Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

MNHQ, please can feminist petitions stay in the feminism section

2 replies

wigglybluelines · 22/07/2019 19:36

The majority view on the feminist board is that we like petitions! We don't want feminist petitions shunted off to the petitions board.

Feminism is about political activism and it feels appropriate for feminist petitions to live there.

Very few posters knew the petitions board even existed.

This post from MoleSmokes sums it up perfectly IMO:

Petitions here: YES
Do I object to petitions here: NO

Another one who had no idea there was a "Petitions Board".

Obviously, only relevant Petitions. If something is not relevant to Feminism/Women's Rights (the URL is actually "womens_rights") then someone is sure to report it.

Posting a Petition often leads to discussion about the issue - which can be helpful if someone is unsure about whether or not to sign. Those discussions are not going to take place if the Petition is shunted off to what sounds like a Zombie Zone going by previous comments.

A Petition can be relevant to an existing discussion. It makes no sense at all to make a new post on the Petitions Board and then link to it in the Discussion here, assuming that in itself is even allowed. So, also allow linking to Petitions that are relevant to an existing discussion.

If people spam links to Petitions, they will get reported.

What other Boards want is up to regular posters and Mumsnet. I don't see how what we might want to happen here conflicts in any way with practice on other Boards.

How about it MNHQ? Please can we keep feminist petitions in FWR?

LilyMumsnet · 22/07/2019 20:18

Hi folks,

We do understand where you're coming from with this - lots of other boards want similar with regards to being able to post petitions.

The issue is, all petitions are important and worthy to the poster/topic. We have a separate section because if we didn't, the main boards would be overrun.

Unfortunately if were to allow FWR to post petitions, albeit, relevant and topical ones, we'd have to do the same elsewhere and there are many boards where we've concerns users wouldn't know when to stop.

We have no plans to change things at the moment but as ever, we'll bear this in mind (and we could give some thought to promoting the petitions topic).

LilyMumsnet · 28/07/2019 09:48

[quote ErrolTheDragon ] We do understand where you're coming from with this - lots of other boards want similar with regards to being able to post petitions.

Probably because the current model simply doesn't work well. The petitions board is not at all obvious, even people who know it exists forget its there or how to find it. It's not easily 'discoverable', a concept which should be familiar to your UI designers.[/quote]

We'll have a chat in the office about ways that we can attract more attention to this topic.

Watch this thread for updates

Tap "Watch" to get all the latest updates

End of posts

There are no more MNHQ posts on this thread