Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Political threads, bullying and echo chambers

1 reply

TenLittleSweetWrappers · 19/11/2025 18:23

I just wanted to clarify Mumsnet’s stance on this as it seems really ‘off’.

I’m a long time poster and not aware that I’ve had posts deleted before or done anything controversial.
A political thread came up in my feed so sort of ‘advertised’ to me by Mumsnet. So I had a look.
Lots of posters are on this political thread who know each other well and have similar political leanings. That’s fine, but there were posts supporting anti-immigration and pro posting flags on roundabouts. So I felt a need to challenge as I don’t share that political stance,

Cue the group of long time posters to jump on me, accuse me of goading, derailing, telling each other to ignore me, referring to me as an ‘it’ - or ‘crying to Mumsnet’ when I ask for clarification - and - as a group encouraging each other to post rock gifs each time I post. Any perceived ‘goading’ or ‘derailment’ by me was minuscule compared to the onslaught of animosity from the bullying group.

Mumsnet told me to stay off the thread and to discuss my political thoughts elsewhere.

I’m sorry, but I’ve never come across this on Mumsnet before? I thought threads were public and all are free to post?
It felt like echo chamber, and rather than address the bullying, gang-like behaviour - Mumsnet seems to be accepting it.

I won’t be posting on the thread anymore. But I’m really disappointed that Mumsnet doesn’t moderate these threads fairly or adds them to my feed when I’m not actually welcome to post there at all and they are only for people of a particular political persuasion.

BeckyAMumsnet · 20/11/2025 12:35

Hi OP. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

Just to clarify - on Mumsnet, threads are public and all users are welcome to contribute but everyone is expected to follow our guidelines.

When we suggested discussing your political thoughts elsewhere, it wasn’t to exclude you, it was because continuing on that thread in the way you were had become more about escalation than debate.

We also want to be clear that our moderation applies to everyone equally. We ask that all members, new or long-standing, follow the same rules and we do act when posts cross the line. Repeatedly returning to challenge others, or using new usernames to continue an argument, doesn’t change the guidance.

Mumsnet works best when everyone contributes constructively, and we do sometimes encourage reflection on whether posting is serving that purpose.

Watch this thread for updates

Tap "Watch" to get all the latest updates

End of posts

There are no more MNHQ posts on this thread