Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Site stuff

Join our Innovation Panel to try new features early and help make Mumsnet better.

Legality on reproducing posts

19 replies

VictorianSqualor · 03/10/2008 10:57

Hi MNHQ.
Just a quick one, I'm sure you'll know the answer to.
Can I legally put a post someone else has made on a forum onto my blog?
It's not this forum btw, and the post would be a printscreen with the name and picture scrubbed out.

OP posts:
VictorianSqualor · 03/10/2008 15:05

bump

OP posts:
MrVibrating · 03/10/2008 17:51

I don't think MNHQ will be able to answer for a different site. Wouldn't it be better to ask the administrator of the forum, or just look at the copyright notice? Which will probably say 'no'.

Why not just post a link?

VictorianSqualor · 03/10/2008 18:14

MNHQ will know if legally someone can reproduce something from a forum.
I can't link as the posts in question are no longer there.

OP posts:
zippitippitoes · 03/10/2008 18:16

well either the site will have retained copyright over the posts like they do on here

or the writer will

MrVibrating · 03/10/2008 19:00

I am in awe at the omniscience of MNHQ regarding the asserted intellectual property rights of unidentified third parties

VictorianSqualor · 03/10/2008 19:19

They had to go through it all though didn't they? All the legalities about posts on a site, with the GF thing.

OP posts:
SaintGeorge · 03/10/2008 19:22

The legalities of who was liable, if anyone, for libel.

That isn't what you are asking, you need to know about copyright.

That will vary from forum to forum, depending on their T & Cs.

RTKangaMummy · 03/10/2008 19:23

So what about what the newspapers do when they copy our posts with out our permission?

AnarchyAunt · 03/10/2008 19:26

It says on their T&C (link at the very bottom of homepage) that they own copyright and you may not copy, publish, distribute etc.

The newspapers will get permission from MNHQ as they will hold the copyright - I guess anyway.

VictorianSqualor · 03/10/2008 19:27

So every time one of does

By AnarchyAunt on Fri 03-Oct-08 19:26:46
It says on their T&C (link at the very bottom of homepage) that they own copyright and you may not copy, publish, distribute etc.

The newspapers will get permission from MNHQ as they will hold the copyright - I guess anyway.

that
are we breaking copyright?

OP posts:
AnarchyAunt · 03/10/2008 19:30

Erm... possibly. Technically.

We could always ask That Place for permission

Or maybe not.

zippitippitoes · 03/10/2008 19:32

normally a website will hold copyright of material on the site

AnarchyAunt · 03/10/2008 19:40

I think its one of those things that nobody worries about unless they are Out To Get You iyswim? Everyone's always C&Ping stuff from other websites or forums - eg the NetMums weaning info - and its not a problem.

But it can be a big stick for the site to wave if you are using stuff in a way they don't like.

onager · 03/10/2008 20:02

I figure most places don't care unless you are duplicating their content entirely so visitors don't need to go to their site.

So if you post part of an interesting article for example with a link to go to the original place (if it still exists) most consider that fair enough.

Make sure you have a notice somewhere saying "email me here if anything breaches copyright and I will remove it" or similar

VictorianSqualor · 03/10/2008 20:21

Ah, good point onager, Hunker has that on her blog from something she copied from the NCT, I hadn't thought about that. Thanks.

OP posts:
Aero · 03/10/2008 23:08

Interesting thread - I'd like to know too as I've been quoted more than once in the last few weeks on various websites regarding dh's current work situation and in the end I felt I had to ask for my thread to be deleted due to press interest!

swampster · 03/10/2008 23:20

I think you can argue that copying a small excerpt to illustrate a point constitutes fair use, so quoting someone's post (e.g. to an online forum such as this) in an article or a blog without the copyright-holder's permission shouldn't be a problem.

VictorianSqualor · 03/10/2008 23:28

That's basically what I want to do swampster.
My blog is about weaning, a certain forum has tons of posters weaning at anything from 2 weeks. I want to reproduce some of their posts on my blog to show how early some people are weaning and the arguments they are using.

OP posts:
swampster · 03/10/2008 23:38

Copyright Law: Understanding Fair Use - any help?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page