Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Mute user button?

1 reply

ifIwerenotanandroid · 22/07/2025 19:23

It would be very useful to have a 'mute user' button covering either one thread or everything on MN.

It may be that there's a poster you just can't stand, for whatever personal reason; or a poster may display troll-like tendencies which can't be called out, under MN rules, & may not be sufficient for MN to delete their posts - or there may just be a time lag in MN dealing with them. In these cases, a 'mute user' button would be invaluable.

It would be even more useful if the muting applied to all usernames associated with that user, so that name changes don't mean having to see their posts.

On twitter/X, I use the block button in this way, to shut out people I don't want to hear from - on there, I can always choose to look at a post by someone I've blocked & sometimes I do. So that facility would be useful, too.

HebeMumsnet · 23/07/2025 11:41

Hi there @ifIwerenotanandroid. Thanks for getting in touch with this idea.

As @ErrolTheDragon mentioned, it is something that's been discussed previously and, for several reasons, we've always felt that it wouldn't work. Mainly for reasons of Swiss cheese, as mentioned here, but also that it just feels a bit 'against the spirit of conversation' if people can create their own 'echo chambers' here by excluding the thoughts of posters they disagree with. One of the great things about Mumsnet (if we do say so ourselves) is that we are an open forum where anyone can share their views within reaason and as long as they do so politely, and we think that's a great thing. Sometimes people might change their minds about something as a result of seeing another viewpoint; sometimes they may not but it still broadens the conversation.

We see what you're saying about trolls that aren't exactly trolls, and we know that can feel annoying, but again, if they aren't breaking Talk guidelines enough to be deleted or banned, it feels a bit wrong that they can be excluded somehow? Added to which, there is always the opportunity to scroll by and ignore if you've reported and we've found there's no breach of guidelines.

So, that was or thinking in the past when this has come up. We will pass your thoughts upwards though. We're always happy to have another think and revisit ideas like this.

Watch this thread for updates

Tap "Watch" to get all the latest updates

End of posts

There are no more MNHQ posts on this thread