) and also a really unsettled period from 3/4am onwards as she'd had her long nighttime sleep far too early.

BonaDea · 12/10/2013 13:56

Sorry haven't read the whole thread but the HV is also ignoring the up to date SiDS advice which is not to leave small babies under 6 months to sleep alone, either at night or for daytime naps. I'm quite shocked at her 'advice' (and by the way not even Gina Ford recommends that!).

As for bed time I started a very loose routine with my LO at about 9 weeks I think. Bath, massage, into 'pyjamas', feed and to 'bed'. When he was tiny that was carry cot in living room and then after a few weeks into the co- sleeper cot in our bedroom. At first it would still be 8/9 before he went down but over time this has settled into a regular bed time of 6.30/7 pm by the time he was about 4 months.

Good luck. What you are doing is fine!

Clarella · 13/10/2013 10:21

evolutionaryparenting.com/proving-the-harm-in-early-sleep-training/

just to add, I think this research pretty much blows your hvs ideas out of the window too. Grin

New posts on this thread. Refresh page